6 ms·
Tallest wooden wind turbine starts turning
- Baldbvrhunter 3y agoSome turbine facts for reference For a typical onshore wind turbine, the tower can contain approximately 295 tons of steel The concrete footings are usually 9 feet thick and 60 feet in diameter, requiring about 300 cubic yards of concrete, which is equivalent to 30 to 40 truckloads. The blades have a 20 year lifespan and cannot be recycled, being made from fiberglass reinforced with plastic, also known as glass fiber reinforced polymer (GFRP). With newer ones also incorporating carbon fiber. All that said, for a turbine to produce enough clean electricity to offset the carbon emissions produced during its manufacturing, installation, and maintenance, is typically around 7 to 8 months.
- cjbenedikt 3y ago"....to offset the carbon emissions produced during its manufacturing, installation, and maintenance, is typically around 7 to 8 months." Finally a clear statement. Never found one like that for DAC. Massive steel and concrete buildings and no answer to exactly that question: how long does it take to recover the CO2 footprint of building these structures.
- Baldbvrhunter 3y agofor wind turbines https://yaleclimateconnections.org/2021/06/whats-the-carbon-footprint-of-a-wind-turbine/ https://yaleclimateconnections.org/2021/06/whats-the-carbon-... https://www.siemensgamesa.com/en-int/explore/journal/uniting-environment-and-technology https://www.siemensgamesa.com/en-int/explore/journal/uniting...
- Xiol32 3y agoUnfortunely it seems these 'wooden turbines' also use fibreglass blades, which is a shame.
- mschild 3y agoNot all of them. https://electrek.co/2022/11/16/wind-turbines-made-entirely-of-wood-are-coming/ https://electrek.co/2022/11/16/wind-turbines-made-entirely-o...
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- adwi 3y agoVery interesting. On average how long until financial break-even, in terms of total investment vs value of electricity produced/sold?
- internetter 3y agoDepends on the site. In the best sites, something like 3 years. In the worst sites, never. Usually, something like 6-10 years.
- CapitalistCartr 3y agoSixty feet in dia. x 9 feet thick is about 950 yards.
- jetrink 3y agoThey are more cone-shaped than cylindrical. 1. https://www.researchgate.net/figure/Illustration-of-the-reinforced-concrete-wind-turbine-foundation-studied-in-this-work_fig1_321907910 https://www.researchgate.net/figure/Illustration-of-the-rein...
- Faaak 3y agoIMHO we should also look at EROI (energy return on investment), which Wikipedia cites [0] to be around ~20, that is a wind turbine will produce 20 times what it cost to make it. [0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_return_on_investment#Wind_turbines https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_return_on_investment#Wi...
- jauntywundrkind 3y agoThe point here that the wooden wind turbine is carbon negative is also a good one (where-as steel and concrete are a big carbon positive) is also worth tracking. I do wish I had a little better idea what the costs of wood were. There have to be nutrients and other resources consumed, that wood takes to produce. I'd love to better appreciate the material flow of wood.
- Brybry 3y agoAlso since it's laminated veneer lumber (LVL) and glued laminated timber (GLT) [1] it's going to have resins/adhesives involved that have an impact as well. Probably still better than the cement in concrete but I don't have a source for that. [1] https://www.windpowermonthly.com/article/1660496/windtech-why-wood-works-modular-low-carbon-towers#:~:text=Erik%20D%C3%B6lerud https://www.windpowermonthly.com/article/1660496/windtech-wh...
- sandworm101 3y agoBy weight, much of that wood is actually glue. The structure is wood fiber held together by chemcial glues. It isnt a tree. It isnt a hand-carved covered bridge. It is an engineered structure filled with modern bits and pieces made out of not-wood.
- dylan604 3y agoI don't know if your listing these as "fun" facts, or as a means to try to denigrate wind turbines. If it pays for itself in 7-8 months while operating for 20 years that's 3% of its lifespan. That's 232 months of clean energy being generated. That's impressive to me. So I don't know what your intent is here, but I'm on board for all of it as a good thing
- russdill 3y agoThat and it's just the lifetime rating for the blades, not the foundation, tower, and hub
- sandworm101 3y agoI would presume that the tower and its foundations, like a large bridge, are functionally immortal. They sound like they should remain useful for a century or more. In such cases the initial carbon cost of construction shouldn't be much of a factor.
- gonzo41 3y agoThe reinforcement in the footing will eventually corrode and so will the tower (even with the best preventative maintenance). The sea likes to ablate things. But I'm sure the engineers are building extra life into the foundations so they can replace the blades every 20 years, and do the tower every 40 at last a few times.
- Baldbvrhunter 3y agohonestly - I was compiling the facts thinking it was going to be much more time for ROI and was happy to have my assumptions invalidated. I'm pro-wind turbine though.
- justin66 3y agoI'm puzzled by these comments. It might take well over a decade for a turbine to truly "pay for itself," depending local energy rates and how the project was financed. If you were to put it in the wrong place, there's no guarantee it will ever pay for itself. (not that a wind turbine was ever built for political rather than hard-headed economic reasons - that never happens!)
- dukeyukey 3y ago> and cannot be recycled This myth just won't disappear. Fiberglass isn't easy to recycle, but we absolutely can and do: https://www.energy.gov/eere/wind/articles/carbon-rivers-makes-wind-turbine-blade-recycling-and-upcycling-reality-support https://www.energy.gov/eere/wind/articles/carbon-rivers-make... https://www.siemensgamesa.com/en-int/newsroom/2021/09/launch-world-first-recyclable-wind-turbine-blade https://www.siemensgamesa.com/en-int/newsroom/2021/09/launch... https://www.nationalgrid.com/stories/energy-explained/can-wind-turbine-blades-be-recycled https://www.nationalgrid.com/stories/energy-explained/can-wi...
- c048 3y agoA lot of things deemed 'unrecyclable' actually are. It's just that it's usually not worth it.
- tcbawo 3y agoAs is often the case, “nobody will do it at market rates” simply becomes “can’t”
- andrewflnr 3y agoFor planning purposes, "will not be recycled in real life" is indistinguishable from "cannot be recycled".
- colechristensen 3y agoBut who cares? If you grind up and bury fiberglass, you’re sequestering carbon and melted sand. I’m fine with this. People intentionally burying carbon do so to celebration when they’re doing it on purpose and selling carbon credits.
- p1mrx 3y ago> The blades have a 20 year lifespan What stops us from making blades with a 60 year lifespan?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- dylan604 3y agoit would be interesting if this is a material science issue where UV exposure just breaks things down to the point that after a certain point they are just unsafe from to be spinning at the rates and mass involved. that's a lot of kinetic energy if an unscheduled rapid disassembly were to occur.
- tuatoru 3y agoYes, it's a material science issue. With stronger materials they would just make the blades longer because the power produced is proportional to the square of blade length (or cube?). Anyway, the blades will be at the limits of material strength (over a reasonable lifetime).
- coryrc 3y agoAblation is one problem, fatigue is another.
- skyfaller 3y agoPaging Low-Tech Magazine! I wonder how they feel about these partly wooden turbines: https://solar.lowtechmagazine.com/2019/06/reinventing-the-small-wind-turbine/ https://solar.lowtechmagazine.com/2019/06/reinventing-the-sm... https://solar.lowtechmagazine.com/2019/06/how-to-make-wind-power-sustainable-again/ https://solar.lowtechmagazine.com/2019/06/how-to-make-wind-p... I expect they would be disappointed that it's not all wood, and also skeptical of these being mass-produced with engineered wood rather than made by local artisans out of regular wood. Can the wood parts be recycled or composted? What happens at the end of life? To quote Low-Tech Mag on composite blades, "The environmental damage of the carbon-epoxy spars can be viewed as acceptable, if compared to the larger damage done by conventional wind turbine blades. However, the waste problem would not be solved, and further growth in wind power would still result in ever larger waste streams."
- Gare 3y ago> If wind would supply a more desirable 40% of (current) power demand, there would be three to four million tonnes of waste per year. For comparison, New York City produces 14 million tons of waste per year. Doesn't seem as dramatic when put in context.
- lovecg 3y agoIt’s like that scare mongering about wind turbines killing hundreds of thousands of birds per year. It’s laughable when compared with billions of birds that _cats_ kill. Any discussion of this topic is ripe with emotionally charged misstatements, I’m careful about taking anything at face value anymore.
- internetter 3y agoCats kill between 1.3 and 4.0 billion birds a year: https://dariuszzdziebk.wpenginepowered.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/09/Loss_et_al._2013-Impacts_Outdoor_Cats.pdf https://dariuszzdziebk.wpenginepowered.com/wp-content/upload... — Smithsonian Conservation Biology Institute & U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service From https://climate.mit.edu/ask-mit/do-wind-turbines-kill-birds https://climate.mit.edu/ask-mit/do-wind-turbines-kill-birds - Wind turbines kill something around a million birds every year - Power lines kill something around 25 times that - And "A 2012 study found that wind projects kill 0.269 birds per gigawatt-hour of electricity produced, compared to 5.18 birds killed per gigawatt-hour of electricity from fossil fuel projects"
- kpmcc 3y agoPossibly a dumb question, but what if this gets struck by lightning?
- throwaway24124 3y agoNot a dumb question, I’m assuming it’s been treated with flame-retardant chemicals, but I’m surprised that it’s fireproof-ness wasn’t addressed in the article.
- Animats 3y agoSince they are the tallest thing around, wind turbine blades get struck by lightning regularly. Fiberglas is an insulator. Aluminum is a good conductor. But carbon fiber is a resistor. Carbon fiber blades have to have embedded conductors to prevent from being blown up by lightning strikes. So there's a layer of aluminum foil or similar to provide a low-resistance discharge path. Same problem as carbon-fiber aircraft, with similar solutions.
- jagger27 3y agoI’m sure they’re still electrically grounded. I’d be shocked if they didn’t have lightning rods, not to mention all of the metallic innards like ladders and wiring that would have much lower resistance than the wood itself.
- jacquesm 3y agoThat's not a dumb question at all. Lightning protection is a different story than when the tower itself conducts. The nacelle (the part that houses the generator) is grounded and so are the blades (they have an integral conducting mesh). All of this is conducted all the way to ground level by conductors much the same as what you'd see on a wooden house with lightning protection. I'm not sure what they've done on the outside of the structure, but I suspect that the chances of the nacelle or the blades being hit are far higher than the chances of the tower itself being hit directly. If it does get hit it might ignite so there is still some part that more detail would help on, I can't see anything special in the photographs accompanying the article.
- mulmen 3y ago> As long as the wood doesn't end up rotting or being burned, the carbon is not released. So this is only carbon negative if the trees are net-new and we recycle or sequester the wood at the end of the service life. I’m skeptical of trees as an effective carbon sink for the purpose of slowing global warming until we have a way to sequester the carbon on geological time scales. This is a great technology and if wood has a smaller footprint than existing material it is a win. I see how wood could be carbon neutral. I’m less certain about it being net-negative.
- berkes 3y agoIf there were no humans to cut forests down, they'd be renewing themselves too. Trees die, fall and rot. Releasing a part of their captured carbon back, and releasing some methane (a worse greenhouse gas than carbon-dioxide). Now that there are humans to cut them down, it makes no difference in re-release of carbon, as long as we replenish the forests in the same rate as we cut them down. Which we don't, but we could. Point being, on the grand scale of things, using (not burning) wood is fine as long as it is renewed. Letting it rot or burning it after use, is fine too. It's what the world would do without humans anyway, without that causing a run-off greenhouse effect. Obviously, processing wood costs energy (footprint), but from what I know when I studied this stuff (early 2000s) steel and concrete are way, way (way!) worse in this, so on that scale too, wood is preferable. It really is magic stuff.
- mulmen 3y agoI agree. But you are describing a carbon neutral system. The article claims wooden wind turbines are carbon negative. This is only true on a short time scale. Once all wind turbines are wood and the first generation reaches EOL they become carbon neutral.
- berkes 3y agoMaybe they are "carbon negative" in the same way as many datacenters or international flights are "carbon neutral": by buying it off: e.g. planting more trees than they cut? But I guess you are right and they're just doing short-term bookkeeping here.
- interroboink 3y agoThe Spruce Goose flies again; in a new form (: Laminated wood is a pretty cool building material. There's typically a lot of epoxy/resin/glue involved though — it's not "just" wood.
- botanical 3y agoIn my ignorance I assumed the blades would be wooden since that has a lifespan and needs to be replaced. A steel base would last for all eternity, so what's the point of a wooden base? Wind turbines offset the carbon emissions in the span of a year.
- omnimus 3y agoThey say it in the article. Its modular and easier to transport so higher towers can be build.
- RecycledEle 3y agoThere is no wood wind turbine that large. The wind turbine has (mostly) fiberglass blades. The tower supporting the wind turbine is partly made of wood.