3 ms·
How do they know the mouse didn't just associate the square with the lack of reward?
by mattmaroon 18y ago
How do they know the mouse didn't just associate the square with the lack of reward?
- gruseom 18y agoPresumably because avoiding the square alone wouldn't explain the preference for the third option over the second.
- mattmaroon 18y agoCould that be just curiosity? The article didn't say how much they preferred them or for how long. Maybe mice are just gamblers by nature.
- Shamiq 18y agoGambling doesn't seem to serve a species well in terms of my evolutionary biological thought process.
- mattmaroon 18y agoThen why are we where we are? We're the gamblingest species of all.
- gruseom 18y agoMaybe mice are just gamblers by nature. Heh. Can we think of an experiment to test that?
- mattmaroon 18y agoSure, same experiment as this one, but instead of introducing another rectangle for the third object, introduce a circle. If they favor that over the rectangle they're clearly gamblers. Actually, I have a snake that eats one mouse per week. Maybe I'll slowly try this over the course of a year or so.
- whacked_new 18y agoReward-driven behaviors are modulated by a reward center, i.e. the dopamine circuit, which gives you the happy chemicals when you get something good. While there is a pain evasion mechanism, there isn't an analogous lack-of-reward-center.
- mattmaroon 18y agoThe dopamine is triggered by the cheese it gets right? At the time when the mouse is making the decision, it knows it'll get the cheese and dopamine from the old rectangle, yet it doesn't go there. So what does this have to do with anything? Why is the mouse preferring something new and unknown over a known cheese/dopamine event? My statement is that the mouse may be gambling, not that it's afraid. It knows the square is no cheese, the rectangle is one piece, and thinks maybe an unknown object of any shape is 10.
- whacked_new 18y agoYou asked why the learning is not taken as an aversion response to lack of reward. My interpretation is because your baseline (square) is zero: that in itself is not aversive; it's just nothing. I think the new rectangle is evidence of hyperstimulation, where a stronger response is elicited when features are exaggerated. To establish this case, we'd have to test how strongly the rat perceives prototypes of squares vs. rectangles; my guess is square-ness vs. rectangle-ness is easily discernable. That is to say, I am pretty convinced this is just hyperstimulation, in which case a random shape would not do. It would have to resemble a former stimulus X but exhibit features that are even more X-like than the previous Xs. If perception of a rectangle is encoded as "right-angled shapes where height != width" (a plausible encoding, because our shape detectors operate on angles and lines, while curves utilize different detectors), then when height !!!=== width, then you get BAM! An analogous example in humans? Tomb Raider :-)