3 ms·
> Running older versions of macOS in a VM enables users to run Intel-only apps long after Rosetta 2 support is dropped from the current macOS Now if they'd off
by mschuster91 3y ago
> Running older versions of macOS in a VM enables users to run Intel-only apps long after Rosetta 2 support is dropped from the current macOS
Now if they'd offer that for x86 Windows guests... I mean, games are the obvious thing but I guess the architectural differences between Apple's PowerVR-family GPU and NV/AMD are just too large, but there's a ton of software that only has Windows binaries available and which I still need either an Intel macOS device or an outright Windows device to run.
Yes I know UTM exists but it's unusably slow and the Windows virtio drivers it ships are outright broken.
- mort96 3y agoEven if you could get Windows working, what good would ARM Windows do? Honestly, running virtualized x86_64 Steam (using something like FEX) under Asahi Linux and using Proton seems like the most fruitful way to play Windows games on Apple Silicon hardware (at least once the GPU drivers mature).
- nxobject 3y agoThere’s one obscure use case that won’t work, sadly - people who have to use proprietary binary only drivers! I’ve been through hell trying to get Oculus Link to work.
- mschuster91 3y agoI meant x86 Windows of course. No other way to flash Samsung or Mediatek phones, for example - the tools are all proprietary and only run on Windows.
- zamadatix 3y agoARM Windows probably already does better than future Asahi+Proton+FEX in that it includes a Rosetta2/FEX like layer of it's own, is otherwise the native Windows without needing to fake that interface, and e.g. Parallels already has DX11 working through Metal without the need for a future version of Asahi drivers combined with the layer in Proton. The downside to either approach is anticheats. Games without them can run great today, games with them can't run at all because they are kernel level x86 code and emulating the kernel architecture is too slow for games. It looks like Windows is doing another ARM push with higher end chips and less vendor exclusivity this time around - maybe that'll finally get enough market penetration to make this less of an issue going forward, at which point virtualized ARM Windows could be nearly fully viable.
- nottorp 3y ago> > Running older versions of macOS in a VM enables users to run Intel-only apps long after Rosetta 2 support is dropped from the current macOS > Now if they'd offer that for x86 Windows guests... Hmm the way i read it they're running older ARM versions of Mac OS in the VMs. Not x86 versions. The virtualization infrastructure doesn't do architecture translation, that is done in software by the OS running inside the VM. As for x86 games... they run pretty well with x86 crossover emulating x86 windows that is then translated by rosetta 2 to arm... is your head spinning yet?
- ngcc_hk 3y agoIf the op premises partially is about when Rosette v2 no longer support, at least the older vm arm based macOS can run Apple intel App using the now current then obsolete Rosette v2. Never thought of that but it happened to power pc App … Tbh they should keep it as unlike powerpc not much people use, intel based app is all around. Having both intel and arm, only one upcoming platform is missing. But supporting a translator as said implicitly in other post is hard. New intel/amd cpu code may appear, ignoring all those amd and nivdia Gpu code which are mostly not supported anyway.