4 ms·
I worked at a fintech that employed both MIT graduates and people that didn't go to college at all. With our hiring and interview process serving as a great fi
by echelon 3y ago
I worked at a fintech that employed both MIT graduates and people that didn't go to college at all.
With our hiring and interview process serving as a great filter, it was impossible to tell who fell into which population until they told you.
- maest 3y agoWhat was the interview pass rate for MIT grads and people without a college education?
- echelon 3y agoIs that really the point worth focusing on here?
- maest 3y agoI think those ratios are more telling than the observation that people are indistinguishable _after_ your interviewing filter. Especially in the context of this topic.
- laidoffamazon 3y agoGiven that MIT grads are objectively superior to the rest of us that didn't get into any elite schools in basically every dimension I'd wager it's fairly high. With that said, the Square interview process isn't as algorithmic as most tech or finance companies and is instead more collaborative, so the raw IQ most MIT grads would use for their Jane Street interviews probably doesn't apply here.
- paulcole 3y ago> Given that MIT grads are objectively superior to the rest of us that didn't get into any elite schools in basically every dimension I'd wager it's fairly high. Genuflect when you say that fella.
- laidoffamazon 3y agoYou jest, but is it not accurate?
- paulcole 3y agoYour belief that somebody who got into MIT is “objectively superior” in “basically every dimension” compared to someone who didn’t is one of the cringiest thoughts I’ve seen expressed on HN and that is saying something. I honestly thought (and still hope) that I missed the sarcasm.
- laidoffamazon 3y agoI'm not being sarcastic and I don't just mean MIT obviously, any elite school. I didn't get into any and I've met people that have. They're just superior - physically, mentally, in habits, by net worth and income.
- defrost 3y agoRich parents does a lot of lifting there. Stephen Smale scored a Wolf Prize, a Fields Medal, a Sloane Fellowship and a slew of other accolades off the back of mediocre grades at the University of Michigan (a fairly decent public research uni I've heard but not as far as I know an "elite" school). Looking around there's many a high achiever that missed out on a US Ivy League placing.
- laidoffamazon 3y agoDon't know if Smale is a good example to use, since he did this 75 years ago! Back then the CUNY schools had similarly impressive graduates due to quotas at the elite schools. And Michigan is also a public ivy, though I'll concede it's more achievable to get into Michigan compared to Princeton (far more egalitarian in this regard). I'll be honest, I'm sure there are some high achievers that missed out, but I haven't met a single one. Most very high achieving people I know that didn't go to top schools at least got into one (and usually multiple). I don't think there's any hope for my class of people.
- ekianjo 3y agoNot surprising. Papers have no bearing on ones capabilities especially in an era where knowledge is virtually everywhere
- wolverine876 3y agoHere's my anecdote: In extensive exposure to a top-25 global university, and to a top-10 elite one, there was a big difference in the student body and the education. The latter was a different world; the education was innovative, brilliant, demanding at a very high level that I didn't anticipate. The students operated at a different level, world-class talent with shocking intelligence and, for their age, experience, being prepared - in a good way - to be world leaders. Maybe a very simple comparison is between young tennis players that work with a local pro and go to tennis camp, and the super-talented ones working with elite professional coaches, the kind that train world champions. It was clear that there is no way you could teach yourself at anywhere near the level of top-10, nor find that education at most schools. And remember that your peers are part of your education - you won't find that population of peers either. I know some institutions hire only from the elite, top-10 schools. I used to think it was 83% prejudice, but after those experiences I understand why. It's still lazy and unfair, but I also see significant reasons for it, maybe 33% prejudice. (Possibly other top-10 schools aren't as good as the one I have experience with, of course.)
- laidoffamazon 3y agoI'd love for you to tell me, step by step, what someone that didn't get into a top institution of any kind should take away from this comment. Because all I can take away is that people like me are just objectively inferior compared to you, destined to not be a future leader or professional. Is that not what you are attempting to communicate? I just want to be crystal clear. We all know people like you are superhuman. I'm just wondering what it should mean for the rest of us, the 99.99%.
- networkchad 3y ago[dead]
- theGnuMe 3y agoSo turns out that someone studied this way back in 1999. I'll let you draw your own conclusions. https://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-srv/WPcap/1999-10/27/049r-102799-idx.html https://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-srv/WPcap/1999-10/27/049r-...
- ken47 3y agoIf the kind of work these people do at your company doesn’t pressure test the skills they exhibited to get into MIT, then that stands to reason.