3 ms·
Oh I can imagine a world without work. Just not such a world in which most people don't starve except for the privileged minority. Issues: 1. Lack of work wil
by kazinator 3y ago
Oh I can imagine a world without work. Just not such a world in which most people don't starve except for the privileged minority.
Issues:
1. Lack of work will cause billions of people to drift around with no purpose, leading to serious social problems.
2. Work cannot be absolutely eliminated. Because the machine which feeds, clothes and houses people will need to be understood and maintained. If several generations of people literally don't do any work, including learning how to maintain the utopia, it will all go to hell in a houndbasket.
3. Some of those who choose to work won't necessarily want to coddle the others. They will view the majority of nonworking people as a superfluous load on the planet, that serves no purpose.
4. Some people work not just to sustain themselves, but for the sake of the work. Not only would it be cruel to take work away from them, but you basically cannot do that. Those people will find something to work on.
- ceejayoz 3y ago1. Plenty of non-workers have purpose in life. Ask a retiree. 2. This assumes we can never make machines that maintain themselves. Opinions on how likely AI vary, but being unable to imagine it at all is odd. 3. We already deal with these folks today. 4. No one's proposing banning work. Just that it'd be nice not to require it to live.
- kazinator 3y agoOnce you make machines that maintain themselves, you're superfluous.
- kazinator 3y agoPlenty of retirees feel empty and lost, and end up going to some kind of work.
- ceejayoz 3y agoSee #4. Someone else in the thread referenced Brooks from Shawshank Redemption; I think it's an apt comparison. A life lived believing work is the only purpose may well convince some that's the truth; they've become institutionalized.
- antisthenes 3y ago1. A proper retiree who is able to indulge in hobbies is very different from someone barely sustaining themselves on basic income (?) or a version of it. 2. Sure, but in the near future this is baseless techno-optimism just like fusion or colonizing the Solar System 3. Today they are a vocal, but mostly powerless minority. They cannot, by and large affect national welfare programs. Imagine if such a small minority held power over all means of housing and production? 4. Some work will always be required, even just to live. For now, to maintain a western developed standard of living, it's actually quite a bit of work, when you consider e.g. high tech electronics, transportation system, healthcare. You're countering your own strawman arguments here.
- FooBarBizBazz 3y ago1. It's said that Britain produced its greatest rock 'n roll when it had the dole. They even rhyme. Point being -- I'm not sure that people need gobs of wealth to make art or to pursue other things that bring them satisfaction. UBI might lead to increases in certain kinds of intrinsically-motivated production. 4. If the western developed standard of living requires too much work, then one way out may be to abandon that standard. Perhaps it is a failed experiment. People in poor countries don't seem any less happy to me.
- kazinator 3y ago> People in poor countries don't seem any less happy to me. A good way to show that would be to stop activities like, oh, learning English and emigrating.