4 ms·
This comes every time when people talk about wind turbines and they are far behind the top 3 killers: Cats Cars Windows in buildings Cats for instance kill
by croes 3y ago
This comes every time when people talk about wind turbines and they are far behind the top 3 killers:
Cats
Cars
Windows in buildings
Cats for instance kill billions each year.
- unnamed76ri 3y agoStrange to include a natural predator in this list.
- rootusrootus 3y agoIt seems reasonable given that the vast majority of the cats in this case aren't natural per se, they are pets kept by humans.
- croes 3y agoBy that logic everything human related is natural too. The number of cats that kill birds is due to the fact that humans breed them en masse. Nothing natural about that.
- WhatsTheBigIdea 3y agoCats are not a "natural" predator in the modern context. They have massive advantages over wild animals including but not limited to 1) A guaranteed source of high quality disease free calories 2) Veterinary care 3) Safe places to rest and recuperate As a result, the numbers of domesticated cats in most environments is radically larger than they would be in naturally balanced ecosystems. The vast majority of modern domestic cats are sport hunters. Most will not even eat their prey as they have better food readily available. It is also worth mentioning that domesticated cats are an invasive species in any environment outside the Nile Delta in Egypt. Modern domestic cats are not "natural" predators in any sense. They can be very cute though!
- lukas099 3y agoNot to mention that they were introduced by humans almost everywhere that they exist.
- rvense 3y agoCats aren't really natural in all the environments we bring them to. And they're also subsidized to hell by their owners, if we weren't feeding them tinned food there'd likely be a hundred times less.
- jeffbee 3y agoVery strange to leave off by far the #1 issue which is habitat destruction.
- croes 3y agoCats, cars and buildings are part of habitat destruction.
- ajb 3y agoThey all happen in urban areas though, which are a small fraction of the country (< 1/10 of the uk, whereas farmland is > 7/10. ). Hence, while they might be significant for whether you see any birds in your back garden, the problems on farmland are more likely to be significant for the bird population as a whole.
- croes 3y agoThere are many cats in rural areas, so they are a significant problem there too.
- ajb 3y agoOkay if you want to be precise, the mass of the density function of cats over uk locations is largely in urban areas, while the mass of the density function of bird-habitat-value is much more spread over the whole landscape, which is also true of agriculture. Risk to birds will be proportional to the dot-product of the bird-habitat-value density function with that of a risk factor, and since the density function of agriculture is much more correlated with that of bird-habitat-value than it is correlated with that of cats, so changes in agriculture are likely to be the greater factor in changes in bird population.
- lukas099 3y agoBuilding height is actually a tradeoff against habitat destruction, since taller buildings use less land but are ostensibly struck more often by birds.
- linuxftw 3y agoThis is highly misleading. The birds that are killed by windmills aren't the same type of birds killed by feral cats. Windmills kill high-soaring endangered predator species.