5 ms·
To me that’s the wrong question. Everyone knew it was trained on copyrighted material and capable of eerily similar outputs. But it’s already done. At scale.
by Havoc 3y ago
To me that’s the wrong question.
Everyone knew it was trained on copyrighted material and capable of eerily similar outputs.
But it’s already done. At scale. Large corps committing fully. There is no chance of that toothpaste going back in the tube.
It’s a bit like when big tech built on aggressive user data harvesting. Whether it’s right, ethical or even legal is academic at this stage. They just did it - effectively without any real informed consent by society. Same thing here - 9 out of 10 people on street won’t be able to tell you how AI is made let alone comment on copyright.
So the right question here is what now. And I suspect much like tracking the answer will be - not much.
- ZitchDog 3y agoNapster hit scale too.
- fallingknife 3y agoAnd that tech was not destroyed by regulation. It was replaced by the superior tech of torrents.
- amazingman 3y agoThe company, however, was destroyed. Along with any possibility for a similar company to exist (for very long).
- qup 3y agoNapster was for sharing mp3s. Torrents are not better at sharing mp3s.
- danielbln 3y agoF500 companies didn't integrate Napster into their software and data stacks left and right.
- j_maffe 3y agoThat's a really eloquent way of saying "It's already happening, so give up on it." I'm sure it works out great for taking action and solving problems.
- Spivak 3y agoIt's already happening and most people like having AI more than the DMCA. Selling people on the idea that ML training is piracy to people who on average pirate content with no moral quandary will go nowhere.
- pennomi 3y agoExactly. People don’t like the DMCA at all. People would be happier in a world with very few IP restrictions at all. But businesses do like it, and profits are what drive these legal decisions. This will always be the case as long as money is more important than humans in politics.
- phatfish 3y agoPeople liked having Napster, but it didn't stop file sharing going from a big mainstream app to underground sites run out of Russia (or other places that ignore copyright law). Sure, you can download music/movies still, but it's not like the Napster days. "Generative AI" is obviously copyright infringement, so owners of the copyright will win in court. Either Microsoft will have to fight a mass of legal cases, some with very deep pockets themselves, or ChatGPT will be crippled for public use. The un-crippled models will exist if you know where to look (and have the hardware), but using them for anything apart from hobby projects would be a legal risk. Certain specific tools may be easier to deal with from a legal standpoint, like code completion maybe. Or models for a specific purpose, like training on a law firm's case history. It looks like Adobe has the right idea with their image generation that is trained on images which they know they have the rights to use.
- Spivak 3y ago> "Generative AI" is obviously copyright infringement You're saying this as a matter of fact when it's not clear at all. We'll see what happens with the NYT case because it touches on all the major points. It's gonna call into question all web scraping and indexing because they're also distillations of copyrighted content in the same manner.
- _xnmw 3y agoSo you're saying this is a fait accompli. Like many great innovations in tech, break the law because the law is silly; remember when Uber and AirBnB were illegal in most major cities and achieved market dominance anyway? I say, good riddance. I never believed in any such thing as "intellectual property" anyway, I say, get rid of it all, patents, copyright, and the whole pile of imaginary "rights". More than half the world (i.e. the Global South) don't recognize these rights anyway, and it is becoming increasingly difficult to enforce it without draconian legal overreach and monopolistic centralization.
- ausbah 3y agothis comment has already aged poorly because cities are starting to push airbnbs out and taxi usage is at least somewhat up
- falcor84 3y ago> taxi usage is at least somewhat up When's the last time you phoned an operator to book a taxi? If taxis are doing better, it's only because they learned from Uber (and the likes) what the job-to-be-done actually is.
- discreteevent 3y agoMytaxi (freenow) was founded the same year as Uber.
- falcor84 3y agoI'm unclear what your point is, weren't mytaxi an "outsider" startup like Uber too, rather than being organized by the taxi companies?
- FridgeSeal 3y agoYou’re right, we should all just give up at the first hurdle, because “they’ve” already gotten away with it, hell, let’s just feed our children to the machine and elect openAI as the rulers of the world, after all, they’ve already succeeded, so we should just give up entirely. Definitely a good attitude to take.
- pxoe 3y agomaking sure that a dataset is clean and not full of material that's improperly sourced, copyrighted, unfit for use due to licensing or ethics, is not nearly hard enough nor "impossible" for it to be a situation where people should just "give up". and yes, while open source models might be harder to regulate, those big corporations that currently use those things without distinction, exist as pretty established entities, and profit from services they offer in millions of dollars. there's more of a substantial existence, and more of a substantial scale of money they actually move. and they don't just "make a tool available", or have users do unambiguous actions where it would be the users that are infringing on anything, but do indeed use questionably sourced data and turn that into a model and offer that as a service. dirty data is very much a part of the deal with those.
- anonymousab 3y agoOr they can be forced to destroy or retrain their models without any copyright materials for which they don't have or do not now attain licenses for. These are multi-billion/trillion dollar companies. They can afford to be responsible members of society here, however much their shareholders and C-suite might hate it.
- rokkitmensch 3y agoThose weights are never coming out of the BitTorrent network though.
- andybak 3y agoThis. The models are out there. Maybe they will just be illicitly shared but even if no new models are trained from scratch I suspect there will be many ways to use extend existing models without going back to scraped images. I always felt that we already had a solution - I can already get all those images from a web search. Where the law currently intervenes is when I try and distribute works based on close copies of them. Why is this insufficient?
- anonymousab 3y agoSure. And neither are mp3s of the same songs that were blowing up on Napster. The existence of widespread illegal means to procure something doesn't mean that we don't and shouldn't require legitimate businesses to abide by the law or require them to make amends for their current transgressions.
- Havoc 3y ago>Or they can be forced to destroy or retrain their models Perhaps. The media industries have been quite successful in going after kids torrenting movies. I suspect they'll have less luck going after big tech & an industry drowning in money inflows. Keep in mind various large techs have already issued blanket indemnities on infringement to their customers. They're absolutely committed & are gonna throw enough lawyers at this to keep everyone busy until 2030. >They can afford to be responsible members of society here oh absolutely agree, but they're not going to do that. This is an industry built on questionable practices like tracking after all
- janice1999 3y ago> There is no chance of that toothpaste going back in the tube. I disagree - we've been here before. The same could be said of many technologies, like cheap music recording/manufacture. You can record an artist once and make records at scale. However no one would think you could record Taylor Swift once and make unlimited copies without paying her. You should read up on the musicians strike of 1942. [0] [0[ https://jacobin.com/2022/03/1940s-musicians-strike-american-federations-of-musicians-afm-labels-streaming https://jacobin.com/2022/03/1940s-musicians-strike-american-...
- aatd86 3y agoData is dynamic. Ok for old data. What about new data?
- chubot 3y agoThis comment is ignorant of history It happened with Napster, then Apple Music, now streaming services There is no widespread file sharing in the general public, instead we have devices that we don’t own, and streaming subscriptions Apple didn’t just copy all the music onto iPods and sell it — it took them a decade of deal making and lots of money to acquire the rights to the content I’m not saying what’s right or wrong, just saying that this comment has very little understanding of these battles
- fouc 3y agoThe difference is the comment was about large corps. Napster wasn't that.
- shkkmo 3y ago> Apple didn’t just copy all the music onto iPods and sell it — it took them a decade of deal making and lots of money to acquire the rights to the content I recaly iPod being a hard drive that I could connect to a computer and just copy music directly to.
- chubot 3y agoPretty sure it was never like that, it was always gated by iTunes. It was an integrated system, not an open one. Definitely is today. It's difficult to copy mp3 files directly to an iPhone and play them. Even from a Mac, but even more so from a PC or Linux. I bet less than 1% of iPhone and iPad users do that. They mostly pay for streaming. (Again, not saying that's better, but just that the general public doesn't do Napster-like file sharing.)
- shkkmo 3y ago> Pretty sure it was never like that, it was always gated by iTunes. Then you need to recalibrate your certainty assessment. Not only did I do this personally with both music and videos, it is incredibly easy to find documentation of the steps. First google result: https://www.alphr.com/add-music-to-ipod-without-itunes/ https://www.alphr.com/add-music-to-ipod-without-itunes/ Apple's ipod sales absolutely benefited significantly from music piracy. Especially early on when nobody hard large itunes collections yet and music torrents were much more common. The genius of the ipod / itunes play is that they got to do both. They benefited from the demand from people with non-itunes libraries, while also offering a low friction sales platform that was easier than piracy.