4 ms·
3 parts of organisation mentioned in the article have their own respective Operating Expenses (OpEx) and Capital Expenses (CapEx). OpEx is what you spend on day
by smugglerFlynn 3y ago
3 parts of organisation mentioned in the article have their own respective Operating Expenses (OpEx) and Capital Expenses (CapEx). OpEx is what you spend on day to day activities, and CapEx is what you invest into something that you will use long term. You can pay via CapEx or OpEx for the same exact result: e.g. if you purchase a car, that's CapEx, but if you rent it each month, that's OpEx. I'm simplifying, but that's the gist of it.
Organisations tend to move away from CapEx where possible, because of two reasons:
1. management decisions require accounting know-how and accounting 'magic' when CapEx gets involved
2. large upfront investments are much less flexible and more risky than day to day expenses
Let me illustrate.
Your marketing department is investing into new on-premises IT system to run promotions and campaigns. They are spending $1M dollars upfront for the installation, equipment purchase, system licenses and so on - all these expenses will be booked under CapEx. That marketing department also pays day to day salaries, and some other regular expenses, which all go to their OpEx.
Let's say right after system is launched and everyone in Marketing starts using it there is a 30% growth in # of leads they bring, and resulting 10% growth in sales. But what does that mean, financially? Was the project a success? 10% growth in sales might not cover full cost of our $1M investment, so for how long would we need to keep up the growth in order to see returns? What growth numbers do we need to keep seeing? What if we decide to adjust and purchase more hardware and licenses as we go? What if system unexpectedly required us to hire extra people in marketing, bumping up department's OpEx?
All that requires calculation, recalculation, excel spreadsheets crunching, more spreadsheets, and a few fat decks of powerpoints just to align all the decision makers around the numbers and understand what worked, financially.
Compare that to marketing department buying access to the same system in cloud via monthly subscription (let's say they start paying $10K total monthly - these will go to your OpEx). Any growth is now super straightforward to assess - you've invested $10K, you got 10% more sales that month, and you can now deduct all the combined OpEx from that number and see if you are still profitable after bringing the new system in. That's a reason #1.
Accounting and decision making complexity is not the only reason to prefer OpEx. Note that accountants came up with smart ways to make CapEx behave more 'OpEx-y' - for example, this $1M in the books will be spread across many months or years by using depreciation across system lifetime, so that upfront investments can be comparable to daily expenses. But the same way you are not buying a local car each time you arrive on a vacation somewhere, businesses don't want to have hands tied in large investments - oftentimes renting something is preferred, and business people will still call their decision to rent instead of buying "switching from CapEx to OpEx". That's a reason #2.
- count 3y agoThe CapEx -> OpEx push is also heavily tax based. I can write off (generally) 100% of an OpEx expense today (or, as I spend the money). CapEx expenses become Assets, which are tracked and taxed, and the business doesn't get to write off that spend immediately - it turns into a 'depreciation' write off, spread over the useful life of the item (sometimes 5, 10, or more years). Real estate, vehicles, large equipment, etc. is generally all done this way - a CapEx gets you an asset or property, which is then taxed and depreciated. Software licenses, insurance and other things can also be done this way (CapEx), depending on the terms and your accounting standards.
- lotsofpulp 3y ago> CapEx expenses become Assets, which are tracked and taxed, > Real estate, vehicles, large equipment, etc. is generally all done this way - a CapEx gets you an asset or property, which is then taxed and depreciated. What tax(es) are you referring to? Property taxes?
- count 3y agoIn some cases (e.g. a building or expensive equipment purchase, probably yes, property taxes in most jurisdictions, at least in the US). The depreciation is deducted from income for income taxes over time, rather than all at time of purchase as an opex expense is. This implies a higher income tax bill 'now', with a smaller deduction smeared over time.
- lotsofpulp 3y ago> This implies a higher income tax bill 'now', with a smaller deduction smeared over time. I would not characterize a lower deduction for a business expense as taxing something. I would have assumed it meant a buyer has to pay an additional tax as a result of purchasing something.
- count 3y agoA business pays no tax on an OpEx. The specific tax on a CapEx depends on the jurisdiction.