3 ms·
Websites will kill apps. It's only a matter of time. The only reason to write apps is for performance and to get access to features your browser won't let you,
by jerf 15y ago
Websites will kill apps. It's only a matter of time. The only reason to write apps is for performance and to get access to features your browser won't let you, but those will both progressively be fixed over time. The only app survivors will be those apps that truly use all the power or truly use very specific hardware that is somehow not safe or not widespread enough to justify browser support.
If your career is currently bet on apps, I'd be sure to diversify in your spare time into something not-app. (Said not-app thing may also be useful in apps, I'd just avoid specializing extensively and solely on things that are only uesful in the app context.)
- roc 15y ago> "The only reason to write apps is for performance and to get access to features your browser won't let you, but those will both progressively be fixed over time." That's certainly possible, but here we are in 2012 and offline use of web apps is still atrocious. To say nothing of how inefficiently web traffic currently maps to the realities of cell phone networks. And then there are user interface concerns (website support for multitouch? camera use? video capture? audio capture?). And everywhere, the all-to-familiar bugbear of disparate specs and support for any and all would-be extension to the web. I personally think the odds are higher that we'll see another computer use method rising to prominence [1], that shakes up everyone's expectations of what an Everywhere Web needs to be able to do. That's ultimately where we're headed and ultimately why the web site vs app distinction is moot. The future is services with many interfaces. Web interfaces, desktop OS interfaces, mobile interfaces, even interfaces to other services -- whatever makes sense so that all of it's features are ready for you anywhere and everywhere you might want them. [1] Head's up displays? Maybe. But I'm thinking more like presence-aware general computing resources. Think appleTV's AirPlay, but for further computing tasks. Walk over to an all-in-one and it becomes an extension of your workspace. More display, more resources, better connection and all your data being sent to it as needed.
- aculver 15y agoI'm not saying apps will kill websites, but we're 5 years into this thing now: Websites will not kill apps. It's not just about performance and hardware access, it's about UI toolkits. Web-based and cross-platform apps just feel different. Even PhoneGap, Titanium, etc. haven't been able to solve this problem. Mobile sites and web-based apps will continue to exist, because it's the right solution some of the time.. but native apps are here to stay.
- untog 15y agoIt's not just about performance and hardware access, it's about UI toolkits. Web-based and cross-platform apps just feel different. Even PhoneGap, Titanium, etc. haven't been able to solve this problem. Right... because the browsers aren't there yet. They absolutely could be, though. Maybe Apple will stop Safari from being able, but they're actually yet to show any indication that they would do that.
- mitjak 15y agoAdd to that the difficult of using and discovering a web app. Apple, for instance, while embracing HTML5 as far justifying death of Flash goes, has made little visible effort to promote visibility of web apps. Some features of mobileSafari have been requested and missing for years (looking at you, contentEditable). That, and lack of an easy to browse web app store is what I would blame. Of course Aplle can't profit from webapps nearly as easily, so it does make sense.
- ajhit406 15y agoI think apps are here to stay mostly because of modularization. Many of the common components of apps these days will be modularized and ported over to numerous libraries. This will make the time-sink risk of developing on a proprietary platform less significant. App ecosystems however will continue to evolve over time. I see most of the big players having a median of about a 10yr foothold on the industry until the next player out innovates them and manages to gain significant market share. In all likelihood however, we'll probably be way off. I should save my HN posts so I can laugh at myself in 20 years.
- davidw 15y agoAgree 100% with the general sense of your comment, but not this: > If your career is currently bet on apps, I'd be sure to diversify in your spare time into something not-app. People still make plenty of money doing desktop apps in this day and age. "Computer stuff" is a big enough field that there are plenty of niches for everyone.