3 ms·
> not being a general purpose OS. Sony actually took at away that ability in the PS3 so they aren't trying to pretend they do more than play media This is just
by AnthonyMouse 3y ago
> not being a general purpose OS. Sony actually took at away that ability in the PS3 so they aren't trying to pretend they do more than play media
This is just assuming the conclusion. They're general purpose computers that could run arbitrary custom code if their owners weren't locked out of them.
And so are appliances and HVAC systems and so on, which is exactly why the owners shouldn't be locked out of them -- this has significant implications for the entire concept of ownership, right to repair and environmentalism etc. They're all general purpose computers, and they should be.
> the hardware and software is ephemeral. In 10 years IOS and Android will exist. We will likely be on the PS6 and 2 more generations of Nintendo in that time. There's less incentive to bother opening up an OS that is abandoned every generation.
But this is making exactly the opposite argument -- it should be opened up because otherwise it will be abandoned and no one else can support it. Likewise, the newer system should be opened up so people can make it run the older games, or the games from other systems from other vendors, whenever possible.
> due to the model of consoles, most of them lose money on sales so they can invoke more software sales. And on top of that, larger studios get direct support from Nintendo/Sony. There is negative incentive for a studio to ruin this relationship unless more companies start making consoles themselves.
This is called a predatory business model, the equivalent of printer makers selling the printer below cost so they can stick you for the ink. There is a serious argument for banning it outright; it's certainly nothing we need to worry about protecting.
- ksec 3y agoBy that definition every single model that includes software will need to be opened up.
- AnthonyMouse 3y ago> By that definition every single model that includes software will need to be opened up. Sounds good.
- smoldesu 3y agoI agree, good luck convincing the FCC.
- AnthonyMouse 3y agoFCC commissioners are political appointments. If they're reasonable they can be convinced, if they're unreasonable they can be replaced.
- johnnyanmac 3y agoI don't disagree with your arguments, but this story doesn't seem to be about forcing an os nor even store to open up. It's more about the 30% revenue sharing and how these stores can't force studios to submit to it if they are interested in using alternative vendors. That's why Google is involved even if you can technically install a dozen other stores (or sideload everything). This won't really benefit anyone but the largest studios, even if they open it up to game consoles. But it could be a first step. But a step with a lot less support.
- AnthonyMouse 3y agoNobody really cares what one company allows in their store if there is a competitive market for alternate stores with low barriers to entry. Allowing competing stores is a major component of opening up the OS. The competing stores would be able to install and run code on the device, with the permission of the owner rather than the OEM. And suffocating alternatives to paying them the vig is a major reason they close the device to begin with, so without that they'd be less likely to stand in your way anymore.
- johnnyanmac 3y ago>if there is a competitive market for alternate stores with low barriers to entry. But that's what the story is about, even with Google: >And although Google permits third-party app distribution platforms, it still generally requires apps to use its billing system. >These effective monopolies on in-app payments can lead to users paying more for the same content or services on mobile devices than on personal computers. Alternate app stores and Android essentially being an "open OS" (with forced Google installation on many devices) outside the store wasn't enough to protect Google from being involved. And the focus of the rationale is focused on the app purchase and their control over suspected price hikes.