6 ms·
I noticed some other weird design choices in the new tube stations as well. Eg air vents that are very fine and visibly clog up. It’s like they designed it to
by Havoc 3y ago
I noticed some other weird design choices in the new tube stations as well. Eg air vents that are very fine and visibly clog up.
It’s like they designed it to look shiny for day one but ignored decades of practical experience
- lhnz 3y agoIt's very difficult to make thousands of up-front planning decisions perfectly. It'd be even more costly to try to perfect every aspect upfront within the planning stage and it'd be more reasonable to make best attempts but to provide for the ability (and budget) to retrofit bespoke alterations to fix problems that arise at a later date.
- AlecSchueler 3y agoBut surely it should be simple enough to look at what alterations have been made on other lines already and start off from a basis that is at least as good.
- vidarh 3y agoOr they decided it was an opportunity to test potential improvements. Testing them on a new line where fixing any "improvements" that don't pan out will be perceived as an improvement might well be better than testing them on an old line where any regressions will be immediately perceived as such...
- martyvis 3y agoWith a constant rotation of contractors and the government staff overseeing them, offering innovative solutions at a better price than the next bidder, opportunities to learn from experience are difficult to achieve with large multi year projects
- lhnz 3y agoThe design and planning process for UK infrastructure is already notoriously expensive and we already do significantly more "planning" than we used to do 100 years ago (when we were actually capable of rapidly building high quality infrastructure). I would expect there to already be consultants doing similar to what you've suggested however the work is complex and many will be quite cut-off from the build process or only around in the short-term.
- bluGill 3y agowhile 100 years ago we built rapidly, there was a large cost in human lives. Planning is part of how we solved that - only part of it, but it is a factor.
- AlecSchueler 3y agoSounds like many of these issues could be described with better knowledge sharing and more tightly coupled processes between planning/building/maintenence. It sounds quite fatalistic what you've said, that we've basically reached maximum planning saturation so we can only pay the costs afterwards when things go wrong. But surely questioning these assumptions is good for our civic involvement and for the lines.
- lhnz 3y agoI agree that it would be fatalistic to not try to improve the situation using technology, I'm just trying to explain what happens as you try to do so with more planning.
- Wytwwww 3y ago> difficult to make thousands of up-front planning decisions perfectly. So don't. Just use something well tried and tested and don't try to be innovative (in areas we you can't dedicated significant amounts of resources for up-front planning)
- concordDance 3y agoThis seems a bit defeatist. Some hope for and striving for improvement is good for a society.
- captaincrisp 3y agoI feel the point is a bit subtler. We should strive for improvement. We should also understand that that takes more than the normal amount of resources to do something different and better & either commit to spending what's required or, if we can't afford to, use something already proven instead. The half-done or broken improvements still get called "innovations" and give innovation overall a worse reputation.
- kergonath 3y ago> I feel the point is a bit subtler. We should strive for improvement. We should also understand that that takes more than the normal amount of resources to do something different and better & either commit to spending what's required or, if we can't afford to, use something already proven instead. Indeed. I wish this point were articulated that way more often. > The half-done or broken improvements still get called "innovations" and give innovation overall a worse reputation. We fetishise innovation as an abstract concept, for good reasons because you cannot have progress without innovation. What we tend to miss is that while innovation is good, some specific innovations are terrible. This is particularly infuriating when they are re-surfacing old, solved problems. Looking at wall tiling for example (or the cladding that can be found in much of the Underground): this was a good solution to a common problem. Bare concrete walls have obvious downsides, which is why we don’t tend to use them in building anymore. Doing away with tiling or cladding sounds like an architect being innovative, but if the replacement does not solve the problem, it’s a regression. It will look modern and clean as long as it will be properly maintained, which is to say for about a year, and then it will decay the way concrete does. It will eventually be clad, or reviled as a post-modern monstrosity the way some bad brutalist buildings are today. Innovation for innovation’s sake is cargo culting progress. This is giving innovation a bad name.
- palemoonale 3y ago> It’s like they designed it to look shiny for day one but ignored decades of practical experience Modern software development, and especially UI design, in a nutshell.
- readthenotes1 3y ago[flagged]
- mytailorisrich 3y agoI have seen stations refurbished less than 10 years where the new benches had to be replaced because they were already falling apart after that time outdoors... On my commute they are fitting new cladding to hide a brick wall on an outdoor, not covered, platform. All the studwork is standard timber screwed into the wall. Any water ingress and this will rot quickly. Oh well.
- mattlondon 3y agoMight be pressure treated timber - looks largely the same as untreated wood from a distance and can last a long time in damp conditions. Many sheds and timber fences are pressure treated and last well - sure they wont last a lifetime or whatever, but will probably not rot "quickly"
- yetanotherloser 3y agoThere are also some heat treated modified timbers now which don't look like pressure treated sheds or fences but which are supposed to last well.
- bluGill 3y agoAll buildings - including stations should have maintenance schedules. There are things to do hourly (or when open), every 2 hours, 4 hours, daily, weekly, monthly, and yearly. In addition you have 5, 10, and 30 year remodel cycles. Of course you always have someone do urgent maintenance - if a pipe breaks you fix it now. However replacing that pipe might leave a poorly patched wall until the next 10 year cycle when the fix is made invisible. You have to empty trash, clean the floors, and other similar things several times per day. Every year you replace filters and do a deep cleaning. (check the documentation for equipment - sometimes this might be a 1 month cycle not 1 year!) You also do a full inspection of everything, touch up paint, and patch anything else. This should be very routine, and thus always cost the same (inflation adjusted). Every 5 years you repaint. You also replace carpet where overly stained. That is touch up the cosmetics in a more in depth way. However this is a small cost. Every 10 years you have to do significant work in the bathrooms (While toilets can last for centuries they start to look bad when you try in a commercial setting). If there is a kitchen it also needs significant work. Avoid moving major things, but this is a higher cost. You should probably be replacing benches on this schedule. Every 30 years you do a major remodel. Here is where you update everything at sometimes high cost. Add elevators if you don't have them. Expand the station footprint if it is too small (you need more stains). Move where the doors are. Change the station approaches. Add more bathrooms. This will be expensive.
- KptMarchewa 3y agoMight be better to clean the vents often than have something inside break due to debris. Of course, it requires to actually clean the vents...
- deutschepost 3y agoI heard that these small holes are supposed to be Helmholtz Resonators. If tuned to the right frequency, they can help with noise reduction. https://hackaday.com/2023/12/24/absorbing-traffic-noise-with-bricks-using-helmholtz-resonators/ https://hackaday.com/2023/12/24/absorbing-traffic-noise-with...
- nuc1e0n 3y agoWith holes like that, birds, bees and rats will nest in those bricks.
- pavel_lishin 3y agoI bet birds make excellent noise-absorbers.
- ametrau 3y agoRats also
- adolph 3y agoProbably clean up discarded biological matter pretty well. Rats have decent cognitive capabilities. I wonder if trained cleaning rats would displace the naughty variety. https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2022/feb/01/swedish-crows-pick-up-cigarette-butts-litter https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2022/feb/01/swedish-...
- bluenose69 3y agoI've seen similar things where I work. In a new building, the architects called for small air vents that would look nice according to some aesthetic criterion. Unfortunately, the vents were so small that, to maintain air flow, the fans inside them had to spin so fast they screamed. This made for a very unpleasant environment. This was where high-profile events tended to take place, to show off the bright new shiny things. But you couldn't hear yourself think there. The solution? They turned off the fans a short time before important visitors arrived. I learned of this when I was chatting with a worker who deals with such things. Apparently, the people who were installing these vents knew that they would be a problem. But who were they going to complain to? The architects don't work here, and the local managers don't listen to their underlings. There are lots of stories like this in many work environments. I think the common thread is that high mucky-mucks are not interested in talking with the people who are doing the labour.
- lhnz 3y agoThis is a negative outcome of the Town and Country Planning Act. We've mandated by law that all planning is done upfront and due to the possibility of construction fraud provide detailed designs to building contractors that disallow them from substituting any materials or design choices without it being explicitly requested by the employer. In theory, there can be conversation between individual subcontractors and the project managers or architects, but in practice these are not always on site at the same time and there are significant costs involved in changes as well as issues with trust. Therefore, we effectively have a very expensive waterfall process that everybody is legally obligated to follow.
- michaelt 3y agoIf it's your project, you can order the builders to reconfigure the ventilation ducts pretty much however you like. Building control require that an architect sign off on things like the size of the beam holding the roof up. If you change that, the architect will have to sign off on the building as constructed before building control will approve it. Planning permission is given on the basis of external appearance, so you can't change too much in that area - but go look at some planning applications, they're very light on details. But other than that? If it's your project and you tell the electrician putting in a socket to put it somewhere else, he'll tell you if it's legal under the wiring regulations, and if it is, he'll move it. The main reason that in large projects builders are required to build exactly to the plan is to stop them substituting cheaper materials. They're under great pressure to do that, because if you allow your builders to replace expensive zinc cladding with cheap ACM cladding, and you ask several builders to tender and choose the cheapest builder, you'll always choose the builder who quoted on the basis of the cheap ACM cladding.
- adhesive_wombat 3y agoVery many older (and not even that old) tube stations have glossy tiled walls[1], presumably because they're easy to clean with just a cloth. Choosing bare concrete looks cool, and you don't need to pay a tiler to install them, but anyone who has ever done any amount of cleaning ever will tell you a smooth, porous surface like that will look grungy soon enough and be basically impossible to clean by hand. [1]: not only the London Underground: glossy wider-than-long tiles aren't generally called "metro tiles" for nothing
- bane 3y agoJust to note, most of the underground stations on the Washington D.C. metro system are bare concrete. The way the stations are constructed, using a low barrier wall, discourages people from touching the main station walls. The low light kind of also helps hide some of the grime. But overall they're relatively clean. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Washington_Metro https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Washington_Metro
- surfingdino 3y agoIf it was bare concrete, you could put tiles over it, but these are removable panels made of "glass fibre reinforced concrete" according to their proud manufacturer https://www.brydenwood.com/projects/elizabeth-line-cladding-design/s1139/ https://www.brydenwood.com/projects/elizabeth-line-cladding-...
- mrguyorama 3y agoThis is the obvious outcome when society rewards the manager who boosts the stock price this quarter (at a future cost) more than the manager that makes sure the company will survive for a hundred years.