> The infidelity example I used was actually part of one of the many HIPAA training classes that I've attended over the years. In the (real life) example the nu

> The infidelity example I used was actually part of one of the many HIPAA training classes that I've attended over the years. In the (real life) example the nurses were gossiping about the case in the elevator. It happened that a family member was in the elevator with them. As I said, I read the original line as being specifically about using medical information privacy protection to keep the information from the spouse, and I think that's a less-than-robust example. I now understand that that wasn't your intent. Mentioning nurses gossiping and discussing patients in an unsecured location adds detail that makes it more robust. > So, treatment for an STD, for example, should be public information? What if that treatment occurred while the spouse was on a six month military deployment? My position is that the answer to the first question should be "no": treatment for an STD should not be public information. The answer to the second question has no bearing on the answer to the first, but it is presented/worded as if it should. That the infidelity and STD treatment occurred while the spouse was deployed distracts from the fact that nurses shouldn't be gossiping in crowded elevators at all. Medical professionals shouldn't be gossiping in crowded elevators independent of the if the spouse is in the military or not or is deployed or not.