4 ms·
Read everything in publication order. That is the only way it will make any sense; later books always assume that you've read the earlier ones, even if editors
by thaumasiotes 3y ago
Read everything in publication order. That is the only way it will make any sense; later books always assume that you've read the earlier ones, even if editors do their best to try to avoid this, but earlier books never assume you've read the later ones.
- wolverine876 3y agoNot every story is written that way. Also, it's not necessary that everything make sense; sometimes there are higher priorities. Sometimes, it's just not worth the time to read it all.
- thaumasiotes 3y ago>> later books always assume that you've read the earlier ones, even if editors do their best to try to avoid this, but earlier books never assume you've read the later ones. > Not every story is written that way. This is... clearly untrue?
- wolverine876 3y agoI don't know about you, but there's much more to the world than what I know.
- simondotau 3y agoSure, but even so I’m reasonably sure we can rely on the linear nature of time. Whether or not the publication of prequels was premeditated, it still rings true that the cultural artefact is always publication order.
- wolverine876 3y agoBut you are not at all required to follow some prior linear order in the linear order of your own time. If I want to smelt steel, I don't need to learn to smelt bronze first. What rings true is the eternal best advice: think for yourself.
- kelnos 3y agoI don't really buy that. An author may have planned out the entire story, but later decides to write and release later parts of the story first, and earlier parts later, as prequels, but not include an assumption in the prequels that the reader has already read the earlier-published works. I don't know how common this is, but I don't think I'd be willing to assume this has never happened.
- thaumasiotes 3y ago> An author may have planned out the entire story, but later decides to write and release later parts of the story first, and earlier parts later, as prequels, but not include an assumption in the prequels that the reader has already read the earlier-published works. Still untrue. The author is going to include whatever information they possess in whatever work they create. If the prequels are written later, they will rely on information from the earlier works, whether the author wanted them to do that or not.
- davkan 3y agoI wouldn’t be surprised if I learned that a majority of books in series have been written with the idea in mind that some readers are coming in fresh. That does not mean that a book is free from having followed the prior works. An author cannot change the frame of reference they were operating within when they authored a work. That’s the reason the “cultural artifact” is the publication order. If we set aside books in a series that were written and edited to completion concurrently and published staggered, then i don’t see how an author could possibly publish a book while managing to entirely circumvent the reality that they have knowledge of the previous books they have written and do not have full knowledge of the ones they have not, no matter how hard they may try.
- partomniscient 3y ago>I’m reasonably sure we can rely on the linear nature of time. I'm not even sure about that, perhaps we can rely on our linear _experience_ of time, but we can't determine which is the correct version of two billiard balls colliding if we're shown the forwards and the backwards versions. Assuming time is linear is convenient, but I don't think its provable or outright definite.
- kelnos 3y agoIs it? I mean, are you willing to assert that literally every single multi-work story was written with successive works assuming the reader has read previous works? Sure, I'd expect that to be the most common case, by far, but asserting that's the only case would seem to be impossible, unless you've read (or at least are familiar with) literally every multi-work story ever written in all of time. I don't think anyone can claim that.
- thaumasiotes 3y agoOf course. That is the only possibility. What the author intended to do is not in question; the question is what actually happened.
- andrewflnr 3y agoIt may not be exactly 100.000% true, but it's close enough that you can just stop thinking about it and read in publication order unless you're given a very strong reason. The author, editors, and publishers would have to screw up very hard for publication order to not be viable, and for something else to be optimal either requires extraordinary writing ability (it's hard to refer to books that aren't written yet, the arrow of time being how it is), or for the series not to have been very good to start. The major exception I can think of is something like Discworld where they're all pretty independent, i.e. barely a series at all in the sense we're talking about, but once you start talking about one of the sequential sub-series, you're back to publication order mattering.
- wolverine876 3y agoPeople say these things with such confidence; where does that confidence come from? It's amazing, but not confidence-inspiring. I've read/seen much art, in books and other mediums, that don't match your description. I find some things are much better if I skip the beginning and come back to it later, if I still think it's worthwhile. > you can just stop thinking about it and read in publication order unless you're given a very strong reason How can you advise - maybe even instruct - people so confidently, without at all knowning them, their purposes, and also what they are reading - which could be anything in the world! Must I read the collected works of Milton in order? The Bible? The Art of Computer Programming? History? Literary porn - can I skip to the good part or do I need to read it all in order? When I see such certainty, I don't think 'who could know that much?' but 'who could think they know that much?'
- andrewflnr 3y agoYou want to compare "the collected works of Milton", the Bible, and TAoCP to the Chronicles of Narnia? We're not talking about arbitrary collections of books, we're talking about fictional works with strong continuity between them in setting and events, among other criteria. But if it's not that good, yeah, go ahead and skip some parts. I did account for that case, but whatever. This is entertainment, not deep moral truth.
- shusaku 3y agoFirefly might be the classic counter example
- mikepurvis 3y agoThe TV show? In that case the DVD set order is the canonical one and is plot/story order. That they were originally aired out of order back in 2003 was a one-off aberration due to studio leadership not understanding or being on board with what the show was about.
- boulos 3y agoLet's call it "production order" then. Firefly was famously broadcast out of order.
- kelnos 3y agoI wouldn't call that a counterexample; if you watch Firefly in production order (not broadcast order; the broadcaster was moronic in reordering things), then you get the best experience. I think it's more fair to call Firefly an edge case, instead.
- db48x 3y agoI can give you a concrete example of where this is not true because the author went to a lot of effort to give both books open questions which are answered by the other: Vernor Vinge’s “A Fire Upon the Deep” and “A Deepness in the Sky”. He made sure that the second book answers the open question(s) left by the first, but also that it had open question(s) which are answered by the first book. It really doesn’t matter which one you read first, because the other one closes the loop, as it were.
- mmastrac 3y agoIn fairness, Verner Vinge is an amazing author and this is probably a skill unique to very few writers. I've found his books to be repeatedly re-readable.
- roca 3y agoMAROONED IN REALTIME, A FIRE UPON THE DEEP and A DEEPNESS IN THE SKY are excellent. I could re-read them. THE PEACE WAR and RAINBOWS END are just average and I would only read them once. CHILDREN OF THE SKY is awful and I wish I hadn't bothered reading it at all.
- db48x 3y agoYea, even the best authors can’t consistently write excellent books. And “Children of the Sky” lacks many of the advantages that “A Fire Upon the Deep” and “A Deepness in the Sky” had, such as space travel. That alone makes it less memorable and contributes a lot to reader disappointment.
- kelnos 3y agoThat just proves what should be obvious: there are always exceptions. In general, I still think production order tends to work best for most works.
- davkan 3y agoUnless a series is explicitly conceived from the beginning as something to be experienced in any order and written concurrently, e.g. the episodes of the Netflix show Kaleidoscope, you should read in publication order if you intend to read the series completely. It’s not just about making sense. A flashback will often make complete sense when viewed at its chronological time. But all sorts of dramatic weight and subtleties can be lost on a reader who does not have knowledge material that was published prior, and it can further alter your perception of events that happen later on that assume you don’t have that knowledge. Each book was written with a unique frame of reference. It’s almost always a mistake to leave that frame of reference.