3 ms·
Each disabled token is pure profit to Tether. They're not cashing them out to the US Treasury, as with Bitcoins recovered from criminal operations.
by Animats 3y ago
Each disabled token is pure profit to Tether. They're not cashing them out to the US Treasury, as with Bitcoins recovered from criminal operations.
- crypt1d 3y agoNeither of those statements is true. Bitcoin seized by US government is often sold off in auctions[1]. Tether seized by the government could also be redeemed for fiat eventually, following due process. [1] - https://www.forbes.com/sites/brandonkochkodin/2023/03/31/us-government-sells-bitcoin-seized-from-silk-road-case-netting-over-215-million/?sh=57a90f032888 https://www.forbes.com/sites/brandonkochkodin/2023/03/31/us-... EDIT: I see now that you were actually comparing the case of USDT freeze against Bitcoin seizures. Nevertheless, Tether doesn't simply get to keep the USD value of the frozen tokens. US government would want to recover that.
- denlekke 3y ago"disable its tokens" "freezing 326 wallets" no indication from this article that the tether has been seized / transferred
- crypt1d 3y agoTokens are frozen "in-place" pending investigation. It differs from how it works with btc, because the government does not have control of the private keys that manage the addresses in question - so they go to Tether who controls the smart contract that manages the transactions of the tokens. This, in practice, means that the US government controls the mentioned tokens for the moment. What happens with them depends entirely on the outcome of the investigation.
- smsm42 3y agoUS govt could also create a govt wallet and force usdt to transfer the tokens there I imagine, if they want to proceed with seizure. They'd likely will need some legal framework for this but it's easily doable. Then us govt can auction it off as they like.
- gropo 3y agoUS govt could also require OFAC sanctions compliance on BTC via international framework as well. 30 warehouses or so, hundred websites, single code repository with a handful of developers. Developers recently closed an open issue an American miner raised with OFAC compliance and the software, and even being able to help write the patch. Beyond freezing, BTC can even be reissued via a module written expressly for such a purpose.
- wolverine876 3y agoIt's an interesting question: What does that mean? Maybe it's better to look at cryptocurrencies as financial securities, shares in an asset controlled by a private company (as has been said many times before). Could General Electric 'disable' the shares of a shareholder? What would that mean? The shareholder can't sell their shares, I suppose, but GE's equity would remain the same (not counting any market movement that would be caused by the sale). Imagine a monetary system where currency was profit to a private company. What will our once-proud industry think of next? Software to help landlords collude, take housing off the market, and jack up rents? Software that impersonates humans, as well as any form of truth? We are on a roll!
- smeej 3y agoThe SEC is arguing that most cryptocurrencies, especially the ones that enable this level of control, are securities.
- nostrademons 3y agoCompanies absolutely can "disable" trading by certain shareholders. This is what an IPO lock-up is, where insiders cannot sell their shares until 6-12 months after the conclusion of the IPO. It's also what a trading blackout is, where employees cannot trade shares between the end of the quarter and release of earnings. These are very common - almost everyone who works for a public company has encountered them. These cases are temporary, but I suspect there are also permanent trading bans that might be caused by legal action - if, for example, an employee is found guilty of a crime, or is under a wage garnishment order. Also, crypto has long had the phenomena of coins that get "locked" and can never be touched or transferred again, simply through holders that have died or lost the private key. For example, the original "Satoshi coins" - the roughly 1M Bitcoin (~$45B at today's prices, enough to make their holder the 27th richest person in the world) mined by Satoshi before Bitcoin became mainstream - have never been spent, and it's likely that their owner is dead. They simply drop out of circulation, and the price of all other Bitcoin rises to compensate.
- wolverine876 3y agoGood points about trading that's disabled. I just wonder what is the same and different about cryptocurrencies like Tether's. > They simply drop out of circulation, and the price of all other Bitcoin rises to compensate. Would that be different for Tether? Isn't Tether a 'private' blockchain that the company controls?
- ThrustVectoring 3y agoEach non-disabled token is also pure profit, they're not cashing them out in appreciable quantities to anyone.
- yieldcrv 3y agoThats because people use the cash in Tether USDT there like their brokerage account: its accumulated from deposit and trading and rarely withdrawn to a bank account. For example, if Charles Schwab created Schwab USD upon every fiat deposit, the growth and redemption distribution would be similar to Tether. People that can save and populate an investment account do that more than they ever actually withdraw to cause a redemption.