7 ms·
Genetic variants for male bisexuality, risk-taking linked to more children
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- mjfl 3y agodata mining. So much scientific pollution these days.
- extasia 3y agoWhy is this scientific pollution? Seems like a valid research question to me.
- mjfl 3y agoit's data mining.
- jncfhnb 3y agoCare to elaborate on why you believe this
- aaron695 3y ago[dead]
- harimau777 3y agoIt's not clear to me what you mean by data mining and why you believe that it is problematic in this context.
- zmix 3y agoThe research implies, that bi-sexuality is based on genes, rather than psychological development. Did I miss something?
- cplusplusfellow 3y agothe basis of the civil rights movement and the LGB community is that these characteristics are immutable on the basis of genetics.
- jncfhnb 3y agoImmutable. Not immutable derived from genetics.
- i8comments 3y agoAlthough immutability is the basis for the LGBT+ political movements, it is known that in some cases sexual orientation fluctuates over time or even flips either way by itself, although there is no known and reliable way to force such changes at will.
- jncfhnb 3y agoShrug
- xpl 3y agoI actually never understood why it has to be immutable (in the context of civil rights). IMO, it's a red herring. Because if it was about free will, then people would still need the right to choose what they want to be — and that needs to be respected if it harms no one. So, genetics or not, that just shouldn't matter?
- worklaptopacct 3y agoAs I see it, this is to point out that attempts to change sexual orientation are doomed to be unsuccessful - and these are, in most cases, either forced or caused by peer pressure. I personally haven't heard of any case of a person doing a full 180 degrees from gay to straight who would not be motivated by religion.
- extasia 3y agohttps://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/sciadv.adj6958 https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/sciadv.adj6958 >Because human same-sex sexual behavior (SSB) is heritable and leads to fewer offspring, how SSB-associated alleles have persisted and whether they will remain in human populations are of interest. Using the UK Biobank, we address these questions separately for bisexual behavior (BSB) and exclusive SSB (eSSB) after confirming their genetic distinction. We discover that male BSB is genetically positively correlated with the number of offspring. This unexpected phenomenon is attributable to the horizontal pleiotropy of male risk-taking behavior–associated alleles because male risk-taking behavior is genetically positively correlated with both BSB and the number of offspring and because genetically controlling male risk-taking behavior abolishes the genetic correlation between male BSB and the number of offspring. By contrast, eSSB is genetically negatively correlated with the number of offspring. Our results suggest that male BSB–associated alleles are likely reproductively advantageous, which may explain their past persistence and predict their future maintenance, and that eSSB-associated alleles are likely reproductively advantageous, which may explain their past persistence and predict their future maintenance, and that eSSB-associated alleles are likely being selected against at present.
- bsder 3y agoI thought this was already known? The replication is appreciated though. The fact that eSSB hasn't been genetically removed means that it is somehow not disadvantageous. All of the "explanations" seem to point to older mothers benefiting from a male child who is willing to take care of children other than their own.
- dsign 3y agoThe capability of "being social" is so important that crows play social games, and their brains are not much bigger than an eyedropper. Homosexuality and polygamy are present in all the species where being social is not just a state machine orchestrated by pheromones (i.e., ants). It is as if Mother Nature would use all the tools in its arsenal to clump together individuals with enough shared interests, and hijacking the mechanisms of sexual pleasure for that goal is a hell of a temptation for our Mother. In humans, the one that brings the most joy to the collective is likely to enjoy others' presence and company, even in non-orthodox says. Being social will afford that person survival when somebody more ill-tempered may fall off a ravine in the middle of the winter, not to be found until the next thaw. And there was an awfully long age when all hominids had to guide them were their genes and instincts. In terms of evolution time, we invented two seconds ago systems of belief and moral codices. They made us so successful that there wasn't enough land anymore to sustain us. Rather than optimizing for individual survival, we started optimizing for the survival of our groups and the systems of beliefs that clumped them. And for their armies. If you live in a place which is mostly deserts, with scarce water and productive land, it would make sense to keep your population numbers low. Unless you are planning to invade your neighbor for their land, or you are expecting your neighbor to invade you at any moment. In that situation, you have little choice but to be the one with the biggest army and the most sexually frustrated, violent males ready to perish in a blaze of glory. Sodom is just a little off from the Dead Sea, and our crops don't like to grow together with salt statues.
- qwertthrowway 3y agoSome of these claims seem outlandish as rationalizations, do you have any evidence or data upholding these claims? I’m not sure how sexual frustration, homosexuality, and the military connect, especially we have the old literature of the Iliad where a famous band of men and their lovers fight.