3 ms·
The thing that gave me pause the first time I thought about it (it was during a test so I couldn’t ask or check) was that if zero is even, that means (despite n
by latexr 3y ago
The thing that gave me pause the first time I thought about it (it was during a test so I couldn’t ask or check) was that if zero is even, that means (despite numbers being infinite) there’s one more even number than odd numbers.
I also knew that 1 is not prime, even if logically it should be. Its definition specifically states a prime number needs to be greater than 1. So that means mathematics sometimes has exceptions for numbers inside a definition.
Given that, it’s not immediately obvious that zero would be even. It wouldn’t be odd either, that was out of the questions, but it could be neither.
- eru 3y ago> The thing that gave me pause the first time I thought about it (it was during a test so I couldn’t ask or check) was that if zero is even, that means (despite numbers being infinite) there’s one more even number than odd numbers. Thanks to Hilbert's Hotel you can re-arrange the numbers to have an arbitrarily larger or smaller overhang of even or odd numbers. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hilbert%27s_paradox_of_the_Grand_Hotel https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hilbert%27s_paradox_of_the_Gra... > I also knew that 1 is not prime, even if logically it should be. Its definition specifically states a prime number needs to be greater than 1. So that means mathematics sometimes has exceptions for numbers inside a definition. The definition I use is that a prime number needs to have exactly two distinct divisors. No need for any special cases in this definition. (The motivation for this somewhat strange definition is so that factoring any positive number, including 1, into a multiset of her prime factors is unique. If you redefine the prime numbers to include 1, prime factoring is not unique. Of course, you could still make everything work out in the end: you just need to declare that your new-prime factoring is unique up to the multiplicity of 1s. Just like eg standard decimal numbers don't change if you add leading 0s, new-prime factoring would not change if you add factors of 1. You can do math with almost any arbitrary definitions, if you add enough exceptions and explanations in your theorems to work around the rough edges in your definitions.)
- latexr 3y ago> Thanks to Hilbert's Hotel That makes no difference to the numbers that exist, it only changes which ones you count for the duration of that thought experiment. > The definition I use is that a prime number needs to have exactly two distinct divisors. No need for any special cases in this definition. You’re still making up a special case with the explicit goal of excluding a particular number. It’s a roundabout definition that requires more thought and will be lost on most people which don’t already know the regular one.