4 ms·
Yes | No. The classic "road trueism" is If you build them, they will fill. Four lane highways with occassional gridlock when expanded become six lane highways
by defrost 3y ago
Yes | No.
The classic "road trueism" is If you build them, they will fill.
Four lane highways with occassional gridlock when expanded become six lane highways with occassional gridlock.
The connection corollary that follows is roads | train lines built to connect A and B will often be followed by small townsites along the way and the spread of "off the grid" living at blocks T junctioning dirt road access from the new A <--> B route.
- bobthepanda 3y agoAlso, the roads built are for the most part free, which certainly doesn't help regulate usage at all. The moment you introduce tolls onto major roads, often they don't meet financial projections, have to be bailed out, etc.
- anamax 3y ago> The classic "road trueism" is If you build them, they will fill. That's only when new roads satisfy pre-existing demand. The fact that someone can't do something doesn't imply that they don't want to do it.
- bluGill 3y agoThere are plenty of rural roads and highways that disprove your point. We fill roads in cities because the population wants/needs to travel. If we would instead build trains those would fill instead. Trains are a lot more cost effective in cities, but no city (not even transit cities like Paris) builds enough of them to make trains a better alternative than cars. Note that by the time anyone realizes roads are full and they need "one more lane" the road has 6 times more cars on it than it can safely handle - people just give up their safe following distance. One more reason to build trains.
- defrost 3y agoIt's not my point, it's a long standing observed principal of urban planning referred to as induced demand or induced traffic. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Induced_demand https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Induced_demand https://www.wired.com/2014/06/wuwt-traffic-induced-demand/ https://www.wired.com/2014/06/wuwt-traffic-induced-demand/ My point was that road access introduced through previously road vehicle inaccessable regions often (not always) leads to more human activity and dwelling in the vicinity of that road. It's not always the case that people appearing from ships, airdrops, or walking in results in roads following them. When my own family first settled in Australia it took 80+ years on the European side for roads to reach them (they used flat bottomed boats on tidal flats to transit goods and livestock), and some 70K years or so on the non European side.
- explaininjs 3y agoBut nobody builds a road to nowhere. You only build a road when there is demand, often from property owners, to be able to reach a place more easily. Thus I repeat the issue is not the roads, they are merely a consequence of the property ownership increasing travel to a remote area. Consider: would a road nobody traveled on be any issue for the tortoises? Clearly not.
- defrost 3y agoRoads are built through "nowhere" all the time .. to join one city to another several thousand miles away with no other "civilisation" between. To join a port to an inland mine site. Once you have a road where once there was no road and no easy access to the land within then people can follow. > But nobody builds a road to nowhere. See: Gunbarrel Highway - a road system from a launch point out into "nowhere" in order to retrieve test missiles.
- explaininjs 3y agoConnecting two occupied points is the exact opposite of building a road to nowhere. And see my point here about “linear” roads (connecting point to point) vs space-filling ones (providing access to an entire grid of houses). In short, an animal can exist very easily in the proximity of a single highway, but existing surrounded by development is a much harder task. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38877692 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38877692
- defrost 3y ago> Connecting two occupied points is the exact opposite of building a road to nowhere. I'm at a loss as to why you even bought it up. My intial comment here: roads | train lines built to connect A and B will often be followed by small townsites along the way and the spread of "off the grid" living at blocks T junctioning dirt road access from the new A <--> B route. was about development following roads that connect places and that development expanding outwards into what was once "nowhere".