4 ms·
If AI is ruled as fair use, no license will stop it, which it likely is to be, notwithstanding the NY Times lawsuit against OpenAI alleging that ChatGPT can rep
by satvikpendem 3y ago
If AI is ruled as fair use, no license will stop it, which it likely is to be, notwithstanding the NY Times lawsuit against OpenAI alleging that ChatGPT can reproduce articles wholesale.
- mobiuscog 3y agoIf it is not ruled fair use, or similar, all non-copyright countries are going to advance far faster. Whilst there are many ethical discussions to have, this will come down to the simple fact of there being people who will take the data anyway and thus have the advantage in datasets, assuming that matters.
- dleeftink 3y agoI think the ideal of more data == faster advancements may turn out to be a false equivalency. Similar to prior innovations, a healthy headcount, headstart and steady R&D funding will more likely make a difference. Besides, rather than vacuuming up exisiting data, future resources might be better spent on creating bespoke datasets with user consent and content licensing baked in from the start.
- kaibee 3y ago> Besides, rather than vacuuming up exisiting data future resources might be better spent on creating bespoke datasets with user consent and content licensing baked in from the start. Not mutually exclusive.
- dleeftink 3y agoProbably not, but I think it is worthwhile to see if models can achieve sota with less, and if not, have individuals clearly onboard and informed of their data contributions. We have conducted large statistical surveys in the past, so I see little reason why these and other established data collection practices could not be updated and utilised for refining contemporary models.
- graphe 3y agoFor DNA and genetics more data is better. Data and it's interpretation is the bottleneck for some subjects but not all. Getting more data from search engines about purchasing habits might not yield more/better results as MoE showed when 2-3 experts was better than 4-6.
- dleeftink 3y agoAt first, data is needed to overcome scarcity in domains where it has traditionally been difficult to obtain -- but I don't think it's quite the same as the 'data' being (colloquially) referred to here. We may want to discern between user generated content and genetic features that one has little influence in creating, among the many other data types and kinds. It's probably a large reason why this space is so difficult to license/regulate: data to one may simply be 'noise' to another, or not even register as such. Definitions unfortunately, do not always map.
- graphe 3y agoThe US shot itself in the hand foot and ass by letting the wright brothers patent troll so hard that they couldn't even make their own planes during WW1, they were buying American designs built by France. https://www.centennialofflight.net/essay/Aerospace/WWi/Aero5.htm https://www.centennialofflight.net/essay/Aerospace/WWi/Aero5... > The United States did not produce any aircraft of its own design for use at the front during World War I. If it happens again for AI who knows what will happen.
- DanHulton 3y agoYou're making an assumption there, that "advance" is just one axis. There are many ways a society could "advance", many of which are wildly impeded by current AI technologies. I'm just not sold that it's a good technology to let run free without any regulation. (Heck, not many are.)
- dahart 3y agoThere has already been one court decision that pushes against a blanket fair use protection for AI training: https://chatgptiseatingtheworld.com/2023/10/13/judge-bibas-issues-1st-ruling-on-how-fair-use-applies-in-ai-training-after-andy-warhol-foundation-decision/ https://chatgptiseatingtheworld.com/2023/10/13/judge-bibas-i... And I think there are dozens of unfinished AI copyright infringement lawsuits... with likely more to come, I speculate. https://chatgptiseatingtheworld.com/2023/12/27/master-list-of-lawsuits-v-ai-chatgpt-openai-microsoft-meta-midjourney-other-ai-cos/ https://chatgptiseatingtheworld.com/2023/12/27/master-list-o... https://heathermeeker.com/ai-copyright-et-al-litigation-scoreboard-sorted-by-complaint-date/ https://heathermeeker.com/ai-copyright-et-al-litigation-scor...
- satvikpendem 3y agoI don't think that first link means what you think it means: > Ultimately, Judge Bibas denied summary judgment and ruled the case should proceed to trial. > Judge Bibas cautioned against “overreading” the Supreme Court’s recent fair use decision in Andy Warhol Foundation, in which the Court limited the weight to give a defendant’s transformative purpose if it is commercial and substantially similar in purpose as the plaintiff’s work. > "Ross’s uses were undoubtedly commercial. And one of its goals was to compete with Westlaw. Thomson Reuters contends that this commercial use weighs heavily against finding fair use. [...]" All that the judge is saying is that previous rulings are not comparable to AI related ones. It is also difficult to see how ChatGPT is competing with NYT, as ChatGPT does not generate (actual, real) news, because it cannot interact with the world as journalists can. Maybe image generators could but a similar judgment stated that it was difficult to see how AI generated images were similar to an existing artist's.
- richardwhiuk 3y agoIt's clearly competing with NYT if people get their news from NYT via ChatGPT instead of getting it from NYT directly. Otherwise you could argue that if I copy and paste the NYT articles onto my own website, because I'm not doing any journalism, I'm not competing with the NYT - which is clearly ludicrous.
- graphe 3y agoUnless NYT proves the few people with a NYT subscription cancels NYT for a chatGPT subscription I don't see anything coming from it. Publicly scraping is what all search engines do. There also isn't any proof of intention, imagine if the US bans AI and china allows it because of the NYT.
- madeofpalk 3y agonotwithstanding all the cases that could rule it not fair use? That's quite the hedge.
- satvikpendem 3y agoYes, but it was due to their specific implementation where NYT showed that ChatGPT "memorized" the words to an article, shown by setting the temperate of the model to 0. Other AI implementaions might easily not have this limitation, so it's dumb to take one implementation and create broadspanning rules for the entire idea as a whole.
- CaptainFever 3y agoNot just that, but in many jurisdictions it is already "fair use" (TDM exceptions). EU, Japan, South Korea, Malaysia, Singapore, etc. If the US bans it, it's only going to hurt itself.
- satvikpendem 3y agoSources on this? As far as I know, no jurisdiction has yet ruled on AI fair use policy.
- Manabu-eo 3y agoFor Japan, I saw this: https://petapixel.com/2023/06/05/japan-declares-ai-training-data-fair-game-and-will-not-enforce-copyright/ https://petapixel.com/2023/06/05/japan-declares-ai-training-...
- CaptainFever 3y agoIt's not fair use per se which is why I put it in quotes, but more like training is basically exempted from copyright in law: https://www.reedsmith.com/en/perspectives/ai-in-entertainment-and-media/2023/06/text-and-data-mining-around-the-globe https://www.reedsmith.com/en/perspectives/ai-in-entertainmen... For commercial use, too. For EU though, commercial use needs to respect opt-out. Other countries can ignore opt-outs.