3 ms·
> You're assuming that people would disregard the labels. People do disregard labels including those with allergies. > If the label was only on products with
by Retric 3y ago
> You're assuming that people would disregard the labels.
People do disregard labels including those with allergies.
> If the label was only on products with a significant risk of causing cancer from ordinary use, it would be rare and people wouldn't ignore it. In other words, if it was only on the products that would otherwise be banned.
Ahh, but the risks are high enough that companies will still put that label on everything unless companies where required to only put such a label on products with significant risk which then gets back to regulators.
- AnthonyMouse 3y ago> People do disregard labels including those with allergies. Exception that proves the rule. The purpose of the law is to protect people who act within reason. If you have an allergy and don't read the label, that's on you, not the company or the government. > Ahh, but the risks are such companies will still put that label on everything unless companies where required to only put such a label on products with significant risk which then gets back to regulators. The entire point is that "regulators say you have to label this" and "regulators say you cannot buy this even with informed consent" are two different things.
- riversflow 3y ago> The purpose of the law is to protect people who act within reason. This is just flat out wrong, and pretty gross. The purpose of the law is to protect people. Not white people, not land-owning people, not smart people, not literate people, not able-bodied people, not "reasonable" people. People. Full stop. Assuming people are reasonable is a recipe for disaster, and ablest. Perhaps one day someone you know will get dementia, or have a stroke, or get macular degeneration, or any of the number of ailments that can relieve you of your ability to read and comprehend long texts, lists, and warnings, then maybe you will understand how ridiculous this view is.
- AnthonyMouse 3y agoI hope your argument isn't that only white people can exercise reason. If you have a mental illness you can go to the store and buy rat poison and eat it. The law doesn't address this by prohibiting rodenticides. If you think you can fly and jump off the roof of a parking structure, the government can't disable gravity. Acting within reason in that context is getting treatment, which is a whole different set of laws.
- Retric 3y agoThis isn’t about extremely dumb behavior, this is about extreme consequences for reasonable actions. If you walk up to a food truck you shouldn’t need to worry about long term mercury exposure from a single lunch. But the same is true if you happen to eat the same item from the same truck for 30 years. The maximum allowable exposure from food is very different between those two cases. But the second case isn’t unreasonable so that’s what the standard should be set for.
- AnthonyMouse 3y agoIt seems like the main issue here is that the level of "informed" has to scale with the level of danger and surprise. If the product is bread and "wheat" is listed as an ingredient, someone with a gluten allergy can be reasonably expected to suss this out. If the product is a granola bar and it contains shellfish, maybe this should be separately noted and not just somewhere in the middle of the ingredients list. If the product contains unsafe levels of mercury, the words "This Product Contains Unsafe Levels Of Mercury" better be featured at least as prominently as the name of the product.
- riversflow 3y agoMy argument is that you are picking a specific group and saying the law is only for them. >If you think you can fly and jump off the roof of a parking structure, the government can't disable gravity The law can make it so you have guardrail on your roof if it is publicly accessible. The law can also make you put up suicide guards if it's really a problem, all of my favorite bridge have them now. > The law doesn't address this by prohibiting rodenticides. Rat poison has actually been getting more scrutiny lately, the traditional pellet form was banned this year in favor of bricks in the US, and non-professional exterminators are limited to buying it a pound at a time. Also, rats are a real pressing problem that is being handled with rat poison. Without it, we go back to food security problems related to controlling pest populations. The same can't be said in reverse, we don't have a real, pressing problem with an overabundance of safety.
- Exoristos 3y agoDo you really have any idea what a body of laws would look like that treated the public as though everyone has "dementia, ... a stroke," and "macular degeneration"?
- ben_w 3y ago"Everyone has" goes beyond what the op wrote. "Anyone could have" is closer. From what little of various laws I've looked at (with the huge caveat that I'm not a lawyer), I think they are written to assume the general public doesn't know what's going on most of the time.
- ben_w 3y ago> Perhaps one day someone you know will get dementia To further this point with anecdotes, both my mother and my grandmother had dementia. Gran started a pot of water boiling, left the room, forgot about it, and thought the subsequent smoke alarm was her neighbours'. Mum stopped being able to count past four, and lost general concept of things existing on the left side of objects from her PoV[0]. When my mum noticed my gran had forgotten to renew her road tax (and noticed this six months after it had expired), she hid the car keys until gran forgot she had a car. When my mum got dementia herself, a similar thing happened. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hemispatial_neglect https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hemispatial_neglect which is distinct from https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homonymous_hemianopsia https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homonymous_hemianopsia — eating dinner, thinking she'd finished, but left half of her plate was full of food she couldn't see until we rotated it 180°, sketching my face and missing my right (her left), that thing with the clock: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:AllochiriaClock.png https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:AllochiriaClock.png
- VBprogrammer 3y agoYou are being extremely naive I'm afraid. People with allergies have to disregard labels every day. Almost everything edible in the UK had these labels. I just looked at the back of the chocolate wrapper I just ate and it "may contain nuts, eggs and peanuts." None of those things are ingredients and the warning is just there to prevent a law suit. My friend who has a severe allergy to eggs and nuts would eat it - otherwise he'd have a very bland diet indeed.
- Retric 3y ago> “regulators say you have to label this” and “regulators say you cannot buy this even with informed consent” are two different things They are the same issue, because labels get applied even when not needed which destroys informed consent. Allergies cover a huge range of sensitivities. People with quite severe allergies can consume small quantities and not notice when someone else with the exact same allergies just in a more severe form would die from consuming it. Thus ‘may contain nuts’ isn’t informed consent what’s needed is a sliding scale of risks not CYA language on basically every package.
- AnthonyMouse 3y agoSo the labeling requirements need a sliding scale. There still isn't anything to ban.
- Retric 3y agoNot just a sliding scale but an accurate sliding scale with inaccurate labeling resulting in a ban. However, allergies aren’t universally harmful. There’s no compelling reason to allow food products with high levels of heavy metals.