Here it is said that the earlier assumption of LLMs being parrots has been universally retracted in the face of the evidence. But if you see the NYT case agains

Here it is said that the earlier assumption of LLMs being parrots has been universally retracted in the face of the evidence. But if you see the NYT case against OpenAI, being uncontrolled parrots is exactly what ChatGPT is being accused of. Which is the truth?