6 ms·
I think they aren't targets due to 1) not being a general purpose OS. Sony actually took at away that ability in the PS3 so they aren't trying to pretend they
by johnnyanmac 3y ago
I think they aren't targets due to
1) not being a general purpose OS. Sony actually took at away that ability in the PS3 so they aren't trying to pretend they do more than play media
2) the hardware and software is ephemeral. In 10 years IOS and Android will exist. We will likely be on the PS6 and 2 more generations of Nintendo in that time. There's less incentive to bother opening up an OS that is abandoned every generation.
3) due to the model of consoles, most of them lose money on sales so they can invoke more software sales. And on top of that, larger studios get direct support from Nintendo/Sony. There is negative incentive for a studio to ruin this relationship unless more companies start making consoles themselves.
- lambda_lord 3y agoYour second point is why the stores need to be opened up. Nintendo breaks compatibility almost every generation, so if you want to replay old games you already purchased on a previous console, you have to repurchase the ported versions or buy Nintendo’s subscription service. I’ve dropped hundreds in the eShop but worry I’ll lose access one day, when the Switch is EOL. In comparison, I’ve been able to run my Steam games on multiple devices through the years because PC is a much more open platform. There are multiple shops, so Steam has incentive to keep games forward compatible.
- filoleg 3y agoThat seems like a very uniquely Nintendo problem rather than a modern console problem. Yeah, PS3 was from the era of consoles where backwards compatibility wasn’t as heavily demanded (given that Steam was in its infancy too), so they went with a notoriously and uniquely overcomplicated making games for it (and, by extension, compatibility). But PS4 era and onwards, any digital purchase you made back then for PS4 is accessible on PS5 as well. And hell, even for PS3 digital purchases it is still kind of true. Unfortunately, PS4/5 cannot play PS3 games natively, but if you purchased a digital PS3 game back then, you are able to stream it using PS Remote Play on your PS4/5. As far as I am aware, a similar thing happened in the Xbox space as well. Xbox One generation and onwards, any digital purchases you made back then are available on the most recent Xbox consoles. And for older games that aren’t natively compatible (and even a bunch of those that are compatible), they provide streaming too (through xCloud). Though don’t quote me on the exact details about how it works for Xbox consoles, as I haven’t used one since the Xbox360 days. Meanwhile, Nintendo resells SNES era games in their “virtual console” section of Switch eShop at a pretty significant premium.
- filoleg 3y agoPast the edit cutoff, so here is an important edit. In the 2nd paragraph, i missed a word and meant to say “[…] they went with a Cell chip, making gamedev experience for it notoriously and uniquely overcomplicated.”
- fomine3 3y ago> PS3 was from the era of consoles where backwards compatibility wasn’t as heavily demanded I don't think so for PlayStaion. PS3 and PS2 had compatibility to older PS by implement old chip. I think why there's no PS3 compatibility is because PS3 unique Cell architecture was dead end.
- filoleg 3y agoYes and no. PS2 was compatible with PS1, but only the first batch of PS3 consoles was compatible with PS2 (as you said, they quite literally just built-in a PS2 chip inside a PS3). After that first initial batch, Sony stopped including the PS2 chip inside a PS3, so PS2 backwards compatibility was pretty much dead. And yeah, the lack of backwards compatibility was almost certainly due to the Cell chip architecture. So yeah, as you pointed out, for Sony it seems like their compatibility goes a bit further into the pre-PS3 era, but for other console makers it wasn't quite the case. Couldn't play original Xbox games on Xbox360 (there is a list of like a dozen games that are backwards compatible, and even then there are issues with some of them like framerate), and neither could you do that with Nintendo/Sega consoles. In that sense, Sony was a bit of an outlier in that they came early to the backwards compatibility game. But these days, 2 out of 3 major console manufacturers pretty much standardized backwards compatibility as a simple "plug and play" feature.
- ksec 3y ago>so if you want to replay old games you already purchased on a previous console, I assume you can turn on your old console and replay those games right? Why does the next generation console has to guarantee to work with older games?
- AnthonyMouse 3y ago> not being a general purpose OS. Sony actually took at away that ability in the PS3 so they aren't trying to pretend they do more than play media This is just assuming the conclusion. They're general purpose computers that could run arbitrary custom code if their owners weren't locked out of them. And so are appliances and HVAC systems and so on, which is exactly why the owners shouldn't be locked out of them -- this has significant implications for the entire concept of ownership, right to repair and environmentalism etc. They're all general purpose computers, and they should be. > the hardware and software is ephemeral. In 10 years IOS and Android will exist. We will likely be on the PS6 and 2 more generations of Nintendo in that time. There's less incentive to bother opening up an OS that is abandoned every generation. But this is making exactly the opposite argument -- it should be opened up because otherwise it will be abandoned and no one else can support it. Likewise, the newer system should be opened up so people can make it run the older games, or the games from other systems from other vendors, whenever possible. > due to the model of consoles, most of them lose money on sales so they can invoke more software sales. And on top of that, larger studios get direct support from Nintendo/Sony. There is negative incentive for a studio to ruin this relationship unless more companies start making consoles themselves. This is called a predatory business model, the equivalent of printer makers selling the printer below cost so they can stick you for the ink. There is a serious argument for banning it outright; it's certainly nothing we need to worry about protecting.
- ksec 3y agoBy that definition every single model that includes software will need to be opened up.
- AnthonyMouse 3y ago> By that definition every single model that includes software will need to be opened up. Sounds good.
- smoldesu 3y agoI agree, good luck convincing the FCC.
- blueboo 3y agoAgreed, mostly, as Id like to point out that the iOS software is abandoned/shut down at approximately the same cadence as new consoles are launched. Rare’s the still-available app that was last updated pre-iOS 10…let alone iOS 5 or pre-retina iOS.
- asylteltine 3y agoThis switch is only useful when it can be hacked. It’s SO much better when you can run whatever you want to run like emulators and other tooling. Or even crazy things, like backing up your saves!
- theshrike79 3y agoI'd posit that modern consoles are MORE general computing devices than mobile phones. For example the Apple M-series SOC only exists in Apple phones and tablets. Meanwhile the PS5, Xbox Series S/X, Steam Deck all use the AMD Zen 2 series CPUs. It's basically off-the shelf hardware with generic well-documented interfaces. The only reason we're not using the Xbox as a cheap Linux gaming machine is because it's absolutely closed up for all hacking.
- fomine3 3y agoAnother discussion: Its hardware is almost a PC, so there's less reason to force it open, because we can just buy a PC.
- theshrike79 3y agoBut it's cheaper to get a console than a PC. That's why the PS2 Linux version was so popular. I can get a Series X for less than the price of a decent GPU. During the GPU price boom I actually got a PS5 _and_ a Series X for less :)
- type0 3y ago> 1) not being a general purpose OS. I don't think iOS and Android are general purpose either. Phones and tablets are used for games as much as the consoles if not more in certain demographic
- johnnyanmac 3y agoI believe they are definitely general purpose. You can browse the web, do professional work in several industries (spreadsheets for business, media editing programs, tax software, etc), play soke fairly intensive games, and track all kinds of parts of your life. And then you can dock all this to a monitor and use a KB&M and treat it like a ultrathin workstation. I'm struggling to think of something you can't do on a phone/tablet these days. Dual monitor support seems to be beyond most devices I tried it with. Maybe some government applications for security purposes.
- Drew_ 3y agoYou can do all of those things on a PS5 or Xbox, Sony and Microsoft just don't let developers publish apps that let you do that.
- SheinhardtWigCo 3y agoNor were those products introduced as a “breakthrough internet communicator”.
- MagicMoonlight 3y agoHow convenient