2 ms·
your projection that human world marketed energy consumption will increase by a factor of 1000× within a century may be correct, but it is far outside the range
by kragen 3y ago
your projection that human world marketed energy consumption will increase by a factor of 1000× within a century may be correct, but it is far outside the range of mainstream predictions, and far faster than current growth
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/World_energy_supply_and_consumption#Total_energy_supply https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/World_energy_supply_and_consum... shows total energy supply (excluding agriculture) growing from 8700 million toe in 01990 to 14500 million toe in 02021, a 67% increase, or 1.66% per year. extrapolating that until 02123 we get only a factor of 5.4× growth, not the 1000× you're predicting
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> projection that human world marketed energy consumption will increase by a factor of 1000× within a century may be correct We currently produce about 2% [1] of the Earth’s insolation, or 6% of that which hits land. So you’re talking factors of 16 to 50, which at 2% growth means 140 years to the former. Again, assuming perfect efficiency and no clouds, et cetera. If we assume 50% efficiency (still with no clouds) and covering half of all the Earth’s land in solar panels, we have about 70 years. It’s ludicrous to assume we won’t see diminishing marginal returns in a quarter of that time. [1] 26 936 TWh [a] / (340 W/sqm [b] x 510mm sqkm x 1000 x 365 days x 24 hours) [a] https://assets.researchsquare.com/files/rs-2026113/v1/1dff0ac3-4472-45de-8b68-4d4abec6efc9.pdf?c=1685628898 https://assets.researchsquare.com/files/rs-2026113/v1/1dff0a... [b] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Earth%27s_energy_budget https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Earth%27s_energy_budget
- kragen 3y ago14500 million toe per year is 19 terawatts, roughly world marketed energy consumption; 1000 watts per m² (nominal solar constant below the atmosphere) times 1.28 × 10¹⁴ m² (area of a circle with radius 6371km) is 128000 terawatts. 19 is 0.015% of 128000, not 2%. so why do your calculations differ? let's see possibly by '510mm sqkm' you mean 510 million square kilometers, as opposed to, say, 510 millimeter square kilometers (which would work out to 510'000 m³). 510 million square kilometers is a good value for the surface area of earth (4πr² ≈ 510066 km²) and 340 watts per square meter is a reasonable estimate for 24-hour mean insolation, disregarding clouds. but 340 watts per square meter times 510 million square kilometers gives 173000 terawatts, higher than my estimate. in terawatt hours per year, that's 1.52 billion terawatt hours per year, which is definitely a lot more than 50 times 26936 terawatt hours i think maybe your error there is that you were trying to convert from square kilometers to square meters by multiplying by 1000. but actually a square kilometer contains a million square meters, not a thousand. so you ended up calculating about 2% instead of about 0.002%, which is what your inputs give if calculated correctly using the units(1) program from unix is a good way to avoid errors like this; in this case you can do the calculation as follows: You have: 26936 TWh / (340W/m^2 * 4 pi earthradius^2 * 1 year) You want: % * 0.0017718851 / 564.37068 however, you also made a smaller error in the opposite direction. the 26936 terawatt hours per year figure is only a small fraction of the total energy supply; as the paper you linked explains: > Considering electrical energy, while 6,131 TWh of energy was produced in 1973, 26,936 TWh of electrical energy was produced in 2019 (IEA, 2021c). that's only about 3 terawatts, not 19, because it excludes virtually the entire transport sector, coal consumption by steel mills, climate-control heat and process heat provided directly by fossil fuels, inefficiencies in the electrical generation process, etc. using the correct figure of 19 terawatts, we derive that world marketed energy consumption is currently 0.01% of global terrestrial insolation, including light that hits clouds and oceans but not including light absorbed or reflected by the atmosphere growing energy consumption by this factor of 6700 at 1.66% per year would take 535 years, but in fact now that pv has dropped the cost of energy so dramatically, i expect energy production growth to speed up. also presumably there will be power-production satellites in solar orbit within decades, permitting progress past kardashev type 1 hope this helps!
- defrost 3y ago510 million square kilometers is a good value for the surface area of earth (4πr² ≈ 510,064,000 km²) (using R = 6,371 km a figure between the equatorial and polar radius of the ellipsoid)
- JumpCrisscross 3y agoYou’re 100% correct. Sorry. Dimensional analysis FTW. My broader point is this: as we deploy solar, mass production and learning curves will reduce costs. But diminishing returns will increase them. Given insolation is not limitless, we should see that curve stretch upwards and eventually intersect other power sources. To suggest otherwise is to say we should monosource solar.
- kragen 3y agono worries yeah, eventually the humans will start to feel the limits of the terrestrial solar resource, but at well over 100 times current world marketed energy consumption, at which point they will have reached the energy intensity level you thought they were already at