3 ms·

If an LLM scrapes a source code repository that requires attribution, will you also preach to tech companies to go after said license?

• brookst 3y ago
  What license requires attribution to read and understand the code? Or to use techniques from code for totally different purposes, embodied in different code? You may have a point for verbatim regurgitation of code, but I’m having a hard time seeing a violation in ingestion code and learning how it works.
  • oldkinglog 3y ago
    > What license requires attribution to read and understand the code? BSD, MIT, several others. Without a license you cannot read the code.
    • kragen 3y ago
      reading has never been one of the rights reserved to copyright holders under us copyright law, and in fact there are a number of carve-outs in us copyright law to ensure that copyright holders cannot prevent people from reading their work, such as the first-sale doctrine and the exemption for copying an executable into memory there have at times been regimes that legally restricted the mere reading of published works, but such policies have generally been considered repugnant to liberal democracy and indeed liberalism in general