4 ms·
i'd never seen steamboat willie before; now that it's public domain in the usa, i have wp says: > In the 1950s, Disney removed a scene where Mickey tugs on th
by kragen 3y ago
i'd never seen steamboat willie before; now that it's public domain in the usa, i have
wp says:
> In the 1950s, Disney removed a scene where Mickey tugs on the tails of the baby pigs, picks up the mother and kicks them off her teats, and plays her like an accordion, since television distributors deemed it inappropriate.[34] Since then, the full version of the film was included on the 1998 compilation VHS The Spirit of Mickey and the Walt Disney Treasures DVD set "Mickey Mouse in Black and White", as well as on Disney+.
this version has the tugging on tails, but not the picking up and accordioning of the mother, so it's a falsified version
the version xdennis linked https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Jap-UBbmPsw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Jap-UBbmPsw in https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38830369 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38830369 does have that full segment and is also clearer
- andrybak 3y agoThe version that was put on the Main Page of English Wikipedia today also has the accordion part: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Template:POTD/2024-01-01 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Template:POTD/2024-01-01
- throwup238 3y agoThat’s one sadistic cartoon…
- maximus-decimus 3y agoI just love those old pre-hays-code movies. The Hay's code brought censorship from the movie industry in 1934 because they were afraid the government would step in otherwise. The fact there's no censorship just makes them so raw.
- safety1st 3y agoMeanwhile, continuing down the rabbit hole of corporate psychopathy: Clicks link to view video Confronted by blocked video with the message "Ad blockers are not allowed on YouTube," even though he turned off his ad blocker a week ago Changes URL to onion.tube to view it there Confronted by a message saying that YouTube is currently attempting to block Invidious instances, so this video can't be viewed Clicks Switch Invidious Instance Finally watches the video ...I guess the moral of this story is, soon we won't even need copyright law to stop us from watching all the things
- hhh 3y agoyou can also open Youtube on a computer without an ad blocker (e.g. a stock Firefox or Chrome instance), or pay for premium if you don't want to watch ads
- echelon 3y agoThe lengths people go to to escape an easy and affordable option is curious. When subscription prices get too high and the service lackluster, I can understand. Every production company tried to build their own subpar streaming service, and value delivery just doesn't scale like that. When every one of a million different news websites has its own individual subscription, I can also understand. Nobody has time for that, and the service offered is never worth the value. But YouTube premium is dirt cheap. And you're paying for legions of engineers to make the service rock solid. And it has everything. I think it's the last service I'd ever cancel, and I don't even watch YouTube that often.
- blagie 3y agoI don't like the bait-and-switch. It's evil and scummy. I feel dirty paying for evil and scummy. Youtube was built based on work of a creator community -- much more so than Alphabet engineers -- who viewed this as a sort of open platform. Once there was network lock-in, the paywall hits, the mandatory obnoxious ads hit, and the user-hostile JavaScript hits. Alphabet holds the legal contract, and the army of lawyers, but there was a social contract with a community which it simply broke. It tried (with mixed success) to do the same with the free GSuite service (once they have all your email, bill you for seeing it). Remember how Alphabet originally won by using unintrusive adwords instead of flashing banner ads? All these things might be legal, but they ain't right. I pay for subscription services, but yes, I'll go to great lengths to never, ever pay a penny for Youtube.
- kragen 3y agothis is why free software and peer-to-peer network architecture is important. centralized network services and proprietary software inherently make users vulnerable to such abuses, and the companies that engage in them will be more profitable than their competitors who don't
- 22c 3y ago> this version has the tugging on tails, but not the picking up and accordioning of the mother, so it's a falsified version I wondered if that puts the Corridor version in jeopardy in any way, given that the version they have posted was produced many years later. In my few minutes of research, it seems like the answer could be quite complicated and it would depend on whether or not the censorship process exceeds the threshold of originality. For example, I imagine if Disney had engaged in a significant colorization process of the original footage in the 50s that the resultant colorized footage would still be under copyright today. I do think that the process of removing footage could be considered a sufficiently creative endeavour. For example, if Kubrick released a re-cut version of Odyssey 5 years after the original, I would not expect the re-cut to enter public domain until 5 years after the original (even if the only difference was removal of certain scenes). If anyone could argue that censoring a film constitutes as an editorial creative process and thereby should be granted copyright protections, it's Disney.
- tweetle_beetle 3y agoIs this related to how mainstream music publishers have been churning out pointless remasters of albums made decades ago "to improve how they sound on modern devices", while dropping the licensing of the originals on digital music platforms (to buy and stream)?
- kragen 3y agothat would require music execs in 02020 to spend money today to guarantee their companies' profits in 02040, instead of spending it on buying cocaine for the next boy band, so it seems improbable
- kragen 3y agowow, i didn't even think of that problem! by falsifying our cultural heritage you may gain the legal right to further suppress its publication and study. a harsher indictment of copyright is hard to imagine
- ttyprintk 3y ago