9 ms·
Notation Must Die: The Battle for How We Read Music [video]
- atonalfreerider 3y agoA VR app called PianoVision has changed my musical life. People need to be open to breaking the boundaries and constraints of paper and rectangular screens, and go 3d and spatial with data display.
- vim-guru 3y agoPianoVision is great! We just need a DrumVision, GuitarVision, ThereminVision, NyckelharpaVision....
- tgv 3y ago[flagged]
- andrewflnr 3y agoI'm not saying you should watch the 75 minute video, but if you don't, then you definitely shouldn't air your ignorant assumptions about its contents. You know, just in case you're wildly wrong.
- darajava 3y agoHe was right to not watch the video. I regret it, it has no substance.
- tgv 3y agoWhich part is wrong? He does plug musescore. And it is an overview of notation history. And the title is clickbait.
- andrewflnr 3y agoNotation history, as a normal person would read the phrase, is only a portion of the video. And the title, unless you think "battle" must imply literal combat, is an accurate representation of the views of many of the people he talks about. He does mention musescore, with full acknowledgement of his affiliation. Have a point for that.
- tgv 3y agoThe title says "die". That suggests a very aggressive and negative attitude towards notation. As does "battle", by the way. It is clickbait.
- andrewflnr 3y agoYeah, and he showcases a lot of people with an aggressive and negative attitude toward notation. Did you still not actually watch the video?
- TylerE 3y agoEspecially since he has a history of shall we say questionable ethics. He posted a video trashing Dorico, a notation software. He was shortly thereafter hired by kusescore, and the next version of musescore ripped off large elements of Dorico wholesale.
- vintermann 3y agoAs I recall, he was much more positive to Dorico than to Finale and Sibelius. Didn't Musescore's owners reach out and hire him because they liked the criticism in that video? And you know, in between the animations of Russian composers vomiting, he did make some solid criticism about music software UI design. It was clear he had done some serious thinking about it.
- jraph 3y agoAbsolutely. In no way his video about Dorico was trashing. He did raise seemingly valid criticism in an entertaining way (to each their own about that last part). I don't quite get the hatred Tantacrul is getting here. About taking UI/UX idea from other products: I don't know if he actually did, but this constantly happens and this is not stealing. If nobody did, each program would come with its own UX and it would be a nightmare.
- TylerE 3y agoWhen you go grow a multicolor tab bar, and just happen to use a near identical colors to your compeitors. I'm not even talking true UI... just cloing look and feel wholesale with the serial numbers filed off...
- jraph 3y agoWhich tab bar? I don't see anything particularly colored on my copy of MuseScore 4.2 (openSUSE Tumbleweed, KDE). There's a tab bar at the top (Home, Score, Publish) and it seems to follow the system colors. If both Dorico and MuseScore do this, they will end up with the same colors. More specifically, apparently they are both based on Qt [1], so of course they will look a bit similar if they use the standard widgets. Looking at screenshots of Dorico, I don't see any outstanding, shocking resemblance with MuseScore. Both tools have their visual identity. Is it a personal opinion you have on this? Has someone written something on it this I could check out? Anyway, I don't have much against clones. Which MuseScore and Dorico aren't. [1] https://blog.dorico.com/2022/01/the-story-of-dorico-4s-development/ https://blog.dorico.com/2022/01/the-story-of-dorico-4s-devel...
- jraph 3y agoTantacrul has been making videos about music far before he joined Muse. He is into UX and music. What is he supposed to do? Avoid getting a fitting job? Stop making related videos if he does? I watched the video when it was released. I guess he mentions MuseScore but I don't remember this. I think I would have remembered an unwarranted mention though. His insight into MuseScore is likely to please his subscribers. And of course the video thumbnail and the title are clickbait. Most mildly successful channel do this because it's pretty much a condition for success on YouTube. I guess blame YouTube or possibly human nature for this. I didn't find the content deceitful. I liked the video, it was quite interesting and entertaining.
- prvc 3y agoCan we get a short summary of this 76 minute video?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- edjw 3y ago[dead]
- brylie 3y agoTLDR from a memory of watching this video a couple of months ago: Despite many attempts at various musical notation systems, they all have trade-offs. Detractors of standard music notation aren't always forthcoming with the trade-offs of alternatives, if they even suggest an alternative. Due to the nuances and complexity of music, standard music notation is about the best system we have iteratively developed over the past few centuries to describe music in a way that is cross-compatible with so many instruments and techniques.
- brylie 3y agoHere's a Kagi summary: Notation Must Die explores the history and criticism of modern Western music notation. It discusses early Greek, medieval and Renaissance notation systems and how Guido of Arezzo standardized staff lines and solfege in the 11th century. Mensural notation was then developed to notate rhythm and meter. The video examines attempts to reform notation over centuries and alternative systems proposed but argues standard notation remains dominant due to its balance and universality. An interesting aspect discussed is how notation is sometimes seen as elitist despite being accessible with education. While no system is presented as a clear replacement, the video shows notation continues evolving with new adapted forms developed for different musical styles.
- prvc 3y agoRight. Roughly the consensus view! Shame on him for the clickbait title, though.
- jraph 3y ago
- adamddev1 3y agoI like the idea at the end about a standardized data format, which would allow the musical data to be arbitrarily rendered in any notation. Kind of like an "interior language" or an "internal symantic representation", sort of how we use ASTs to represent code.
- eternityforest 3y agoIsn't that MIDI?
- vintermann 3y agoI had hopes for this video, but he didn't really go in-depth on the serious/successful reform projects. We're all literate here. But very few of us can sight-sing. Attempts to teach musical literacy like reading literacy on a mass scale have failed. Or have they? Some efforts have done much better than others. I looked into a guy called Lars Roverud, crediting with reforming church singing in Norway in the 19th century. His system was a simple one based on numbers, very similar to the Chinese one briefly touched on in Tantacrul's video. It worked really well. Then there's the American shape note tradition. I'd say that's an impressive success: regular churchgoers, not just an especially talented choir, actually learn to sight-sing three and four-part harmony. They don't just learn the melodies by heart, they can actually flip to a new song and sing it. They rely on a partially symbolic system, and on harmonization conventions. There are actually a lot of didactic music success stories, and what virtually all of them have in common is a symbolic system for pitch/harmony. But what those systems also have in common, is that most of the benefit to literacy is gone a generation after someone says, "how great! now you should advance to real music notation!"
- Kwpolska 3y agoHave there been serious attempts to widely teach musical literacy?
- jedrek 3y agoI didn't have it in the US in the 1980s, and my wife didn't have it in Poland in the 1980s/1990s either.
- vintermann 3y agoHow do you define it, then? You never had recorder lessons in elementary school?
- Kwpolska 3y agoDo recorder lessons involve any music theory? Do they include learning notation? Or just blindly making different sounds, or learning just the specific ways to manipulate an instrument?
- harryvederci 3y agoThe transition from the chess intro to music notation at around 9:30 is amazing :D
- QVVRP4nYz 3y agoI watched it before and the thing that I will forever remember from it was the "jubilate": https://youtu.be/Eq3bUFgEcb4?t=1346 https://youtu.be/Eq3bUFgEcb4?t=1346
- kaapipo 3y agoFun fact: he is also the main designer of Musescore and Audacity
- darajava 3y agoHe doesn’t really go into the problems of modern music notation in any depth, and he implies that the solution is that ugly numbering system. He doesn’t mention at all the incredible expressiveness of the notation system that was the result of thousands of years of human innovation. I feel weirdly cheated after watching this whole thing, like I could have gotten all the info from reading a 400 word article.
- tumult 3y agoWhat? Did we watch the same video? The opposite is true. A large portion of the video covers the history of notation and how expressive it is. And he specifically doesn't say that an ugly numbering system is the solution. In fact, the opposite.
- vintermann 3y agoYes. Given how hard he trashed Finale and Sibelius, I would have thought he'd be less defensive about traditional western notation. But while he mentioned some other systems in actual use and did distinguish between crazy reformers and serious/established reform proposals, he spent most of the video deriding crazy reformers and defending the traditional one. The best he said about "ugly numbering systems" was roughly what most conservatorians say (roughly paraphrased): "that's interesting, maybe it could have some limited didactic use."
- praptak 3y agoSo I just started piano (got one for Christmas). Notation is a PITA but the effort to decipher is still orders of magnitude easier than actually playing anything. I can imagine the effort ratio gets even more skewed by the time you get to the level at which you could invent a better notation, so in the end nobody bothers.
- josephg 3y agoI don’t think you can accurately extrapolate from one week of piano experience. If you keep at it, I suspect how it feels to play in 6 months or 6 years from now will be very different from how it feels to play now. I’ve been playing piano casually for about 18 months now. I can sight read easy music (though I can’t play smoothly) and I can play a bit of jazz. Physically playing the instrument - hitting the notes I intend to hit - is pretty easy. But reading sheet music (and especially reading the rhythm) is absolutely my bottleneck right now when it comes to performance. I’m sympathetic to the problem - improving sheet music notation seems hard. But learning it really is a hassle.
- jacquesm 3y agoIf you have a piano with MIDI I'd love it if you as a beginner would give pianojacq.com a workout and let me know what you find could be improved. It's super hard to go back to that first impression state and your feedback would be very valuable. Regardless: congrats on getting an instrument and starting out on it!
- parasti 3y agoMusical notation is fine. But you have to go out of your way to encounter it. By comparison, written text is literally everywhere. I walked past a couple of pages of accumulated text just by walking to work and did not see a single musical symbol anywhere.
- 112233 3y agoMusical notation is absolutely terrible, possibly even as terrible as written english, just in different ways. Not only you cannot infer anything from context while reading for the first time (unlike with english), modal markings that completely change meaning of most symbols are scattere all over — slightly to the left, slightly above, left margin, top of the page etc
- randomdata 3y agoLike a lot of things in life, it's fine. Not good. We could do a lot better, but only with considerable human effort, for which there is not a strong incentive.
- valdiorn 3y agoI read the title and immediately thought "god, another know-it-all that thinks they can design a better music notation system. He clearly hasn't seen Tantacrul's video on the subject" :)
- decasia 3y agoMy experience with classical musical notation (as a pianist) is that it gets much easier to read the more you understand the conventions of the music. After you have a sense of what conventional classical music sounds like, of the kinds of scales and melodies and patterns that it usually uses, then when you look at a new piece, you aren't starting from scratch; you are pattern matching against a document that contains mostly familiar idioms. And that makes it much, much faster and easier than reading something completely unfamiliar or avant-garde. This is true with some kinds of jazz too: after you've played enough jazz standards, it gets easier to sight-read a jazz piece from a fake book, and have it come out pretty much right the first time. The chords are mostly what you expect, the melody uses familiar scales, and so on. It's not that things have to be 100% in genre, but if they are 80% in genre, then that reduces cognitive load immensely, and it's easy to cope with the 20% that is more surprising. It's easy to think of a musical genre as being something that provides comfort and familiarity (if not boredom) to the listeners, but it's interesting to think about musical genres as a sort of shortcut that helps the performers as well. I don't think there is any truly universal musical language and notation. It depends on the specific kind of music you care about. That being said - the other thing that made sheet music easier for me was taking a year of voice lessons. I came away more attuned to melodies than I used to be and better at understanding them on the page.
- bombcar 3y agoPeople not “used” to music don’t realize that for any particular segment, there’s really not an infinite number of possible “next notes” - just like when reading English and you see a three letter word starting “ca” it’s only got a few options to finish it up: b,d,m,n,p,r,t,w kinda thing.
- feoren 3y agoThat's not reading. That's guessing. Look up the "three cueing system" for reading. It's a workaround for bad readers. You're saying that people can read music, unless the music does something unexpected, and then they'd play the wrong thing. And possibly never know it. So they're not reading music at all. Why bother? Can you pronounce these fake words? I'll bet your pronunciation is basically the same as everyone else with a similar accent. Yet none of the middle letters are on your list. That's because you can read. Advocating for guessing what the next note is when sight-reading is terrible advice. You will learn the song wrong and never fully un-learn it. Caquin Caanin Cazin Cayin Cacin
- p0w3n3d 3y agoMy one and only accusation to the musical notation is that sometimes some information is hidden (like swing, slide, accents) in the music genre or context, and I am unable to play it correctly unless I have heard it before (or at least learned something similar in the context it was created in). But the more pieces I learn to play, the more I will be able to play. It's like a language. If you just started, don't complain about the spelling rules or idioms. Just learn them and you will flow. I also tend to help myself by rewriting parts of the music to the computer (musescore), especially in case of some really messed up rhythms, however, if there is contextual information in it, the computer won't help me here.
- viraptor 3y agoIt's healthy to complain about things sometimes. That's how we get an occasional refresh of spelling or grammar in many languages. I may not have a solution to this, or be very skilled, but will still complain about how (for example) multiple voices on one sheet sometimes require guessing, because there's some implicit idea about which pauses were skipped. Also, the spelling "rules" in English are terrible. Both beginners and experienced users should be free to complain about that.
- footlose_3815 3y agoIf they could redo figured bass, it would give me some confidence that they aren’t stuck in their ways.
- jinushaun 3y agoI’m currently teaching myself piano and saw this video a few weeks ago. I can barely read music (only 3 weeks in!) and this video still didn’t provide a compelling alternative! Tabs make sense for guitars but the treble + bass staffs are easier to read for piano.
- archagon 3y agoIn case anyone is interested, I played around with a novel musical notation paradigm in the form of an iPad app a few years ago: http://composerssketchpad.com http://composerssketchpad.com (I don't think it works anymore, and I don't have the ability to update it at the moment due to work conflicts. Also, sorry for the crappy trailers: I barely knew what I was doing back then!) Basically, you draw pitches directly on a horizontally-infinite canvas. By default, pitches stick to equal temperament gridlines, but you can turn off this snapping if you want to play around with a microtonal tuning or annotate a bendy guitar solo. The intent was to create a notation system that's intuitively usable and (theoretically) able to represent any pitch-based music. I wanted to add the ability to specify arbitrary snapping grids as a v1.1 feature, but I ran out of time. Will come back to it someday; hope to move it to a more universal platform and add power user functionality that would take it out of the "toy" category and turn it into an actually useful compositional tool. Also, this was before MIDI 2.0, so arbitrary per-note pitch bending was implemented as a huge hack — definitely looking forward to that refactor. None of this is intended for sight reading, though. It's more about being able to jot down completely arbitrary pitches with relative ease.
- greenbit 3y agoHeads up, that's about an hour and 15 minutes of video, the first 10 minutes of which actually talks about chess as an example of the sort of perspective that will be applied to the music problem.
- jacquesm 3y agoYes, it's pretty roundabout. But interesting!
- trilbyglens 3y agoPretty much any argument that gives proper context for a complex thing requires backgrounding the argument.
- bjoli 3y agoNow I have something to refer to every time I hear someone complain about the standard notation. I am an orchestra musician, and about once a year someone comes up with a system with more shortcomings than benefits. I have started using the socratic method, but I have had conversations that ended with people saying that it isn't a problem to not be able to write triplets. "Then you switch to 6/8".
- djtango 3y agoyes - perhaps other systems can can capture the simpler cases, but standard music notation has been battle tested against many instruments and multi instrument. And iterated on for literally centuries. It's fine to acknowledge there is a barrier to entry and there may be better DSLs specific to particular use cases but it's also a shame that we have this one language that has captured so much of existing music already
- vintermann 3y agoThe question is what is music notation even supposed to be. Is the purpose of music notation to be something you can set in front of a musician and make them play the music the way you want? In that case it performs pretty well, though it varies widely by instrument (both the ability to let them perform, and the actual notation). But if the purpose is music literacy, letting regular people read a score and be able to hear the music in their head, then it's not working well. Even experienced musicians (like I assume OP is) usually associate notation not with sound, but with finger and lip positions first, the means needed to reproduce it. And only then, sometimes, from finger positions to sounds. I remember the band kids in ear training classes in high school wiggling three fingers, playing an imaginary trumpet, in order to be able to sight sing. The reason I'm interested in alternative notation is that I dream of being able to read music like I read text. Who wouldn't want that? And despite having learned to sight read on some instruments and to sight sing reasonably, I don't feel like I can do that.
- TylerE 3y ago99% of that is audition, not score reading. Reading a score mechanically is not difficult after a few not-especially steep hills are climbed.
- brudgers 3y agoMy only criticism is Tantacrul doesn't mention tracker notation. While I don't disagree with his conclusion about the advantages of conventional notation -- I kept thinking about Iverson's Notation as a tool of Thought as I watched the video -- I do think that tracker notation might be roughly equivalent to conventional notation as a way of thinking about music. It just that tracker notation isn't optimized for tonal harmony (aka the music of dead German men) and staff notation is. Instead tracker notation is optimized for precision and machine reproduction. Tracker notation directly facilitates complex musical composition by an individual, performance by an individual, and mass dissemination of those compositions. Essentially, Tantacrul's argument is premised on the necessity of paper and meatware performance. Don't misunderstand me, I think MuseScore is awesome and recently I've found composing in staff notation valuable and efficient. This is just a critique of his essay. And perhaps a deeper criticism is that his assumption of tonal harmony and paper and meatspace may reflect the kind of bias about the nature of music he criticizes elsewhere. I mean trackers are a "folk art" technology. They are a very plain and intellectually accessible way of notating music. The verbosity of tracker notation means a person can gain competence in a matter of hours rather than years. Tracker notation removes the social gatekeeping that accompanies traditional western music education (that criticism isn't wrong). I mean staff notation puts tonal harmony at the center of composition. Percussion and microtones get short shrift...nevermind samples and noise and effects (what is the musical notation for a dotted quarter note delay?). None of this means I didn't enjoy the video. And none of it means I want to have an argument. Notation as a tool of thought: https://www.jsoftware.com/papers/tot.htm https://www.jsoftware.com/papers/tot.htm
- andrewflnr 3y ago"Tracker notation" is basically the same as the "piano roll" he talks about, right? Anyway, I think "meatware performance" also underlies the criticisms he's responding to of standard notation as applied to music students, most of whom are trying to physically play instruments (those trying to compose on a computer are indeed on a completely different track that doesn't need to care about paper or performance). So he may have picked it up from that context of the whole which-notation question. Hopefully this doesn't count as "having an argument". :)