6 ms·
Japan's 18-year-olds at record-low 1.06 million
- jncfhnb 3y agoA strange thing though. Walking through Japan I saw many more young people and parents with children than I am used to in the states.
- ecedeno 3y ago> Walking This is why
- bombcar 3y agoYes. In America the children are transported in motorized divisions. The US is a little over double Japan’s population and has 4x the number of 18 year olds.
- jimberlage 3y agoI live in a very dense area of the US midwest (still single family homes, but shotgun style houses) and I see a lot more young people and parents! I think it’s the density and walkability. I’m told Japan is really good at both of those things.
- anon291 3y agoThat's because in the United States, children and people in general are cooped up in these crazy things called 'cars'
- jimmyed 3y agoThe solution to Japan's problem is mass import of highly educated, non radical people who are a net positive contribution to Japanese society. India, China, S Korea are good candidates.
- kardianos 3y agoThat moves the problem around. That doesn't "fix" any problem.
- somewhereoutth 3y agoChina is already facing the same issue - regardless of exhortations by the CCP, people just aren't having kids.
- faeriechangling 3y agoAll 3 countries have a birthrate below replacement. Highly educated, non radical people are those not having babies to begin with. At some point society will either reckon with its values and value raising children more highly, or generations of highly educated non radical people will keep wiping themselves from the gene pool until things balance themselves out.
- ProcNetDev 3y agoOr we could just allow immigration?
- aegypti 3y agoThe median ages of South Korea and China are 45 and 40!
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- conductr 3y agoI’m not an expert by any means, but aren’t they too concerned with cultural purity to ever really consider this? I feel like they would have already started down this path if they weren’t.
- A_D_E_P_T 3y ago> India This is an extremely bad idea. It's hard to imagine two cultures less compatible. Indians would have a very rough time in Japan -- imagine being effectively ostracized and forever unable to integrate into society (and not only yourself, but also your descendants!) -- and the average Japanese won't last 10 minutes in India without having a nervous breakdown on account of unsanitary conditions, lack of personal space, interpersonal aggression, etc.
- somewhereoutth 3y agoDemographic collapse in advanced nations is an existential threat to our civilization, if not our species. As much as climate change. We need to remove as many impediments as we can to child birth and rearing - for example changing how we work so that children are compatible with productive and fulfilling careers (and indeed lives as a whole).
- FirmwareBurner 3y ago>Demographic collapse in advanced nations is an existential threat to our civilization But it makes landlords and housing business owners great profits.
- KoftaBob 3y agoWouldn't it do the opposite? You end up with fewer people competing for housing over time.
- FirmwareBurner 3y agoNot if you look at internal and external migration. Housing has gone up in the big cities of countries with declining demographics because the places where demographics are declining are villages and small towns because everyone is moving to the big cities with jobs and universities which see virtually unlimited demand irregardless of local demographics. Look at Germany, Italy, Balkans, etc. all have declining demographics ranging from slight to severe yet housing in their cities has gone up from slight to severe. Like everything in real estate, it's all about the location location location, so everything is localized not extrapolated to the whole country it's why demographics can be steeply declining but prices steeply going up in cities. Unless you want to live in desolate villages with no infrastructure or jobs, urban housing prices isn't tracking demographics. Edit: to downvoters, check the numbers please
- thriftwy 3y agoEverybody would be moving to the big citiea regardless. It would just be even less affordable.
- stephc_int13 3y agoI know that many people are afraid of this demographic shift, but while I think this will certainly require societal adaptations, I think this is overall a extremely good thing. Over-population would be a much more difficult problem to manage, I am not sure about the optimal human population for this planet, but I am fairly certain that a stable population is much better than a quickly growing one. Quick decline can also be an issue at some point, but in my opinion there is a tight relationship between population density and the housing market, the latter acting as a bottleneck, and if I am right the whole thing should be self-correcting. The next generations will have more space than they need for themselves, that will naturally lower the barrier to have multiple Childs.
- greatpostman 3y agoWe’re not even close to overpopulation
- nikhilsimha 3y ago/s ?
- FirmwareBurner 3y agoOnly of you ignore CO2 and other environmentally damaging emissions that stem from needing to feed and push millions more people out of poverty into the middle class where they also start to consume and travel and produce emissions. So yes, the planet can theoretically sustain billions more people but only if you look at planetary free square footage per capita, but at the cost of either them living in absolute poverty, or insane environmental damage and climate change which will also create poverty from the issues climate change will cause to agriculture and food prices, so we're back to millions living or dying in poverty. Canada and Australia are huge countries but the livable parts are quite small. You can't have infinite growth on a planet of finite resources.
- freshpots 3y agoWell said, many seem to conflate abundant space (habitable or not) with resources as if they are evenly distributed and consumed.
- lgkk 3y agoI agree with Tucker Carlson from what he said on all in podcast about Japan. Yes the population decline is alarming but does slowing growth really matter when you have a strong culture? I don’t believe the solution to their problem is importing random people who share nothing in common with their culture. The Japanese should be able to maintain their culture and I am sure they will bounce back. They owe it to nobody to radically change their culture to appease some number crunchers. And I say this as an immigrant to US. I’ve been to Japan and it’s just quite amazing.
- b0bb1z3r0 3y ago[dead]
- jakderrida 3y ago> Yes the population decline is alarming but does slowing growth really matter when you have a strong culture? Wtf is "strong culture"? I guarantee your answer would be different than Tucker Carlson's because he never intended it to be defined. It's just a fake term he made up because, in the heads of his mindless listeners, it invokes the idea that some cultures are superior, but deliberately with no criteria to define it.
- tesdinger 3y agoA population that consists of more retired elders than workers is a problem. There are no automated retirement homes and more medical workers are needed as well.
- ProcNetDev 3y agoBeing anti-emigration seems to be winning in the minds of pretty much every rich nation right now. But it is just bad policy: https://www.aeaweb.org/articles?id=10.1257/jep.25.3.83 https://www.aeaweb.org/articles?id=10.1257/jep.25.3.83 People said the same thing about the Irish and the Italians in the US. It was wrong & racist then and it is wrong & racist now.
- krapp 3y agoFirst, Japan's entire history is a story of radically changing their culture. Adaptation and cultural syncretism is the norm, not the exception. Also, the vast majority of immigrants to Japan will always be from other Asian countries. It seems like a stretch to assume none of their neighbors (from whom Japan adapted much of their own culture) share anything in common with them. But of course, this isn't about Japan. It never is. This argument is always an orientalist proxy for Western xenophobia and racial prejudice. A polite way to say "I don't like the brown people in my country who speak a different language and worship strange gods, wouldn't it be nice if we could be more like the noble Japanese, who are willing to fall on their katanas and go extinct rather than suffer the impurity of foreign blood?"
- b0bb1z3r0 3y ago[dead]
- globalise83 3y agoSomething a little sad about this loss of youth from our cultures. Instead of seeing new trends and radical fashions everything seems just as it was 20 years ago except the young are more reticent. A critical mass of boisterous youth is needed for the production of new culture, and I suspect that in ageing societies we fell below that threshold about 2 decades ago.
- ImAnAmateur 3y agoThat critical mass may be online now. And the internet is so silo'd that it may not form or may not be noticed.
- woleium 3y agoit feels like we are all walled off from anything but our own echo chambers :(
- MichaelZuo 3y agoThis is an interesting observation, it might not even be possible for the vast majority of users, by definition, to be outliers enough to move the needle appreciably. i.e. readers will only care to remember the most notable/unique/etc... fraction of comments. And everything else will just meld together into one big mental blob. Maybe that is why there's been a flight to smaller online communities?, even 'Joe Average' has realistic prospects of writing something memorable if there's only a few hundred folks to compare against.
- spaceambienceyt 3y agoLiterally impossible given the size of the internet. It's not like there are groups out there funded to control discourse or introduce/censor topics for their own nefarious (relative and inconsequential in the scope of history) goals. They have nothing to gain at all from such distraction, thats what Netflix is for. Society has never been freer in terms of personal expression! Your comment is actually ludicrous and ridiculous. The focus on more important issues, as is apparent in the open forum, will only naturally arise. There is no fear of doing essentially nothing, repeating the same pointless discourse... for what may now seem like in perpetuity, and all the while never progressing, with 'frivolous discourse' and trivial ego-protecting topics (let's be honest, we are all free-thinking individuals here), for another year. And perhaps the year after as well.
- _fat_santa 3y agoWhile population decline I see as a major issue, the more pressing issue is that our social services will collapse. Other comments have said that social services are basically a Ponzi scheme, where the younger generation subsidizes the older generation. It's not hard to believe but then the next questions is: what are we going to do about it? Eventually the age bell curve is going to start trending up for the older folks and were are going to have vastly more people taking out of the system than folks putting into the system.
- stephc_int13 3y agoPart of the social security system is built as a Ponzi, but we often forget that kids and teens are also economically inactive, having less of them means more money for the old.
- Engineering-MD 3y agoHopefully automation will help somewhat. But really we need to invest more in treatments for ageing and senescence, which is woefully underfunded.
- stephc_int13 3y agoFor any living species the population is self-regulated by the ecosystem. We're no different. We've been able to change our ecosystem with technology and thus greatly expand our population. But there are limits, always. And we're lucky that this self-regulation is still operating (I think that the housing market is acting as the signal for us) otherwise we would have to endure an ecosystem collapse at some point.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- iteratethis 3y agoWhen people are free to decide how many children they want, this amounts to 0, 1 or 2 typically. Which averages out to about 1.5-1.8 in most developed nations, which is significantly below replacement rate. Japan is an extreme case. People often blame the cost of living. Whilst it doesn't help, it's not the root cause. The root cause is straightforward: people simply do not WANT more children. Those that want children, will often have 2. There's very little reason to have 3, 4, 5 or more once you have 2. Two children already dominate your life so there's little incentive to just let the number grow arbitrarily. And having more than 2 children has very real consequences. For your home, your car, your schedule, your sanity. Even most millionaires will not have a huge amount of children. Bottom line: most people still want children and will have 2. Which is not enough to cover the replacement rate. No policy, monetary or otherwise, will significantly move the needle. Japan's issue is the above universal behavior combined with additional local constraints. As also seen in South Korea and China, the "work yourself to death culture whilst also financially supporting your ageing parents" means your culture as a whole ultimately goes extinct. It makes family formation near-impossible. Instead of working more we should work less if we're interested in continued existence. The world won't move in that direction though it's "all hands on board" to deal with the current ageing society. Mass immigration doesn't solve this. It's a brain drain for those countries, but also consider that a giant population of young people will turn into a giant population of old people, requiring even more young people. Which won't happen because also in developing countries the birth rate is in decline. A very dark conclusion you could make is that people get too old.