3 ms·
Constrained devices should rather stick to the existing key exchange methods, until more certainty exists about the threat of quantum computers. The current me
by adrian_b 3y ago
Constrained devices should rather stick to the existing key exchange methods, until more certainty exists about the threat of quantum computers.
The current methods have much lower overhead than any of the post-quantum methods.
Constrained devices that must be quantum-resistant while not affording the cost of hybrid algorithms, which are only slightly less expensive than pure post-quantum algorithms, should better use key-exchange methods based on pre-shared authentication keys, which have much lower overhead than the public-key methods.
They could still use hybrid key exchange methods, but very infrequently, only for updating the pre-shared authentication keys, in which case the slowness of the hybrid key exchange method would not matter.
- JoachimS 3y agoThe problem is that constrained devices with planned lifetimes of 20-30 years being specified today already are getting requests for inclusion, usage of PQC as well as classical algorithms. Pre-shared only works for deployments with low-ish number of devices. We are talking about 1000+ devices.
- adrian_b 3y agoThat is why I have said that if updating the pre-shared authentication keys through separate communication channels is impractical, they can be updated through hybrid public-key based key exchange methods. If a hybrid key exchange method is used e.g. only after one thousand or even after one hundred of connections made with pre-shared keys, then the hybrid method can be very slow without significant impact. This is the same like reusing in TLS 1.3 a previously computed shared secret for a new connection, just using this for a large enough number of successive connections so that the slowness of the constrained device does not matter.
- michaelt 3y agoTLS-PSK is used in some of the largest volume resource constrained internet-connected devices in the world. You buy a $5 wifi-controlled lightbulb? There's a good chance it talks to its backend servers with TLS-PSK.