4 ms·
A simple theory of cancel culture
- irrational 3y agoThanks for posting this. It clarified a lot of things for me.
- kayodelycaon 3y agoOne thing I think the author is overlooking is the effect on small communities. With visibility into the tiniest of infractions, with minimal effort you can recruit enough outside pressure to banish someone from a small community. I’m pretty sure everyone seen this played out by children and teenagers. The problem is how quickly this can spread. Rumors were already a problem, but when everybody can read them in real time, it is harder to combat them.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Eddy_Viscosity2 3y agoDecent description at first, but strayed a bit at the end into needlessly bashing the younger generation. "This may also explain the rather extraordinary political ineptitude of the current younger generation."
- nataliste 3y agoThe simplest theory is that the phenomenon is the equivalent of a biological Distributed Denial of Service attack using human botnets. Mitigation techniques for handling DDoS attacks have equivalencies when dealing with humans. Block open ports; allow-list by default; use IPS to penalize participants. Reddit largely mitigated brigading by identifying and penalizing the participants. There's no reason similar strategies couldn't be applied cross-platform or legislated.
- drewcoo 3y ago> Cancel culture arises from a structural change in the dynamics of social interaction facilitated by the development of social media. So it's not an extension of shunning, which has existed in human cultures for as long as we know? It's not a form of boycotting? I find it very hard to believe that this suddenly arises from nothing other than social media. That does make it easy to solely vilify tech, though . . . another common "woke" behavior these days.
- satisfice 3y agoSocial media has greatly magnified the familiar phenomenon.
- kthejoker2 3y agoI have an even simpler theory. These things have always existed - the Internet and technology has just brought unprecedented scale to the same problems. It's the literal incarnation of "lies fly around the world 10 times before the truth gets its boots on" Scaled audience, speed, response, impact. It's not just a dimension of the problem, it creates a qualitatively different problem because of the asymmetry between harm and remedy. You could always pirate works - the issue is now you can do it at scale. You could always use low tech (human) "facial recognition" to ban people from events - now you can do it at scale. You could always do revenge porn / gossip / shaming - now you can do it at scale. And you could always boycott / "cancel culture" someone - scale. I think our biggest mistake is trying to apply 20th (or worse, 18th) century thinking to these issues.