6 ms·
The side effects of most cancer treatments are aweful. How do they compare?
by bluGill 3y ago
The side effects of most cancer treatments are aweful. How do they compare?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- satchlj 3y ago[flagged]
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> bar for side effects is much stricter for preventative treatments like vaccines These vaccines are for treatment. They don’t prevent cancer. They treat it. They’re vaccines because they work by arming your immune system versus doing the fighting themselves.
- satchlj 3y ago> The cancer vaccine: Moderna and pharma giant Merck are developing an mRNA-based cancer vaccine, mRNA-4157 (V940), for people who’ve had high-risk melanomas removed.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> for people who’ve had high-risk melanomas removed This is still treatment. They aren’t administering the vaccine to healthy adults. The population is melanoma survivors with a high risk of recurrence.
- shadowgovt 3y agoIsn't this hair splitting on definitions? They are there for vaccinating against future instances of cancer after somebody is in remission from previous instances of cancer. It's not a generally-distributed vaccine, but there are all sorts of vaccines that aren't generally distributed and instead applied only to populations likely to encounter the illness protected against (such as the battery one is exposed to if one travels to particular parts of the world).
- KMag 3y agoThey're treating the traces of cancer that are very likely left behind after the melanoma removal, that are likely to result in recurrence.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Terr_ 3y agoA comparison with rabies vaccine may be useful here. On the scope of the entire human body, the virus usually enters first, before the vaccine is used. However on the scope of individual tissues and cells, the vaccine is often the first on the scene, prepping your cells before the (sneaky, slow) virus makes its main attack.
- throwaway29812 3y agoAll of this is completely based on the individual case.
- dralley 3y agoIf the Rabies virus, or cancer, "beats" the vaccine on a significant scale, then it matters little what it is called because you will probably be dead in short order.
- throwup238 3y agoRabies post-exposure prophylaxis is different because it's made up of several components: human rabies immune globulin (HRIG) and the vaccine. The vaccine takes a while to work so HRIG is the first line of defense that prevents the virus from entering the nervous system until the immune system is able to fight the virus.
- mcmoor 3y agoFrom what I've heard it's still usually "preventative" because we can't confirm that the rabies infection will successfully infect until it's too late. So we vaccine anyone with (very) likely case.
- phpisthebest 3y agoThis further redefinition of the term "vaccine" is a huge problem by definition a vaccine should NOT be a treatment, a vaccine has to be preventative, and further personally I believe only Sterilizing immunity should be considered a "vaccine" This is very important, because a "vaccine" in the US has legal protections other medical drugs, treatments, etc do not get, which is why there is a push to include alot of these things under the definition of "vaccine" so now they get the legal shield
- shibopo 3y agoI mean the general problem is that the word vaccine has been merged with two meanings of "creating something so your immune system gets prepped to prevent disease". Moderna here create something so your immune system gets prepper but it doesn't prevent it's used to fight. I mean this word came from cow, you are right, it's time to redefine some of these terms.
- beowulfey 3y agoThat's not the definition of a vaccine. A vaccine is something that registers our active immune system against an antigen, so that our body detects and eradicates it upon detection. The timing doesn't really matter and there are a lot of therapeutic vaccines [1]. [1] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9729511/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9729511/
- phpisthebest 3y agoIt is now, it has been expanded over the years most recently in response to covid as to include mRNA in the definition of what a vaccine is explicitly to shield these big pharma companies from liability for any harm adverse reactions to mRNA may have to individuals It is shocking to me that soo many people that normally at against large companies, and against even capitalism do not see the huge danger in classifying these things as something that gives the companies creating them an almost complete liability shield from harms caused by their products. Once something is a "vaccine" in the US you lose all ability to sue for most harms caused by said vaccine.
- sbelskie 3y agoThis does not appear to be a preventative treatment. It treats existing melanoma by inducing the body to produce antibodies against it, no?
- satchlj 3y agoIt is intended for people who’ve had high-risk melanomas removed, to prevent cancer from coming back.
- JumpCrisscross 3y agoYou’re both right. It’s preventative, not prophylactic. We’re strict with the latter because they’re administered to healthy adults. That doesn’t apply here. If you took every coronavirus mRNA vaccine side effect and multiplied the severity and frequency by two orders of magnitude, this vaccine would still be worth it for many with melanoma.
- ajb 3y agoThe reason preventative treatments are held to a higher standard is because they are given to a very large number of people who might never get the disease anyway. Hence, a 1 in 1000 risk is significant. If you are treating people who have had cancer, their risk of getting it again in much higher than 1 in 1000.
- Turing_Machine 3y agoRight. There's also the fact that the FDA will accept much worse side effects for a cancer treatment than they would for (e.g.) an athlete's foot treatment. For a bad cancer like some melanomas, just about anything that doesn't kill the patient outright is gonna be on the table.
- kurthr 3y agoIt's also personalized, which to me says that it's unique and each could have different likelihood of autoimmune response. The vaccine works by instructing the body to make up to 34 “neoantigens.” These are proteins found only on the cancer cells, and Moderna personalizes the vaccine for each recipient so that it carries instructions for the neoantigens on their cancer cells.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- throwup238 3y agoMost of them are awful but only in rare cases do they cause permanent damage beyond what is already happening with the cancer and usually the patient can recover after the treatment is stopped. Anything that stimulates the immune system runs the risk of increasing its sensitivity too much till it attacks normal cells and at that point, a lot of horrible things can happen ranging from a new mild allergy to neurological disorders like multiple sclerosis to acute organ failure. Since the point of the therapy is to get immune cells to attack the cancer cells, there's the very real risk of instead targeting the tissue the cancer evolved from.
- bsder 3y ago> Most of them are awful but only in rare cases do they cause permanent damage beyond what is already happening with the cancer That's simply not true. Chemotherapy, in particular, is ridiculously bad. Chemo brain is a thing. Another example, people have to wear cold packs on their hands and feet in order to minimize the neuropathy that some chemotherapies can cause. Other chemotherapies cause your veins to leak with attendant swelling everywhere. Several years after therapy, some of that swelling still persists. Radiation is horrendously bad at damaging intestinal tissue. etc. Yes, it beats being dead. That's about all you can say about it.
- ChrisMarshallNY 3y agoI agree. I have not been through it, myself (crosses self), but I live on Long Island, which means that I have watched a lot of people go through it. Most recover nearly completely, but they all suffer some permanent effects, like sun sensitivity, hair loss, digestive problems, anemia, weakened immune system, etc.
- stjohnswarts 3y agoWhy would living on long island mean you would watch a lot of people go through it? Is there some some kind of cancer hot spot on long island? Genuinely curious.