3 ms·
Maybe this is an unpopular opinion here, but "tickets" don't make any conceptual sense for driverless cars. The entire concept of tickets and fines are to act a
by crazygringo 3y ago
Maybe this is an unpopular opinion here, but "tickets" don't make any conceptual sense for driverless cars. The entire concept of tickets and fines are to act as a deterrent to individual drivers who might make unsafe choices -- that they'll actively choose whether to obey a speed limit or not.
Driverless cars don't seem to be programmed to break laws in the first place. They're incapable of making a choice to break laws to save time. They're simply programmed not to speed, not to run through red lights. And when they do, it's not out of some "choice" -- it's just a bug or deficiency in their code.
Driverless cars absolutely do need to be held to safety standards. But the way to do that isn't through issuing tickets. It's simply for a governmental regulatory agency to set statistical limits for the manufacturer's software for mistakes like running a red light, and if the whole fleet of cars goes above that limit you require the software manufacturer to fix it, risking fines if they don't fix it quickly, or losing the ability to operate at all.
Issuing tickets for driverless cars makes as much sense as issuing tickets if pharmaceutical companies put the wrong amount of a drug in a pill. Tickets are for individuals who make choices; safety regulations with fines and revoking licenses are for corporations and things like driverless cars.
- lallysingh 3y agoNo it doesn't, but they should ticket the cars anyway. The ticket gets paid by Waymo or whoever runs the car. They don't want any more resentment from other drivers.
- RandomLensman 3y agoAvoidable costs are still an incentive to improve for the companies owning or running driverless cars. As it feels unlikely all things that will ever happen are captured within regulations, fines could still be useful. The bigger question is what to do with things exceeding fines, i.e., stuff that would lead to a custodial sentence for a driver.
- renewiltord 3y agoThat's a pretty good point. Just wanted to comment to say that I found it convincing. Ticketing is a less effective tool for large scale operators. The benefit is that ticketing is the administrative mechanism we already have so we can use that to aggregate and judge performance.
- anileated 3y ago> Tickets are for individuals who make choices; safety regulations with fines and revoking licenses are for corporations and things like driverless cars. Fine the owner of the self-driving car enough and she will sell it and never buy from this company again. Fine enough owners and the company is broke. Similarly, we do not punish the Coca-Colas of the world for pumping out fossil-fuel based plastic packaging by a ton, but countries do increasingly enforce consumer recycling (with penalties). Not saying it’s good but it is what it is.
- sixothree 3y agoSo you’re suggesting the effect is correct but it shouldn’t be first order and some invisible free market force will actually work the way you pretend?
- gnicholas 3y agoI agree that regular, run-of-the-mill tickets wouldn’t motivate driverless car companies. But I disagree that there shouldn’t be any penalty for a company whose fleet does not exceed some threshold of red-light-running, for example. If a vehicle unjustifiably runs a red light, there should be a penalty, regardless of how it’s being driven. The penalties could differ for driverless car companies, to make sure they’re big enough to meaningfully motivate these companies. Otherwise it feels patently unfair to human drivers, who can’t say “well, my family hasn’t broken many traffic laws recently, so I shouldn’t have to pay a ticket for just running this one red light/almost hitting this one pedestrian.
- wongarsu 3y agoTickets also set dangerous incentives. Cities would be rewarded for intentionally creating traffic situations that will be misinterpreted by driverless cars, making the roads less save for everyone. Of course this can already be an issue today, but driverless cars might tip it from being a necessary evil to just plain evil
- ufmace 3y agoI basically agree with all that. I think I'd further say that the way any kind of practical regulation shakes out, it may never make sense for individuals to own self-driving cars. If we are to hold the creator of self-driving systems responsible for any poor behavior of their creations (as we very well should!), then they must have both the ability to be certain that all of their deployed software and hardware is always in the intended correct working order, and the ability to perform fixes and updates on demand of either themselves or some regulating agency. Therefore, it seems pointless for it to ever be possible for an individual to "own" such a thing. They would inevitably be mandated to never attempt to modify the system and to accept any updates and maintenance tasks immediately on the creator's demand. So why should any reasonable individual, or banks who would have to be writing loans to those individuals, want to own such a thing when they have so little control over it and so many liabilities? Consider a situation like - the car has 6 laser/lidar sensors. It is designed to continue operating as well as possible if one of them malfunctions. If one of them does infact malfunction, who is responsible for deciding when to replace it and paying for such service? If you truly own such a vehicle, wouldn't you be the one paying for it? And if you're paying for it, how could you not be the one deciding exactly when it happens? So then inevitably some people would put it off as long as possible and have the vehicle operating in a degraded condition. Maybe it could try to refuse to operate until serviced, but when? Maybe when you're out of town somewhere, or when you have an important meeting to make it to later? Liability, even conditional, for the end user doesn't seem like a very good solution either. Is it really a good system for every unfortunate incident to become a legal battle between an individual owner and what would necessarily be a gigantic mega-corporation with a fat legal budget for who is really responsible? Yeah, no. So I think I just proved that self-driving cars pretty much always have to be operated as a taxi-like system as Waymo etc currently do. Lidar sensor breaks? Not my problem, the service needs to send another one, no matter what the location - it can't go to any location it couldn't send a replacement to anyways. If there's any problems, there's always a clear party responsible - a giant wealthy mega-corp that is very easy to regulate and fine and capable of fixing the whole fleet fast. Am I missing something here? Maybe, but I don't see it right now.
- michaelsshaw 3y agoThe absurdity of ticketing driverless vehicles makes it all the more clear that American police will lobby hard in favor of it
- x86x87 3y agowho is liable in case of a self-driving car causes an accident? Is the liability any different between an accident and a potential accident (ie ticket) ? I for one do not buy the argument that the intent to break the law is not there. To understand why this is the case: imagine a really fast self driving car that enters the runway at an airport. It speeds up as it attempts to take off. It does not take off and in the process - best case - causes delay for everyone using the airport. Now, I could argue that this car is a plane and it was in fact NOT programmed to NOT take off. Therefore everything is good. In my opinion: self-driving cars do not belong on the road unless there are real consequences to their screw ups. Right now it's a beta test where you might just lose your life and nobody is going to be held accountable.
- analog31 3y agoIn between tickets and regulations, there's insurance. Say that my car bumps into a parked car. My insurance pays for the repairs. The insurance company figures out how much to charge me. Simply saying that a driverless car pays for the damage that it causes might be the way to manage this issue.