4 ms·
Red meat causes heart disease. Except when it doesn't?
- sickofparadox 3y agoAt the end of the day, this is the iterative process of science. Something as foundational to the average American's diet as red meat is going to be a difficult variable to isolate and weigh the costs of, and we may not even get an answer one way or another in my lifetime. For my part, I'll probably just keep eating it because red meat tastes good.
- MuffinFlavored 3y agoWhat if I ate 16oz (pre-cooked weight) of meat a day for 90 days, then I go get some bloodwork done? Would they be enough to be conclusive? What could we expect the bloodwork to show? https://youtu.be/IUYhhlNV-4o https://youtu.be/IUYhhlNV-4o Dr. Shawn Baker only eats meat
- raxxorraxor 3y ago> Since health recommendations are generalized for an entire population, it makes sense that experts target individual advice with the public in mind. I profoundly disagree here. I believe it would and should undermine trust in scientific publications if the results get framed with the intend to influence behavior. That is neither scientific nor helpful. Perhaps a statement would need to make sure it cannot be generalized as is. You can say that nuts are healthy for the most part, it won't immediately kill the people with allergies and you could also replicate the numbers game that was put forward as a justification to lie. Perhaps the result of a study needs to be put in context, if it is not "communicable" as is. But this is such an easy example to communicating the results that there shouldn't even be a thought wasted for the "correct" framing of a study.
- didgeoridoo 3y agoIt gets even worse when policy-level thinking gets incorporated — something like, “eating red meat causes climate change; climate change hurts people; therefore we declare that eating red meat hurts people.” The most obvious recent example of this was the health establishment supporting mass gatherings during the George Floyd protests, because of the argument that fighting racial inequities was even more critical to public health than stopping the spread of COVID. Trust in public health institutions has been consequently gutted, and I don’t see it coming back any time soon.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- 1905 3y agoIn the coming years we're going to see a war on meats as large organizations push their "environmentally friendly" patented protein sources. The small farmer will be pushed out with carbon taxes and other fees.
- 11235813213455 3y agomeat should be considered luxury, based on its footprint, so higher cost and people should consume much less of it, simple
- robocat 3y agoThe limit of that argument is that most everything is a luxury, that life itself is a luxury that should be taken away.
- 11235813213455 3y agoLuxury: "something adding to pleasure or comfort but not absolutely necessary" Talking, walking, breathing air, drinking water, eating cereal or local vegetables are not luxuries Talking to friends over phone, taking your car to gym to then run on a treadmill, drinking anything but water, smoking, eating meat/fish/dairy products/processed food are luxuries
- robocat 3y agoYour comment implies very deep inconsistency: your examples have no pattern that others outside of your circle might agree upon. Why should your personal "definition" of luxury be a golden standard for all? Cereal is an internationally traded commodity - the polar opposite of local produce. Local produce is often an expensive luxury in my experience. Even in my hippy experiences I don't think I've ever met someone who has grown their own oats. You define talking to friends over phone as a luxury - why? Is having time and opportunity to talk to friends in person a luxury? Are food standards a luxury? Is potable tap water a luxury? Historically beer was a means of providing safe drinking water. Was it a luxury when used for that purpose? Is commenting on an internet forum using your mobile phone a luxury? I am probably being provocative. However I think the questions above are simply implications of my comment.
- 11235813213455 3y agoRed meat causes environmental damages, because it requires so much more resources and pollution, this is more important There are people buying top grade meat for their pets, seriously, this is incredible, 1/5th of world meat production is used for pets btw
- Pooge 3y ago> 1/5th of world meat production is used for pets btw Could you give the source for this?
- 11235813213455 3y agohttps://www.huffingtonpost.co.uk/entry/would-you-feed-your-dog-insects-to-help-the-planet_uk_5c371958e4b045f676890c63 https://www.huffingtonpost.co.uk/entry/would-you-feed-your-d..., https://sentientmedia.org/pet-food-environmental-impact/ https://sentientmedia.org/pet-food-environmental-impact/
- ipaddr 3y agoIs it 1/3 or 20%. Who is estimating? This is junky science. The links talk about fish/meat not red meat.
- 11235813213455 3y agoread meat has an even higher impact than other meat, 2nd link shows what type of meat mostly compose pet food, and for the estimation there are enough numbers (just the number of million of tonnes of pet food is so huge and again doesn't take into account people buying the best meat fr their pets, or more rare people eating dog food..)
- ipaddr 3y agoThat meat is made up of organ meat humans don't consume.
- gmarx 3y agoBased on what is reported in the article (and without reviewing the review studies) we can only say that claiming in a survey to eat less red meat is associated with a small reduction in heart disease risk. After decades of nonsense high profile nutritional studies being presented then debunked the represented my policy is that I only believe large effects.
- drpgq 3y agoI wonder how much this risk compares to smoking a pack a day? Or being obese or sedentary?
- keernan 3y agoAm I reading the article correctly that it was published in Feb 2020?