3 ms·
And $10/month subscription? What should something like Photoshop with 10000x the features and development costs then charge? $1000/month? I understand "keepin
by coldtea 3y ago
And $10/month subscription?
What should something like Photoshop with 10000x the features and development costs then charge? $1000/month?
I understand "keeping it simple" but not "keeping it simple AND charging a crazy price for it" (there are essential, complex apps, that charge much less than that).
I guess, if you can get away with it...
- weego 3y agoScale and niche don't have the same underlying pricing considerations
- coldtea 3y agoAs if the "minimalist editor" niche isn't already served with 1000 other apps? It's not exactly a niche the author uniquely identified and served. It's one of the most crowded markets when it comes to offerings.
- metafunctor 3y agoIt's a crowded market, but it IS a market. In fact, crowded markets are the ones that work the best. If people find their app, like what they see, and are willing to pay the price, what is your objection exactly?
- coldtea 3y ago>If people find their app, like what they see, and are willing to pay the price, what is your objection exactly? My more general objection to your question is that I don't consider individual preference, or individual choice, or individual action beyond criticism, just because the individual is "fine with it". People can "find a product, like what they see, and be willing to pay the price", and the purchase could still be stupid and deserved to be called as such, and the price could still be highway robbery and be deserved to be called as such, and the product could still be subpar/average/bad and be deserved to be called as such.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- metafunctor 3y agoDo you think you know better than the companies developing these products and the consumers buying them? Do you believe you understand what the right products and fair prices should be? This seems to justify your use of terms like 'highway robbery' and calling people 'stupid'. I would have words for such viewpoints, but for the sake of a civilized conversation, I won't express them here.
- coldtea 3y ago>Do you think you know better than the companies developing these products and the consumers buying them? Yes. Do you think it's impossible for someone else to know better than the buyer if the latter got a good deal for a product at a given price? If so, I have a bridge to sell you. >I would have words for such viewpoints, but for the sake of a civilized conversation, I won't express them here. Good for you. I have similar words for your viewpoint.
- alpaca128 3y agoWhy don't you let the actual target audience decide whether the niche is served or not? Everyone has a different definition of "minimalist" and niche markets may have more specific requirements, so if someone can sell their specialized tool then what's the problem with that? Nothing of what you wrote is a reason against the existence of more choices.
- coldtea 3y ago>Why don't you let the actual target audience decide whether the niche is served or not? I do. Do you see me passing any laws or enforcing something to prevent it? Am I allowed to criticize their decision though, or is that to much to ask? >Nothing of what you wrote is a reason against the existence of more choices. That's because writing against "the existence of more choices" wasn't my point. It was about criticizing stupid choices.
- kibwen 3y agoHistorical note: Photoshop cost $895 in 1990, which is more than $2,100 today. Original MacWorld magazine review: https://archive.org/details/MacWorld_9006_June_1990/page/n201/mode/1up https://archive.org/details/MacWorld_9006_June_1990/page/n20...
- macintux 3y agoLong ago I paid somewhere between $25 and $100 for a calculator construction kit on Mac classic. Purely a purchase of love because it seemed like cool software and I love RPN calculators. I resent the modern attitude that paying for software is an undue burden.
- coldtea 3y ago>Historical note: Photoshop cost $895 in 1990, which is more than $2,100 today. I know. I've used it for decades. But $2100 for Photoshop - a professional working tool - even today, is way more justified than $100 for a "minimalist text editor" (or $120/year subscription for same). Not to mention you can get Photoshop+Lightroom+1TB storage for the same exact yearly subscription price. If it wasn't a piece of software but something like a barebones plastic spatula sold for $100, people would just laugh it off. But because it's software and intangible we can mystify the end product and pretend like there aren't some much more realistic prices one would expect it to be sold at, and it's "all about demand". In other words, we bring in some of the mystification from the fashion industry, where the same t-shirt (materials, labour, design, etc wise) costs $10 in some outlet and $200 in another because it has a different brand name attached to it.
- sph 3y agoWhy should the author care whether their price scales to Photoshop level? Price should scale with demand. A company like Adobe might want to maximise revenue, so they price it optimally to make the most money out of their product. A single developer might not want to support half a billion users at $5. If selling at $60 means a lower number of users and a manageable number of support requests per month, it is a much better idea, even if it means less revenue. And in general, at higher prices you get better quality customers. Pricing is hard, because it is not intuitive. And more importantly, the value of something is often subjective. People tend to forget that.
- coldtea 3y ago>Why should the author care whether their price scales to Photoshop level? The author shouldn't. Buyers should care what they're charged. >Pricing is hard, because it is not intuitive. And more importantly, the value of something is often subjective. People tend to forget that. And subjectivity often leads to stupid personal buying decisions. People tend to forget that.
- sph 3y agoNo one is getting scammed here, even if it cost 1000x as much. Why are you saying buyers don't know what they are charged? > stupid personal buying decisions Why does it affect you so much what other people are doing with their money? Spoiler alert: it is none of your business, and you are taking it way too personal.
- coldtea 3y ago>No one is getting scammed here, even if it cost 1000x as much. Why are you saying buyers don't know what they are charged? I'm obviously not saying they are blindly charged an amount that they don't know. I'm saying that they are buying stuff influenced by the minimalist fashion/emotion/etc and they don't know they're overpaying for no good reason. >Why does it affect you so much what other people are doing with their money? Because I live in a society, not in the wilderness. What people do with their money affects everybody, and people making better decisions is good for society in general. >Spoiler alert: it is none of your business, and you are taking it way too personal. While answering to me is "your business"? And getting into direct personal comments (as opposed to making a general remark)?
- koopuluri 3y agoYou're making a common pricing mistake: the price of a product has absolutely nothing to do with the cost of building it. Nothing. Price only depends on what people are willing to pay for it, i.e. on the perceived value. Just because you aren't the target audience for such a product doesn't mean that audience doesn't exist. The world is large. Personally I see a great business in premium tools for the elites in any domain. A professional writer probably wouldn't mind shelling out an extra $1000 a year or more for a premium tool that's better than anything else out there. Smaller audience, but it likely exists. This goes both ways: if people aren't willing to pay even the price it takes to make the product, you go out of business. This happens often as well. If photoshop saw an opportunity to increase the price to generate greater revenue, of course they'll try to do so. These changes in pricing and priorities often lead to opportunities for new products & companies.
- mattbrewsbytes 3y agoI wish more software companies would take the approach of not bloating up everything and constantly updating everything. Its like the keeping up with the Joneses mentality but for software.
- quantumdot42 3y agoI created an account on this site (after years of lurking) just to upvote you here. Just because other people are willing to spend this kind of money on a text editor doesn't mean we can't think they are ridiculous for doing so. I definitely judge people who spend $10 on a text editor.
- coldtea 3y agoThanks! It's like people confuse criticizing an action with doing some dictator like thing against it happening. I'm not passing some law preventing people buying a barebones text editor $100 (or $10/month). Just criticizing the wisdom of that decision.