3 ms·
> True to a degree, but not nearly effective (not every market is a perfect one). Most dense cities don't have nearly enough parking for the demand. You can me
by AnthonyMouse 3y ago
> True to a degree, but not nearly effective (not every market is a perfect one). Most dense cities don't have nearly enough parking for the demand.
You can measure demand relative to supply by observing pricing. But if the price is high then it would be profitable to build more parking garages. The sort of thing preventing this from working would be if you would e.g. prohibit people from building parking garages. But you don't have to prohibit them in order to not require them. Requiring them is a subsidy.
> I'm not sure they are less sympathetic than most others, who also have self-serving motives.
"Landlords want rents to be high" is an extremely unsympathetic motive, especially in cities where a large proportion of the voters are tenants.
That's the reason for the pretexts. Otherwise they would just say "let's inhibit new construction so landlords can charge higher rents" instead of needing to launder it through another policy objective. The former is often exactly what happens in the suburbs where policies are put into place with the express purpose of increasing "home values" i.e. housing costs, because the majority of voters there are property owners and the prospective buyers don't already live in the jurisdiction to vote against them -- often because they can't afford housing there.
But because the true motive is often hidden, anyone opposed to astronomical housing costs has to be wary of policies that limit construction even when the stated rationale is something else.
- wolverine876 3y ago> The sort of thing preventing this from working would be if you would e.g. prohibit people from building parking garages. But you don't have to prohibit them in order to not require them. Requiring them is a subsidy. That assumes that markets work well in every circumstance. I think that pretty clearly isn't true. It would be interesting to learn the facts of the parking space market in cities.