6 ms·
NYT sues OpenAI, Microsoft over 'millions of articles' used to train ChatGPT
- scotty79 3y ago- Alexa, what's a New York Times? - There's no such thing as New York Times.
- hoppyhoppy2 3y agoBeing discussed at https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38781941 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38781941
- pama 3y agoThere is no proof so far that openAI has violated any copyright. I understand the public’s emotions but recall that these large language models can read all the public info and make useful generalizations.
- Retric 3y agoBeing public doesn’t mean copyright goes away. If you can’t use a 3rd party program even once without permission why would you assume you could use someone’s book etc to train a model without similar permission? My guess is there’s going to be an exception given, but that’s not yet decided.
- tracerbulletx 3y agoBecause the law has never delt with the concept of training models like these before and it's not just automatically the same thing as republishing something non-transformative no matter how much some people want to just assert that it is without actually thinking about it. It's a new case, that probably needs new different types of protections and consideration.
- oh_sigh 3y agoDoes the law care about the method(whether it is ML or just reading the article from a database) if the model can spit out a verbatim copy of an article?
- MeImCounting 3y agoI see this argument everywhere and have yet to succeed in getting ChatGPT to give an article. This argument is basically a non-starter
- Retric 3y agoResearchers have gotten large chunks of verbatim text. Suggesting it’s only infringing if the entire work is reproduced is legally incorrect and therefore irrelevant. https://mashable.com/article/chatgpt-revealed-personal-data-verbatim-text-attack-researchers https://mashable.com/article/chatgpt-revealed-personal-data-...
- paulddraper 3y ago> Suggesting it’s only infringing if the entire work is reproduced is legally incorrect It may not be conclusive, but it's highly suggestive: > Amount and substantiality of the portion used in relation to the copyrighted work as a whole: Under this factor, courts look at both the quantity and quality of the copyrighted material that was used. If the use includes a large portion of the copyrighted work, fair use is less likely to be found; if the use employs only a small amount of copyrighted material, fair use is more likely. > https://www.copyright.gov/fair-use/ https://www.copyright.gov/fair-use/
- Retric 3y agoContext is important when reading that, just 7 words can be copyright infringement.
- oh_sigh 3y ago
- logicchains 3y ago> If you can’t use a 3rd party program even once without permission why would you assume you could use someone’s book etc to train a model without similar permission? Because you're trying build a silicon brain, and a carbon-based brain is allowed to learn from books and articles without permission (e.g. reading them at the library or online), so why shouldn't a silicon brain also be allowed to learn that way?
- throwaway788 3y agoYeah, but that carbon-based brain should have also obtained the learning material legally. Why would a “silicon-based brain” be any different.
- cxr 3y agoIn a discussion, one should strive not just to stick to saying things that are true, but to make sure that what they're saying is both true and relevant. People should obtain their learning material legally. True statement (at least as "true" as any opinionated value judgement can be, I guess). The question is how, though, is that statement relevant here? Even by the NYT's own telling (the way that OpenAI obtained their articles was from the NYT's website) what OpenAI did was not illegal copyright infringement. The problem is that NYT is under the impression that allowing search engines to access their paywalled stuff and hoping they don't do anything else with it besides putting up conventional, Google-style SERPs makes for copyright infringement if what one of them actually wants it for involves other reasons. It doesn't. There's an adequate legal instrument available for NYT to use if they want to enforce conditions on use: a contract. Do they have a contract that somebody violated? If not, they have no cause to go after anyone. And if they do have a contract that was violated, then that's still not copyright infringement—it's a breach of their contract.
- Retric 3y agoYou seem to be confused, giving someone permission to do X is only permission to do X and nothing else. If I open a store you have implied permission to enter the premises, but not stay inside for 16 hours. Further the second I ask you to leave you no longer have permission to be on the premises. The store doesn’t need to add a lock or put up signs, you’re aware you don’t have permission and that’s it.
- salawat 3y ago...Are you forgetting the fact that every clickwrapped application that doesn't have a network gated auth is just a binary patch away from being "legally impotent". In point of fact, one of what I consider the "shadow innovations" of the technical era is that we even accepted the idea of clickwrapped contracting as a valid legal construct; especially given the fact a canonical requirement of a contract "a meeting of the minds" never substantially happens. (No redline accommodation, no valid contract imo).
- shadowgovt 3y agoEssentially, it may very well be the case that AI resynthesis is in a category so novel that copyright (which is itself a completely artificial construct composed wholly of law, with no grounding in natural rights whatsoever) has not predicted it and is utterly mute on what should be done with it one way or the other. If that is the case, the time has come for novel law to address the issue. And that will be a hell of a political fight because it will basically boil down to who we feel should have more rights and resources in society.
- jgalt212 3y agoThis statement ignores that fact that often, or too often, LLMs just regurgitate the training data. Direct reproduction is not a derivative work.
- tbrownaw 3y ago> understand the public’s emotions but recall that Is it actually the public, or is it three dinosaurs wearing a PR campaign?
- ChainOfFools 3y agoThe same had been said, with probably more justification, about YouTube for the first few years of its life, and yet it's still here.
- chung8123 3y agoYouTube is still based on copyright violation but there is no way to stop it so publishers play ball. There is no way music companies would allow their stuff on there for so cheap if they could stop it.
- tanseydavid 3y ago>> There is no way music companies would allow their stuff on there for so cheap if they could stop it. Which is just another way of saying "Music Companies would stop technological progress itself if it affects their bottom line (and they can figure out a way to do it)."
- silveira 3y agoI came here to say that. At some point I could literally what full movies on Youtube, pretty much anything I searched.
- hulitu 3y agoYou can still do it.
- jeremyjh 3y agoYoutube is paying royalties though.
- ChainOfFools 3y agothey are now, yes. But that was not the case in the beginning, before Google bought it, people uploaded content completely without any regard to intellectual property and YouTube became the dominant streaming media platform and a couple of otherwise fairly skilled but hardly exceptional software engineers were made multi-millionaires) because it was the place to get free stuff that you'd otherwise have to pay for.
- asdefghyk 3y agoDid Microsoft use its vast source code repositories to rain its AI? Did Google use its vast source code repositories to rain its AI ? They would also have vast s of user manuals etc. That are copyright? where these used too Does anyone know ??
- hulitu 3y agoOf course not. If i steal from Google or Microsoft it is copyright infrigement. If Google or Microsoft steals from me it is business as usual.
- ProxCoques 3y agoCopyright in its current form needs to die. It doesn't protect the artist, it protects their publishers and those who benefit from the sweat of their brow after the artist is dead. Protect works for 7 years renewable for 7 and no more.
- telesilla 3y ago7 years isn't realistic in the case of many authors and artists whose work becomes more valuable after time on the market, awards given as they mature etc.
- kemotep 3y agoAdditionally if your concern is that artists and authors aren’t being paid, a 14 year copyright term is nothing. A corporation would just contract you to make a work, complete whatever minimum release is necessary to get copyright, then wait until it’s public domain to wide release a remastered version that they no longer have to pay royalties on since it is public domain. Despite how many negatives the current copyright regime has, having to wait 70 years after the death of the author is far too long of a timeframe for that strategy to play out.
- surgical_fire 3y ago> A corporation would just contract you to make a work In that case, by definition, the artist was paid.
- kemotep 3y agoThe last round of strikes by the writers and actors unions were about royalties. Being paid for a spec or a per diem while making the movie can be peanuts. Big name actors and writers make percentages on the backend.
- ProxCoques 3y agoI'm not concerned about that. And if I was, why should artists be treated differently to anyone else who chooses to charge for the product of their efforts? Copyright didn't exist before 1710. Art sure did though. A protection of 7 years seems fine by that measure. Go make some more art after that expires. Or even before!
- mensetmanusman 3y agotax the ai companies and just give it back to the creators then.
- pseudocomposer 3y agoPerhaps it’s time to end the notion of copyright entirely. It’s been flawed since its inception, but more obviously so since the digital age made it apparent that information wants to be free, and will always find a way to be so. Does modern copyright have any purpose other than maintaining the existing class order?