2 ms·
You’re begging the question. Just because people who study the same objects as culture, tradition, and religion, call their field a “science” does not mean we h
by rayiner 3y ago
You’re begging the question. Just because people who study the same objects as culture, tradition, and religion, call their field a “science” does not mean we have to accept their terminology. I would call their field something more akin to theology, with the use of numbers being a sort of ritualistic exercise. Gay’s presidency is consistent with that—it simply abandons the pretense that those trappings actually matter to the field.
- tptacek 3y agoIt's called "science" because it uses the tools of science to address questions about its subjects. Like all sciences, it makes predictions and tests them. As any social scientist will tell you, it is much more difficult to model and predict social phenomenon than basic physical phenomenon. You know that, which is why, in the message on the other branch of this thread, you couch your objection in "precise" predictions --- not an actual qualifier of science, but a decent rhetorical hedge. Ultimately though, you're just quibbling with the name. You're as intensively interested in this field of study as its practitioners; from economics to developmental psychology, it is almost all you talk about. That's fine! But really, you just object to the conclusions you perceive social scientists to be arriving at.
- rayiner 3y ago> you're just quibbling with the name. I'm not quibbling with the name, I'm objecting to classifying them together with real scientists. That classification has immense implications for how society views them and their assertions. I'd be fine if they called themselves scientists, if we called real scientists something else. The point is that society should recognize that their aping of scientific methodology confers no special validity to their conclusions.
- dctoedt 3y ago> I'm objecting to classifying them together with real scientists. Do you regard meteorology as a science? As a group, meteorologists aspire to make the best predictions they can with the available tools AND to develop better tools. As near as I can tell, social scientists do basically the same (as exemplified by, e.g., Kahneman and Tversky).
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]