2 ms·
The idea of measuring the “efficiency” of the tax system in terms of money in per money out seems a bit odd to me in the first place. Taxes don’t create wealth,
by bee_rider 3y ago
The idea of measuring the “efficiency” of the tax system in terms of money in per money out seems a bit odd to me in the first place. Taxes don’t create wealth, the job is to destroy it at the correct rate.
Don’t get me wrong, I’m not a “taxes are theft” dummy or anything like that. Taxes are an important knob in shaping the economy. But a better functioning tax collection agency should more effectively implement the rules of whose money is collected for deletion, not just collect more money generally.
- xboxnolifes 3y agoIt's still a useful measure to be aware of. Imagine if the IRS costed 30% of collected taxes to run instead of 0.4%. That would be a pretty telling sign that maybe we need to improve the IRS instead of raising taxing.
- bee_rider 3y agoOnly, I think, in the sense that it would be bad if it was very expensive. It just isn’t an efficiency, in the <achieved quantity>/<total quantity> sense. The measurement of <tax revenue>/<money spend on tax collection> is meaningless in the same way that a comparison between the energy required to flip a light switch and the energy that is sent to that socket as a result is basically meaningless. I mean, sure, if tending a light switch required an appreciable percentage of the amount of the energy the socket could provide, that would be bad, but it is a ridiculous scenario.
- Frost1x 3y ago>Taxes don’t create wealth, the job is to destroy it at the correct rate. Not exactly, it's more about redistributing or reappropriating wealth because we know there exists flaws in the economic system we have (progressive tax systems). In more general terms, ignoring progressive structures, it's about investing in necessary shared services for everyone and to maintain the government that does such and more. Looking at taxes as if they destroy wealth is a bit bleak. Governments may not be the most efficient institutions in all possible metrics but they're not out to destroy wealth exactly.
- bee_rider 3y agoI don’t think it needs to be seen as bleak; money just exists as a tool, it doesn’t have any other meaning, sometimes destroying it is the best thing to do. It is fungible anyway, so I think it is really just a matter of semantics or philosophy if the government is collecting and redistributing dollars, or if it is destroying and creating them. My (outsider) understanding is that modern monetary theory leans toward the latter, because it more accurately reflects the latitude the government has, working with a fiat currency and all that.