2 ms·
Funny, my take on Oppenheimer is the opposite -- and I loved both movies. Nolan is making the explicit argument that Oppenheimer is the most important person o
by crazygringo 3y ago
Funny, my take on Oppenheimer is the opposite -- and I loved both movies.
Nolan is making the explicit argument that Oppenheimer is the most important person of the 20th century, it's literally a biopic that adheres (shockingly) faithfully to history, is explaining everything to you from the history of Los Alamos to justifications to drop the bomb to arguments for and against the H-bomb, and you come out of the theater absolutely ready to debate the issues.
Oppenheimer is the literal opposite of art for art's sake. It's a straight-up history lesson that presents different sides of one of the biggest moral questions of the 20th century.
Now other films of his, whether Tenet or Inception or Interstellar -- those are much more art-for-art's-sake. You can discuss them aesthetically all you want, but aside from questions of taste and clarity and plot, there isn't much of substance to debate.
(On the other hand -- while Barbie was hyped as providing a lot to discuss, it was actually mostly just a very clever super funny comedy. It didn't really lead to all that much debate, aside from whether the idea of playing guitar "at" someone was merely a really funny joke, or one of top five funniest jokes in the movie...)
- aaomidi 3y agoThe whole Barbie thing wasn’t important until the vocal political right made it their new public enemy #1.
- cameldrv 3y agoIMO the movie is making the point that Oppenheimer's security clearance review was politically motivated and essentially baseless. There's also a scene where Oppenheimer demands that workers without a clear need to know be told what they are building for morale/efficiency reasons. The fact is though that the Manhattan Project had multiple Soviet spies, and Oppenheimer's policies enabled them. It's even come out more recently that Oppenheimer is mentioned as a Soviet intelligence source in a decrypted cable from the San Francisco consulate.