3 ms·
> But I disagree with the underlying assumption that you can anthropomorphize LLMs. Gradient descent and backpropagation don't take place in the brain. LLMs "le
by ben_w 3y ago
> But I disagree with the underlying assumption that you can anthropomorphize LLMs. Gradient descent and backpropagation don't take place in the brain. LLMs "learn" in the same way that Excel sheets "learn".
Backprop doesn't happen in us, but I think our neurones still do gradient descent – synapses that fire together, wire together.
And ultimately, at the deepest level we can analyse, our brains' atoms are doing quantum field diffusion equations, which you can also do in an Excel spreadsheet, so that kind of reductionism doesn't help either.
> Humans are living beings with needs and rights. A person being able to legally squat in a home doesn't mean that a drone occupying property for some amount of time also has squatter's rights, even though you could easily and affordably automate and scale the deployment of drones to live and hide away on properties long enough to attain rights regarding properties all over the country.
Yes, but we can also do tissue cultures and crude bioprinting, so it's a very foreseeable future where exactly the same argument will also be true for living organisms rather than digital minds.
We need to figure out what the deeper rules are that lead to the status quo, not merely mimic the superficial result. The latter is how cargo cults function.
- danans 3y ago> We need to figure out what the deeper rules are that lead to the status quo, not merely mimic the superficial result. Sure, that's an interesting path of inquiry, and one should be free to understand themselves as being no different than a machine if they desire. But the objective of laws is the benefit of (at least some) humans, not machines covered in lab grown tissue. The process of being human is a big part of what makes us human.
- ben_w 3y ago> machines covered in lab grown tissue I think you're misapprehending — I mean an entity fully 3D printed out of tissue, no machinery (unless you're counting all biology as machinery, but I think you're not doing that). I recon bio-printing is now where home computing was in the Apple 1 era, so this is a way off, but it's foreseeable. > The process of being human is a big part of what makes us human. Mmm. How much has that process that changed since the ancient world?
- riversflow 3y agoI recon bio-printing is now where home computing was in the Apple 1 era How do you recon that, Apple 1 was Turing complete. We haven't printed life, that would be a tremendous accomplishment. I think we're closer to Edison inventing a lightbulb as a step to computers being possible. Printing a conscious thing, at all, would be like the transistor. An Apple 1 analogue wouldn't be likely because of the terrible ethics of a "shitty" printed human.
- ben_w 3y ago> We haven't printed life, that would be a tremendous accomplishment. Sure we have, and in multiple different senses. The ones which matters here are cell culture, which is nowhere near the fanciest bar that's been surpassed in this field, and tissue culture which is somewhat harder but the reason why I recon it's at the Apple 1 level is that a small number of experimentalists are messing around with it using expensive equipment that you can technically buy at home but you need to be well trained to actually use, for example: https://youtu.be/Z_ZGq8Tah0k?si=u6bBatjuSWcyNYJ3 https://youtu.be/Z_ZGq8Tah0k?si=u6bBatjuSWcyNYJ3 And, more broadly, there's bioprinting as a research etc. field: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/3D_bioprinting https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/3D_bioprinting And here's a TED talk from ten years ago where they demoed an early research 3D printed kidney on stage: https://youtu.be/bX3C201O4MA?t=11m46s https://youtu.be/bX3C201O4MA?t=11m46s
- riversflow 3y ago> Sure we have, and in multiple different senses. No. That isn't printing life, that is taking already living cells, priming and transforming them into something useful. Regardless, I'd count it if we could make an entire living organism this way, but we cant. Creating a working organ is no doubt amazing, and proof that this technology is worth pursuing, but it isn't "printing life" any more than producing life saving drugs is. In your example you are talking about being able to bioprint a person(they have to be a person to have that right) to squat a property. Bio printing an organ isn't an example of that, it's not even close. Saying that we are anywhere near being able to print a human to squat a property is pretty ridiculous.
- ml-anon 3y ago>Backprop doesn't happen in us, but I think our neurones still do gradient descent – synapses that fire together, wire together. No! Hebbian learning is categorically NOT gradient based learning. Hebbian update rules are local and not the gradient of any function. Cortical learning is so vastly different from how artificial neural networks “learn” they cannot even begin to be meaningfully compared mathematically. Hebbian learning is not optimization and backprop is not local learning. Part of the problem of these discussions is a bunch of clueless people talking with authority.
- ben_w 3y agoFinally, a good counterargument. I've seen enough terrible arguments to know exactly how you feel — even in specifically just AI. I have to keep reminding myself that outside of my own speciality, ChatGPT knows more than me despite its weaknesses, so I bet ChatGPT knows more about Hebbian learning than I do. I'll look into that more.