2 ms·
Are Harvard Graduates Better Than Harvard Dropouts?
- paulpauper 3y agoSure, some talented driven people can be successful without college. But survivorship bias is a thing, as he notes: Let me put it as simply as possible: Many successes are dropouts, but few dropouts are successes. That sums it up. Many in an absolute sense, but still small relative to successes. In a world of 8 billion people, there are 'many' of many things, so what. The examples he gives are outliers among outliers. Bill Gates, Zuck...we're talking ultra-geniuses in an IQ sense who had every advantage growing up, and then also founded two of the most successful companies in the world. Yes, totally doable. Not to mention, having attended Harvard, sans diploma, confers many advantages too in terms of networking. (4) As the college experience becomes more expensive and close-minded, the appeal of alternatives increases exponentially. uhh...but the college wage premium has grown too. The median debt for a college grad is $30k, which is easily covered by higher wages and better employment prospects. Plus, there are tons of scholarships and other payment plans. Top schools love to give generous financial aid to top students. The $500k figure he paid for his two children is a big outlier and not at all representative of grads overall. No mention of scholarships in the article. I highly doubt he paid that $500k out of pocket. The typical net tuition is half to a third of the MSRP. https://thehill.com/business/4002592-forget-that-90000-sticker-price-college-costs-are-actually-going-down/ https://thehill.com/business/4002592-forget-that-90000-stick... (6) Dropouts really do change society. Maybe for some things like art and music, but then why do all these woke/dei people who affect policy--either in corporations or government--have degrees. So much for 'useless' degrees. If you want to have a say in how society is run, a degree is basically a necessity. We can rant about how unfair this is, but those are the rules. Got to be in the game to play.
- fasthands9 3y agoThe artist examples were more interesting than the Gates/Zuck stuff. Harvard has very generous leave of absence policies so Zuck could have easily returned to finish his degree two years (or more, I believe) after leaving if Facebook did not work out. It really is just a selection effect for that level of achievement. I am mostly of the belief that higher education is about signaling, but signaling is valuable to even the majority of geniuses so there's really no opting out sadly.