10 ms·
What it will take to unleash the potential of geothermal power? (2021)
- adrianN 3y ago>If prices come down, and if it can be deployed widely enough Drilling deep holes is expensive, prices are unlikely to come down much. Steam generators are expensive too.
- nucleative 3y agoWhy is the cost of drilling so high? I'm sure the rigs are an expensive capital outlay, but do the operators require advanced skills? Once a hole is drilled, does it have a limited lifespan, or is that investment something that can be hypothetically used for eternity?
- Bedon292 3y agoDrilling to the depth needed to get high enough temperatures for energy generation can be hard. Depending on how active the area is. Iceland, which has tons of heat close to the surface can do it with relative ease. But elsewhere you may have to be drilling far deeper through much harder rock to get there. In some locations you may have to drill down many km at 10s of meters per day through the hardest rocks. It could potentially take months to hit the right depth. You also need materials to ensure that the well doesn't collapse on itself, and stuff like that as well. I would expect the hole itself should have an extremely long lifespan, but I don't really have much to back it up. Its not for electric generation, but for Geo HVAC the ground loop itself has a 50 year warranty and quoted 150+ year lifespan. The house will probably be long gone before the loop would go bad.
- jofer 3y agoThe operators very very very very much require advanced skills. Don't confuse roughneck work with drilling engineers. Drilling engineers also aren't by any means the only advanced skillset required. It requires a large team of highly educated (postgraduate degrees usually required) and highly paid professionals. The materials you're using when drilling are expensive. The steel casings that you're putting down the hole are specialized alloys. You're using very large amounts of expensive specialized fluids to fill the hole during drilling (drilling mud) that are relatively hazardous and need to be treated after use. You're going through large numbers of very expensive consumable parts (e.g. drill bits are _not_ cheap, and there are a lot of even more expensive consumables). A large amount of the equipment and consumables are custom built for the specific conditions you're working in. There are certainly cases where you can use things that are a bit more of a commodity, but deep and hot wells usually don't fall into that category. And yes, there are a ton of companies that specialize in making all of these things either en masse or custom built to order, but they're still expensive. You're also going to need to run logs (i.e. downhole measurements) using a wide variety of very expensive and very specialized tools. It's not just a hole. You're also building a subsurface structure and collecting information about the subsurface. Any well has a limited lifespan. Geothermal wells aren't that different from hydrocarbon wells in this sense. You're not actually able to extract heat from the bulk of the rock mass. Rocks are _very_ poor conductors of heat. So you're extracting heat from relatively tiny depth within the rock mass along the surface of a pore network. You're flowing water from one well (an injector) to another well (a producer). As that flows and temperatures and water chemistry change, various minerals precipitate out and block the pore throats. Even in cases where you can avoid those reactions, you eventually block different pores and fracture networks with debris. You can and do use techniques to restore that (aka "workovers"). However, they are expensive and have diminishing returns. And even if none of the before-mentioned things happen, you'll eventually hit diminishing returns on the temperature you can produce, as the heat can't migrate from the bulk of the rock to the water-rock interface very quickly. Either way, eventually you drill new injectors and producers. The cycle you need to do that on varies quite a bit depending on the specifics of the project. In some cases, it's a couple years, in others it's a decade or two. Either way, you need continued redevelopment plans to continue production. All of that is not a problem and is work as normal. I'm just trying to lay out what subsurface projects entail (be they geothermal, oil, methane, or even large scale water production). It doesn't mean geothermal is impractical or overly expensive (far from it). But it does mean that there are very large initial captial expenses and then periodic capital expenses needed at later dates to continue optimal operation.
- porkbeer 3y agoDoes the widespread cooling of the planets interior have any possible consequences?
- BMc2020 3y agoAn astronomer/geophysicist could answer better, but my understanding is nothing we could possibly do would change the planets temperature the tiniest fraction of a degree. I also read somewhere that if the sun disappeared and the earth flew off into space, life would persist in the oceans for millions of years because it would take that long for them to freeze to the bottom.
- theideaofcoffee 3y agoThis question is usually asked when conversations about geothermal come up here, and for good reason because it’s a valid question. The long and short of it is that the amount of thermal energy that humans would be able to realistically extract pales in comparison to the amount already lost to heat flux through the surface, the amount generated via radioactive decay and frictional forces from gravity/tidal sources and convection in the core. Some answers on a relevant stack exchange answer with more general calculations [0]. Edit: Off the top of my head, it’s estimated that total core heat is approximately 10^31 J, heat loss at a rate of 47TW, (forgive me for not carrying out the calculation completely or for sources on those numbers, they can be easily searched, I’m on mobile), so the orders of magnitude difference already are so vast it’s a rounding error in siginificant figures. [0] https://earthscience.stackexchange.com/questions/2302/can-the-overuse-of-geothermal-energy-become-an-environmental-concern https://earthscience.stackexchange.com/questions/2302/can-th...
- gustavus 3y agoAt the scales were talking about it's somewhere between Going to the beach and getting shot by a swimming dog carrying a gun in its mouth and the problems caused by doing flybys of Jupiter. https://what-if.xkcd.com/146/ https://what-if.xkcd.com/146/
- angiosperm 3y agoIronically, stealing momentum from Jupiter would speed it up.
- wscourge 3y ago> They require more capital investment than solar or wind projects: $3,000 to $6,000 per kilowatt, compared with $1,700 to $2,100 per kilowatt for wind and solar. (However, a geothermal plant will produce between two and four times as much electricity as a wind or solar plant of the same capacity.) Solar/wind: 1.7k - 2.1k / kW → N Geothermal: 3k - 6k / kW → 2N - 4N Looks like an investment no-brainer.
- hn_throwaway_99 3y agoI don't understand what that second sentence means. What do they mean by "capacity" if it's not electricity generation capability?
- maliker 3y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Capacity_factor https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Capacity_factor
- cshokie 3y agoCapacity is the most they can produce at any given time. Solar only produces power during the day. Geothermal produces power 24 hours a day, without any regard for day or night. Therefore for the same “capacity” geothermal will produce more power per day because it produces for more hours a day at the same rate. (This does not account for any complications such as the cost of that capacity or whether geothermal has other downtime to consider.)
- hn_throwaway_99 3y agoD'oh, yeah, totally makes sense, thanks!
- Gibbon1 3y agoThe napkin math factor I use is to get the average power you need to divide solar and wind's name plate power by about 4. So to get the same amount of total yearly energy as a 1GW nuke plant that runs 24/7 you need 4GW of solar. Because solar produces about 6 hours of power per 24 hour day. From a capital cost perspective this is not nice at all. Too be fair upside of solar/wind is solar and wind farms don't go down for a year and a half of unplanned maintenance like nuke plants sometimes do.
- rmm 3y agoI worked on a mining project years ago where we had to dewater the mine of 90 degree Celsius water at 700L/s. Always wondered whether we can use it for energy….
- darig 3y ago[dead]
- zdragnar 3y agoYou could use it for district heating of buildings in winter, but that's about it. As the article mentions, you need to get above the phase transition between liquid and gas at high pressure (they mention 150c) to be able to reliably and quickly convert the thermal energy into kinetic, then into electrical inductance (gas expansion moving a turbine, moving a dynamo). Maybe if you went into business making pot roast, you could cook meat low and slow, or set up massive dehydrators. Running it under a shallow drying bed might make salt extraction from water evaporation faster, too. Sadly, none of those things tend to be very close to mines.
- angiosperm 3y agoThere are fluids other than water that have usefully different boiling points. Problem is that mature turbines are designed for steam. Turbines for other fluids cannot approach their market volume.
- pi-e-sigma 3y agoThat's not true at all. If any other liquids were more useful they would have been used long time ago, even in places where the cost is not of primary concern, such as nuclear submarines.
- angiosperm 3y agoNuclear submarines have no use for a working fluid that boils below 100 C. Indeed, they pressurize the water so that the boiling point is well above that point, because they have no difficulty heating water well above that. Steam is used everywhere despite that it is quite corrosive, mainly because it is cheap.
- ggm 3y agoThey tried experiments fracking into hot rock in australia and went bankrupt proving the concept. Bit of a shame. More money got pumped into CCS which is demonstrably bloody useless, works for gas well life extension but not sequestration
- defrost 3y agoTo clarify at least two companies circa 2003-2013 successfully proved Australian geothermal could generate power at the 1MW level via pilot plants .. and had no futher investment or interest to expand further. Geodynamics writes off Cooper Basin geothermal assets https://reneweconomy.com.au/geodynamics-writes-cooper-basin-geothermal-assets-40047/ https://reneweconomy.com.au/geodynamics-writes-cooper-basin-... Petratherm Ltd: https://www.energymining.sa.gov.au/__data/assets/pdf_file/0009/689265/gel156_178_180_yr1_annual_rpt_www.pdf https://www.energymining.sa.gov.au/__data/assets/pdf_file/00... (now doing other exploration: https://www.petratherm.com.au/projects-overview/ https://www.petratherm.com.au/projects-overview/) To quote GeoScience Australia (2013): These learnings have come at a high cost ... in excess of $0.5 billion What's happened to geothermal? Simple in concept—complex in application : https://www.ga.gov.au/ausgeonews/ausgeonews201306/geothermal.jsp https://www.ga.gov.au/ausgeonews/ausgeonews201306/geothermal...
- ggm 3y agoPulled out at the wrong time, the wellhead kit is probably buggered now. The qld government wasn't sufficiently keen, some say they make too much money from non renewable energy. Maybe times have changed now.
- WarOnPrivacy 3y agoThere are a lot of near-surface options for heating and cooling. They reduce electrical usage rather than generate it. I worked on geo control systems for FL buildings. We'd pump water up from the aquifer, transfer heat from the building into it and dump it back. It starts getting cost effective above 10k or 15k sqft. In northern states they do large closed loops wound over a large yard or field and buried just below the surface to capture daytime heat or pump heat into the earth. Basically a larger version of rooftop water heating. There are a lot of variants of this but you get the idea.
- Bedon292 3y agoMy understanding is that, while you can do surface loops with enough area, its easier and less disruptive to just do vertical holes for ground loops. At least in Northern Virginia drill ~150ft of well per ton. At 400ft the wells maintain temperature a relatively consistent temperature year round year round.
- theluketaylor 3y agoDrilling down is best for retrofitting existing structures and built environments, but for new neighbourhood development trenching is super cheap since you have to disturb all that dirt anyway. Prep for roads and all the underground services means you have the ground open anyway, might as well run some coolant lines while you're down there. District heating loops can be done almost for free with greenfield development and it should be highly incentivized to slash the energy required to heat and cool the new structures.
- iancmceachern 3y agoMake drilling cheaper. This would also help with water access. The biggest cost of small geothermal and water projects is always the drilling. Drill rig time is always a limiting factor.
- WarOnPrivacy 3y agoYeah. We'd do 3"-6" wells at 450ft for hvac geo and it'd be 10%-30% of the project cost. I don't believe drilling has gotten cheaper in my lifetime.
- Bedon292 3y agoWe just recently got Geo HVAC, for our two units it was 800 total feet divided into 2 wells. And drilling was in the area of 25% of the total cost. 50% for the units themselves, and I guess 25% for the other parts, labor, and misc stuff. While drilling is definitely a big chunk, all of it is so much more expensive than traditional air heat pumps that even without drilling it would still be at least 50% more expensive. Double without US Federal incentives.
- echelon 3y ago> Make drilling cheaper. How?
- iancmceachern 3y agoI've been wanting to build and try something like this: https://youtu.be/3pOSzBgB8WU?si=kCyDZA0GkKMFAzNH https://youtu.be/3pOSzBgB8WU?si=kCyDZA0GkKMFAzNH Could easily be improved upon, seems workable
- defrost 3y agoFor shallow dirt holes, sure. Not so great once the pressure increases or granite|schist layer intercede.
- 3y ago
- WarOnPrivacy 3y agoHVAC geo scales up. You could do a neighborhood utility and homes can heat/cool for the cost of air circ. You'll wind up with a novelty, an HOA that benefits every home (fees for for power/maint pumps). A couple of generations ago, we had neighborhood sewage utilities all around here. Neighborhood geo seems less complex than that.
- swamp_donkey 3y agoThis was tried using money for 2010 olympics in Whistler BC as the athlete accommodation was sold as subsidized housing to local workers after the olympics. The geothermal district heating project had many ongoing issues with repair costs being borne collectively by the new owners. Some saved $150/mo by removing it and switching to electric [0] 0: https://www.piquenewsmagazine.com/opinion/letter-to-the-editor-for-the-week-of-january-2-2509128 https://www.piquenewsmagazine.com/opinion/letter-to-the-edit...
- WarOnPrivacy 3y agoI appreciate the info. I'll give it a read.
- swamp_donkey 3y agoThere are probably a dozen articles on the issues in that pique news paper spanning a decade. Lots of finger pointing between the parties responsible for the design, installation and maintenance. The Vocal group of owners got bailed out by the local government at one point but it didn’t resolve the ongoing issues. Not to say the technology is hopeless, just in this instance it wasn’t done properly so maybe it isn’t as easy as people think.
- pjdesno 3y agoThere are some places (e.g. https://heet.org/geo/ https://heet.org/geo/) that are looking at neighborhood "geothermal" - basically using ground temperature as a heat reservoir for heat pumps. They're getting buy-in from natural gas utilities, some of whom see it as a way to keep using their capital, rights of way, and expertise in digging holes in the ground (and maybe in billing folks, too) to keep making money as households convert to heat pumps.
- edbaskerville 3y agoThis interview with Fervo CEO Tim Latimer on the Volts podcast was really fascinating: https://www.volts.wtf/p/enhanced-geothermal-power-is-finally https://www.volts.wtf/p/enhanced-geothermal-power-is-finally As a layperson I was certainly impressed by the notion that enhanced geothermal could get us the last x% of firm energy needed for a stable grid once solar+wind+batteries have gone as far as they can go. Another interesting tidbit is that you can actually use their system to store excess energy from, e.g., wind and solar.
- angiosperm 3y agoOnce we have plenty of solar and wind generation capacity built out, it will be time to start building out short-term storage. Until then, generating capacity is the best place to put capital. In time we will have tropical solar-powered ammonia synthesis, to ship to places that are in danger of draining short-term storage or are in polar night. So, "as far as they can go" is meaningless. They can go the whole way.
- bordercases 3y agoUse piezothermal cells
- nostromo 3y agoI used to worry that might cool down the earth’s interior too quickly and regret it with mass geothermal. But waste heat (not global warming from carbon, which is a separate and more pressing problem) will boil the oceans in a few hundred years on our current trajectory, and now I’m for cooling as much as possible however we can.
- stevenpetryk 3y agoApparently it could actually be beneficial to cool Yellowstone and prevent it from becoming active again.
- hunter2_ 3y agoI tried to search before asking, but only found the contrary. [0] How does this work? [0] https://www.usgs.gov/observatories/yvo/news/why-cant-we-drill-yellowstone-stop-eruptions-and-make-power https://www.usgs.gov/observatories/yvo/news/why-cant-we-dril...
- shagie 3y ago(It's partly a reference to a previous HN post) Could We Stop Yellowstone From Erupting with a Giant Geothermal Power Plant? - https://www.construction-physics.com/p/could-we-stop-yellowstone-from-erupting https://www.construction-physics.com/p/could-we-stop-yellows... https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35703906 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35703906 213 points | 8 months ago | 174 comments https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38596622 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38596622 141 points | 23 days ago | 137 comments
- EnigmaFlare 3y agoWow. Have you got a source for that? Waste heat from human power generation and use, not from the Earth cooling? Boil as in bubbles of steam or just slightly evaporate a little? A few hundred as in < 1000 years? And current trajectory as in something like exponential growth which obviously won't happen? I'm sure some part of that makes the idea far less serious than it sounds.
- nayuki 3y agoKudos to the rare American article that puts metric units first! (e.g. "seven kilometers (four miles)", "150 °C")
- hunter2_ 3y agoMight be their style, or could it be because geothermal is thriving and evolving in places using metric and rounding is problematic?
- pfdietz 3y agoOne possibility is further collapse of the price of other renewables. If solar were nearly free (< $0.01/kWh, say) it could make sense to bank that energy as underground heat. The thermal time constant for hot rocks scales as the square of the linear dimensions of the rocks, and can easily reach many years even for relatively shallow systems (this is why geothermal works at all). Such a system would not need to drill as deeply as a natural geothermal system operating at the same temperature, and might be able to get much hotter than anything not drilling near a volcano.