4 ms·
Labor Misconduct Complaint Response: SpaceX Claims Fed Agency Unconstitutional
- slavboj 3y agoThey have a reasonable case. The idea of "independent federal agencies" that make substantive policy, are immune to democratic control, and also get to play-act as pseudo judicial bodies is a constitutional abomination.
- AnimalMuppet 3y agoPerhaps so, but... that sure makes it look like they have no reasonable answer to the allegations against them.
- justrealist 3y agoWhy are they obligated to answer? The allegations are legal soup anyway. The NLRB made up on the spot that criticism of the CEO was protected speech. There's nothing to say other than "you just made up that rule".
- taylodl 3y agoTHEY ARE NOT immune from democratic control. That's a common falsehood promoted by the extreme right. Congress has the power to reign them in any time they choose. Congress simply prefers to whimp out and lie to their constituents that "there's nothing they can do" and transfer blame to someone else.
- sickofparadox 3y agoSo they're only immune from democratic control in reality, but technically they could be reigned in if the people that are happy to let them run free would decide to 180 their positions? Sounds like effective democratic control to me.
- coolhand2120 3y agoWoah there. Congress does not have the right to delegate the authority given to them by the constitution. So it is indeed unconstitutional. A great many of the alphabet soup agencies are in this boat. Whole lot of unconstitutional behavior going around and nobody really bats an eye.
- HenryPrickett 3y agoOn what basis do you believe Congress is not allowed to delegate any power. The idea that statutes cannot allow for administrative rulemaking is some psycho libertarian bullshit because it is literally impossible to run an administrative state where the nuts and bolts (rather than just the goals, outcomes, and boundaries) of the administration of law must be handled legislatively. Read this and do better https://constitution.findlaw.com/article1/annotation03.html https://constitution.findlaw.com/article1/annotation03.html.
- avs733 3y agoI suspect several people in this thread are conflating the non-delegation doctrine with the major questions doctrine, which is a confusing narrative that has been pushed to make the major questions doctrine seem less whackado.
- coolhand2120 3y agoThe courts disagree. https://reason.com/2023/11/13/gun-hobbyists-and-liberty-win-big-in-court/ https://reason.com/2023/11/13/gun-hobbyists-and-liberty-win-... Agencies cannot make law. SCOTUS has repeatedly said congress cannot delegate legislative authorities to other agencies. That they do it anyway does not make it constitutional.
- slavboj 3y agoExecutive departments not answerable to the President are unconstitutional, full stop. We do not allow Congress to delegate its authority and/or strip authority from the President and move it into a fourth branch of government.
- tedivm 3y agoThe Supreme Court, which is who decides what is unconstitutional, has spent hundreds of years disagreeing with you. Full Stop. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Independent_agencies_of_the_United_States_government https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Independent_agencies_of_the_Un... I always find it weird when people make statements like yours, full of confidence that what they are saying is the way everything is and should be, when they are literally completely and utterly wrong. What you have is an opinion of how you think the government should be run, based on your interpretation of the constitution. The reality is that the Supreme Court thinks your interpretation is wrong, and since they're the deciding factor that means your interpretation is wrong.
- slavboj 3y agoThey can be "independent", provided the President is able to fire them. That is the mechanism for accountability. NLRB directors only being fireable for cause, rather than because the people's elected representative chooses to can them as a matter of state policy, is unconstitutional. https://www.npr.org/2020/06/29/884958645/supreme-court-rules-that-the-structure-of-key-independent-agency-is-unconstituti https://www.npr.org/2020/06/29/884958645/supreme-court-rules...
- averysmallbird 3y ago[flagged]
- averysmallbird 3y agoYou may have that political position, but you're wrong on the merits. The non-delegation doctrine exists, but independent agencies survive because its administrators are Presidentially appointed and Congressionally confirmed, and other factors. Other commenters have rightfully also pointed out that you probably have more chance to engage in the democratic process with an independent agency, which also tend to have greater representation from the political party not in control of the Presidency. It would be correct to say that there are new attacks on the administrative courts systems and extent of deference to administrative rulemaking. But you're wrong about independent agencies.
- tedivm 3y agoWe've had "independent federal agencies" since before we had the constitution. Our entire economy, specifically the federal reserve, is based on independent agencies. The case in question isn't about whether independent agencies can exist or not. The claim is that the way the panel is appointed is not constitutional. If they win the case then it would simply require the board to be appointed in a more specific way. > SpaceX in its lawsuit claims that, because federal law only allows board members and administrative judges to be removed for cause, and not at will, the NLRB’s structure is unconstitutional. The lawsuit seeks to block the NLRB case from moving forward. There's also a second claim that they should be allowed a jury trial. > In its lawsuit, however, SpaceX claims that the NLRB proceedings violate the company’s “constitutional right to trial by jury.” The constitutionality of the agency itself isn't what's being discussed.
- slavboj 3y ago"Independent" just meaning "not part of a cabinet secretariat" is not at issue. When the claim is that the governance structure and the pseudo judicial hearings by which they actually exercise authority are unconstitutional it's fair to qualify the argument as "the agency is unconstitutional". No one would have an issue if the board and officers were fireable by the president at will, like they are at say the CIA or EPA, and if they had to actually go to court to allege violations of the law.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- tootie 3y agoYeah, that's not true at all. The NLRB, like all agencies, was created by act of congress and given a remit to regulate areas of civic life within a specific range of factors. A complainant can try to argue that a specific regulation is outside their remit or otherwise in contravention to other Constitutional protections, but they can't just say the agency has no right to make rules. There's a gigantic stack of precedent that Congress or the courts can rein in specific rules, but so long as they within the bounds set in their charter, they are absolutely allowed to make new rules with the force of law (ie can the EPA regulate carbon emissions as "pollution"). It's just standard bureaucracy since it would be utterly impossible to put every single minute regulation up for Congressional debate. Especially when they require niche technical expertise to even understand.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- stuaxo 3y ago> violate the company’s “constitutional right to trial by jury.” This is what we get as declaring companies as people.
- justrealist 3y agoNot really. Companies are owned by people, and if a federal agency can fine a company $10mm, they are taking that property from one or more people. It's still a direct financial taking from owners.
- coolhand2120 3y agoVs. “this faceless unelected bureaucrat can shut down my business because of reason him and his unelected coworkers literally just made up without any legislation”. I’m going with the one that protects private sector over government.
- avs733 3y agofaceless beaucrat tells faceless corporation its violating the law doesn't bother me all that much. What you see from BOTH is people's perspectives coming out in which side of an argument they humanize and which side they dehumanize.
- obblekk 3y agoWe also get things like companies being able to refuse to give your data to the police without a warrant (unreasonable search and seizure protection for people).
- justrealist 3y ago> In its lawsuit, however, SpaceX claims that the NLRB proceedings violate the company’s “constitutional right to trial by jury.” It's really not an absurd claim.
- passwordoops 3y agoOnly because the supreme Court ruled corporations are legal people. Without that absurdity, this would be absurd
- obblekk 3y agoI wonder if Elon is distracting people from the issue: can you go into an office, openly announce to everyone your boss is a terrible human being who should be denounced, and reasonably expect to keep your job? Workers should have the right to improve their working conditions, but not to hate on coworkers. Be they bosses or subordinates. Regardless, the unconstitutional part is this decision is like an illegally created new law - it essentially carries the weight of law, can only be appealed to the people who made the law, and was never debated or voted by democratically elected reps.
- toomuchtodo 3y agoSpaceX should have their federal contracts pulled (>$1B) to put his power trip in check. Certainly, challenge the system if you feel wronged, but don't be surprised when the system pushes back. The executive branch has made their position on labor rights known [1] [2], take government dollars away from bad faith actors if they must. [1] https://www.whitehouse.gov/briefing-room/statements-releases/2023/11/16/fact-sheet-president-biden-takes-historic-step-to-advance-worker-empowerment-rights-and-high-labor-standards-globally/ https://www.whitehouse.gov/briefing-room/statements-releases... [2] https://www.whitehouse.gov/briefing-room/statements-releases/2023/09/01/fact-sheet-ahead-of-labor-day-biden-harris-administration-announces-new-actions-to-empower-workers-building-on-the-presidents-historic-support-for-workers-and-unions/ https://www.whitehouse.gov/briefing-room/statements-releases...
- obblekk 3y agoI’d rather live in a society where companies can challenge the system without threat of shutdown. Imagine how the other side would use the power to make contract decisions based on political loyalty.
- toomuchtodo 3y agoWe want different things, and Elon believes himself accountable to no one and desires absolute unelected power. See you at the voting booth, I want people like him kept in check until gone. I am willing to compromise a bit on governance out of pragmatism considering how people like him will use any bugs or loopholes in systems to achieve their desired outcome, crushing anyone along the way who they believe impedes said outcome. Like Oracle [1], don't be mad at the lawnmower. It's just a lawnmower. Protect yourself from it, because it doesn't care who it hurts [2]. Elon believes empathy is a weakness, for example. It's like trying to negotiate with a Great White shark. You're gonna have a bad time. I'm advocating for a cage to protect us, not the shark. Let the shark be the shark while minimizing the harm it causes. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5170246 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5170246 [2] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38127745 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38127745
- ImJamal 3y agoIt seems like there is a better argument. The 10th amendment basically says if it is not given to the federal government and not banned by the Constitution it is left to the states. Labor rules are not mentioned in the Constitution so a plain reading of the amendment and Constitution would mean labor rules are left to the states and the federal government has no authority in the matter. Then again if such a thing is accurate then 3/4 of the federal government is unconstitutional.
- granzymes 3y agoMost of the complaints about the NLRB and other agencies are bunk. However, the quasi-judicial bodies inside administrative agencies are legitimately worrisome. Making substantive policy is fine as long as Congress has given them an intelligible principle to guide them - which they have: the NLRA. The NLRB is not immune to democratic control; the General Counsel of the NLRB is removable at will by the President and Congress can override any rule or precedent. However, it is legitimately a problem that the NLRB and other agencies have their own internal court where you have no right to a jury trial, the rules of evidence are stacked against you, and the ultimate decision is heavily dependent on the partisan makeup of the current Board (Democratic boards routinely overturn precedent established under Republican boards and vice versa). There is a case at the Supreme Court this term that may begin to remedy that.
- avs733 3y agoI would call it a concern rather than a problem. It'll be interesting, and likely frustrating, to see what what the Supreme Court does but it is worth noting some potential upsides - for both parties to a case- of this system. The reasoning for the internal administrative courts is because these (SEC, NLRA, etc.) are highly esoteric and detailed areas of the law. Having people be judges in these cases who are experts can be a positive so they don't get BS'ed and can resolve issues efficiently and effectively and consistently. That is very different from the experience of dealing with federal courts at large where a judge may be hearing a murder trial one day and a shareholder lawsuit the next. Those courts ALREADY have huge backlogs so adding this case load to them is likely to be disastrous as well as resulting in more manifestly unfair outcomes when one side is able to delay to the point where remedies aren't meaningful. The argument that they are political (your overturning) also applies pretty damn well to EVERY court these days, not just internal administrative ones. I think a useful analogy is to how frustrated much of HN gets every time federal judges struggle to grok technology - whether it be the internet, software code, or privacy. Imagine if there was some sort of court dedicated to dealing with 'technology stuff' where the judges had a background in the relevant areas to make sure reality won the day. There is a place for generalists and a place for specialists. Maybe this isn't the best way to handle it but it is a way.
- ChrisArchitect 3y ago[dupe] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38873002 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38873002
- hansvm 3y ago(not a lawyer) People don't always get trials by jury either (petty traffic cases being perhaps the most common example), and SpaceX does have the opportunity to testify and present evidence to a judge. As far as evil actions by evil corporations go, they're about to get a slap on the wrist for the 0.1% of employees directly affected by the allegations. Is that major enough to warrant a trial by jury in the first place? It looks to me like the point is to ensure that if these allegations are false then there's a reasonable chance to defend against them (not a trial by jury, but nobody's being accused of murder or thrown in jail either), and that if they're true then reasonable remedies are applied this decade, while they still matter. I can see the argument for not just wanting some bureaucrat to be judge, jury, and executioner, _but_ that's also not what's happening here, is it?
- pierat 3y ago> People don't always get trials by jury either (petty traffic cases being perhaps the most common example) And this is also a gross miscarriage of justice, and basically is uncontrolled rampant taxation. And somehow, its done as a contortion that the BMV "allows" you to drive, so you're bound by their ALJs, who are actual judges but with laughable standards. And the BMV can revoke driving rights for any/no reason. Its cause the system would drown if citations actually required a real court and jury and such. So the state just jedi-hand-waves and says no. Hopefully, SCOTUS decision will also remove this BMV speeding ticket bullshit in kangaroo court.
- hansvm 3y ago> And this is also a gross miscarriage of justice, and basically is uncontrolled rampant taxation. I agree wholeheartedly. The world you appear to want (similar enough I think to the one I want) isn't the one we live in though, so it'd be weird to grant SpaceX special privileges. This won't be the start of a grassroots movement to fix that injustice; it'll be one exemption to let SpaceX fuck over their employees, customers, and shareholders a bit more easily.