2 ms·
Human progress has always been about building upon and extending the work of others. Besides, AI only produces a sort of "average" of what is already out there
by WalterBright 3y ago
Human progress has always been about building upon and extending the work of others.
Besides, AI only produces a sort of "average" of what is already out there. Is it really creative work to produce an equivalent of that average?
I remember when the "typing pool" was a thing. Word processors utterly destroyed that category of work, as well as the jobs for typesetting and layout, back in the 1980s.
- extractionmech 3y agoI would argue that the analogy rests on an incomplete consideration of the dimensions of the matter. Such tools amplified a worker’s inherent utility. The name given to the new tool reflects its nature: processor of words. Whose words? The typist. “Other peoples’ words processor” vs “word processor”. More generally, AI introduces yet another systemic mechanism for wealth extraction by the wealthy. The wealth here is creative power of the !wealthy. More sinister than the grand larceny by a thousand minor borrowings is the fact that meaning, ideals, motivating energy to move masses is taken away from the candidate pool — anyone of us can be the next demagogue, it’s not too late yet — which may include genuine thought leaders are going to be buried by the electric demagogue working for the proverbial man. “We need to hire more copyrighters for our propaganda using these ‘word processors’” becomes “Who could resist the onslaught of “our” creative efforts? Surrender now Dorothy.” tldr: Humanity has reached the absolute limit of the utility of ancient means of governance. New technology demands that we comprehensively review socio-economic order in society. Failure to do so will gift the current “winning” players in the ‘zero-sum-game’ of the du jour regime near guarantee of perpetual habitation in their very very special social perch. “Think of the children”
- WalterBright 3y agoIn the 1800's Germany started behind Britain and raced ahead of it in industrial might. One factor in this was Germany did not recognize copyrights. Printers went looking for something, anything, to print and printed up a storm of technical literature that enabled this rapid industrialization and the increase in wealth of its ordinary citizens.
- extractionmech 3y agoBless you Walter, you are a positive man. Let’s “hope” so buddy.
- miguelazo 3y agoThe typing pool converting one format to another is not equivalent. It’s more like the demise of administrative support professionals. That work just got shifted to the people they used to work for because it was now supposedly “easier” to manage themselves with more advanced information technology. Which is why we all have to waste massive amounts of time figuring out our HR stuff, arranging work travel, etc.