3 ms·
While different, I find this discussion about AI and copyrights as an evolution of the war that never was: Google/FB converting in the portal/proxy for content
by wslh 3y ago
While different, I find this discussion about AI and copyrights as an evolution of the war that never was: Google/FB converting in the portal/proxy for content and while it is not generative AI you can find copyrighted images just using Google Images or as an snippet in the normal search engine. I mention Google because it is the de facto monopoly but this applies to a lot of aggregators.
I know we are talking about different technologies but it seems all these people were very silent and find some opportunity in having this war with OpenAI (not an endorsement) but not fighting others.
I am not making an statement about the morals of AI and aggregators/search engines (super interesting discussion that in a way was happening for long) but I am surprised that organizations are "just" waking up. It seems they just see it is a much simple and cheap fight.
- theamk 3y agoThe thing with Google is it is super trivial to exclude your text - tag on page, header on server, etc.. So all the conversations about google "stealing" context always seemed pretty silly to me. Compared to that AI offers no way to opt out, which is a big difference.
- dmbche 3y agoPersonal use of copywritten material is fine - there is no breach of copyright when you download a picture from Google for yourself. If you use it commercially then there is breach. Uploading copywritten content is a breach of copyright as well, even without commercial use. Google/Facebook are hosting and giving access to a bunch of media, which might or might not be copywritten - it's the individuals problem.They make.money from ads, not from the content. AI companies stole copywritten media to train their commercial LLM, sell them or their products and make profit. I don't think it's the same.