3 ms·
> Solar and wind + storage, in the long run, is currently not cost competitive in most markets. That's not even close to being true. Uruguay is 100% wind +
by bryanlarsen 3y ago
> Solar and wind + storage, in the long run, is currently not cost competitive in most markets.
That's not even close to being true. Uruguay is 100% wind + storage. 90% - 98% from wind, with 2% - 10% from hydro.
The US has two advantages that Uruguay doesn't: a continental sized energy grid and a mix of wind & solar. Plus the advantage of building it out in the 2020s rather than the 2010s when both solar and batteries are an order of magnitude cheaper than they were when Uruguay was building out.
California has solar + storage projects that are supplying power for 4c/kWh. That's cost competitive.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> Uruguay is 100% wind + storage Uruguay pays $170/MWh [1]. That’s what power from the first-of-its-kind and hideously-delayed Vogtle nuclear power plants will cost [2]. [1] https://www.global-climatescope.org/markets/uy/ https://www.global-climatescope.org/markets/uy/ [2] https://www.powermag.com/blog/plant-vogtle-not-a-star-but-a-tragedy-for-the-people-of-georgia/ https://www.powermag.com/blog/plant-vogtle-not-a-star-but-a-...
- bryanlarsen 3y agoAre you comparing retail price to wholesale price? The generation cost of power is a very small fraction of the retail price in most markets, especially in Uruguay. Distribution and paying off old debts is a massive fraction of the cost.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> comparing retail price to wholesale price? Yes. If you have an adjusted price, I’d be curious. That said, we can compare the real-world France and Uruguay. On the basis of both price and cost, France runs cheaper. Obviously there are many other factors at play. But while I love Uruguay and its bold energy vision, they are not an example of wind + storage proving economically viable.
- bryanlarsen 3y agoThe Uruguayan transition was led by a nuclear engineer who decided in 2008 that renewables were cheaper than nuclear. In 2024 renewables are more than an order of magnitude cheaper than renewables were in 2008.
- bryanlarsen 3y agoRe: France vs Uruguay. Yes subsidized electricity is cheaper than unsubsidized electricity.
- peterfirefly 3y agoUruguay has dams in the mountains for its hydro. The country can choose how much electricity to generate from them to compensate for low winds. That's only viable with mountains + valleys + sufficiently low population density (206th in the world). It's not something that generalizes to the entire lower 48 (but it will work fine in parts of California).
- bryanlarsen 3y agoThe US gets 6% of its power from Hydro. The Uruguayan experience makes it clear that it has enough Hydro energy capacity (not sure whether it has enough Hydro power capacity, but that's a lot easier to add than energy capacity). Build enough solar & wind so that you get enough power with either solar or wind if the other is not producing, and fill in the holes with hydro and the existing nuclear.
- peterfirefly 3y agoSometimes you have a nice dam that can either tap or leave alone, knowing that the water will still be there when you need. Sometimes you just have a flowing river -- and sometimes that river doesn't flow so fast. Hydro isn't a single thing. The former can be used to compensate when the wind doesn't blow and the sun doesn't shine. The latter can't really. Uruguay has the former. Parts of the US has the former. Does all of the US?