2 ms·
What encourages me on this is that we just need a single instance to pan out. Just one. And I get the sense that we’re getting closer each year.
by Havoc 3y ago
What encourages me on this is that we just need a single instance to pan out. Just one. And I get the sense that we’re getting closer each year.
- dtgriscom 3y agoIt isn't "one and done." Room temperature superconductivity will be an amazing breakthrough, but there will be many more barriers to overcome before it becomes a practical product.
- dexwiz 3y agoHardly. Just because you can make a chunk of it doesn’t mean it’s automatically useful. Is it ductile enough to make wires or sheets? Does it corrode quickly? Is it stable in the long term? Does it amalgamate with other metals too easily? Materials have a whole list of properties that are important in both manufacturing and usage contexts. Alternative processing methods can fix some issues but not all. That being said, finding one should be like kicking down the door to a whole room of related possibilities.
- nyokodo 3y ago> finding one should be like kicking down the door to a whole room of related possibilities You actually agree with the GP, you are just being more specific about what “one working” means, and providing more criteria for what getting “closer every year” would entail.
- TheRealPomax 3y ago*Two. Not one. It's not science until it's been independently reproduced. Until then, it's "cute, but we can't trust what you're saying until someone else shows you're not making things up". And that counter resets every single time someone does something slightly different and then claims that it works.
- ramraj07 3y agoIn that case it needs to be three, not two. No statistical method works on n=2.
- TheRealPomax 3y agoEven better, two is the absolute minimum to be able to at least claim real science happened.
- nektro 3y agothat's the beauty of science!