6 ms·
1 in 2 new college graduates are jobless or underemployed
- nandemo 15y agoJust a few weeks ago: "After grad job slump, big hiring is back at U.S. colleges" http://www.reuters.com/article/2012/04/01/us-economy-hiring-college-idUSBRE83007N20120401 http://www.reuters.com/article/2012/04/01/us-economy-hiring-...
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- YuriNiyazov 15y agoThey should learn Ruby on Rails. * Yea, this sounds like I am being an asshole, but really - the gap between how many developers are needed and how many are available is probably hundreds of thousands.
- sopooneo 15y agoThose that are suited to it, yes. But I learned to program because I couldn't help it. It fit so well with my mind that every second was pleasure. And it got me a great job. But that's just good luck for me. That's the world happening to be aligned with my obsession and aptitude. If the only demand right now was for people that could play a mean game of pick-up basketball, I'd be the one serving latte's. Edit: You are right though. My little cousins that are coming up, even the ones that might not love programming, I am encouraging to learn what they can. Just be able to do the basics and it probably increases your worth as an employee by a large factor.
- astrodust 15y agoWhile programmers in general are in short supply, Rails people are extremely scarce. This is surprising considering the learning curve for this platform is basically a few weeks of intensive training, perhaps even less for those familiar with some other MVC development model. Mobile applications are putting a tremendous strain on the labor pool by demanding not just native developers, but people who can build out back-end APIs to support these applications. Rails is great because it can get your product out the door and expose what kinds of difficulties you'll have scaling it by providing real-world data on how it's used. It's fast to ship and an essential first step.
- guynamedloren 15y agoIs this true? Do you have anything to back this up? Not doubting you, I'm genuinely curious. Perhaps I undervalue my skillset...
- astrodust 15y agoMaybe it varies from market to market, but here (Toronto), there's almost zero in the way of surplus labor. Rails is fairly well established here in the web arena because of the efforts of companies like Unspace that have been active promoters.
- ashayh 15y agoIt is a few weeks for people with novice-to-moderate knowledge of programming, web-dev, javascript and a sprinkling of Unix. Most people without this background are starting from scratch, and if they have no determination, are soon lost.
- patio11 15y agoThey should. They'll also find it helpful to learn what a command line is and how to operate it. Oh, and HTML -- got to know HTML. And Javascript seems to be pretty popular these days... at least enough to operate jQuery. Then there's SQL, because even Rails developers will get their hands dirty at some point. Of course, we wouldn't want to start them with data programming because they've got imperative programming, object oriented programming, and MVC architecture to get on top of first. We'll start with simple syntax that as many as 1/4 of you will understand after a week of classes: "a = 10; b = 5; c = a + b; #What is the value of a now?" After they get through that a quick course in Linux system administration with a refresher on the file system metaphor ("Its like Facebook... actually, no, it is wholly unique to your experience and every person you'll be working with has forgotten that twenty years ago it confused them, too, so expect not-so-good natured ribbing when you ask questions."), and how to use Google, StackOverflow, Github, and a version control system designed by a supergenius who doesn't care what your fingers think about getting bitten. Sweet, that gets us to Hello World. OK, now let's start doing useful work: meet your new friends, the letters A, P, I and the number "countless." Here's the Stripe API, go charge credit cards. Ugh, wait, you set the name value of the credit card text field in your HTML, which results in the credit card number getting written to production.log, thus causing us to fail PCI compliance. Don't you know anything? Seriously: I think young college graduates would be very, very well served by skilling up on things that are commercially valuable rather than the blather that comprises a lot of what passes for education. That said, "just learn Ruby on Rails" perhaps does not appreciate how much of a gap there is between the bottom half of the US college-bound population and an engineer capable of commercially valuable work.
- guynamedloren 15y ago> That said, "just learn Ruby on Rails" perhaps does not appreciate how much of a gap there is between the bottom half of the US college-bound population and an engineer capable of commercially valuable work. I agree. On the other hand, that's a relatively easy gap to fill. A recent example: http://techcrunch.com/2012/04/20/smoopa-state-trooper-ios-development/ http://techcrunch.com/2012/04/20/smoopa-state-trooper-ios-de...
- 15y ago
- hokua 15y agoToo many people confuse a college degree with functional skills. College is a good place to gain functional skills, but in the age of grade inflation, a degree does not imply you've gained any.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- commanda 15y agoI'm not sure why college students aren't told that a degree in anthropology/english/women's studies is not going to give you marketable skills, while a degree in nursing/engineering/computer science will. Perhaps incoming freshmen should be given better guidance?
- hokua 15y agoTotally. In fact, colleges should publish outcome stats -- what percent graduating in degree X got a job in their field within 9 months? And at what median starting salary? Dismal numbers would cause many students to reconsider that Psych degree, or at least realize they are really undertaking a 4 year vacation.
- KaeseEs 15y agoAlmost all schools do publish these exact statistics broken down by major.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- jforman 15y ago"Do what interests you" is very common and very bad advice. I studied social anthropology for a semester because it "interested" me — but only in theory, not in practice. The computer science degree I eventually received has yielded a far more interesting career than what my friends in psychology/philosophy/sociology have experienced, on average.
- commanda 15y agoI declared a double major of dance and creative writing when I entered college. Nobody discouraged me. It was sheer luck that I stumbled across computer science, fell in love, and never looked back. I shudder to think how my life would have turned out if I had stuck with what had originally interested me.
- deleted 15y ago
- ZephyrP 15y agoThis is interesting to me. I'm 20 years old and I'm not in college nor do I plan to finish a degree (and if it wasn't for technology greats like Peter Thiel and PG advice, I might still be making a $100,000 mistake). I'm a fairly normal guy, I've been out of high school for 3 years now and I'm making slightly less than Bureau of Labor Statistic's 2010 Median Income for 'Software Developers', which I believe is more than enough to not be considered underemployed. I see a lot of psychic pain in my peers about how hard work is or the labor market is so difficult, but to be frank the failures I see are directly attributable to plain laziness in a generation addicted to easy and inane pleasure. I'm afraid young people of today are losing the real virtues of life like living with passion and taking responsibility for who you are. The ability to make something out of yourself and feeling joy in life is more alive today than in any other point in human history. I see a lot of active rejection of the ideals of hacker culture, perhaps epitomized by my generation's obsession with video games (which, incidentally, I think could be argued as more detrimental to human wellness than even the most societally hated and destructive addictive stimulants like methamphetamine or cocaine) This is really a shame, as one thing that comes out of hacker culture is a feeling of a real kind of exuberance about your work. Your work is yours to create. I've read the college labor statistics with some interest, even fear. But when I read them, I can't help but think that something essential about our generation and present technological zeitgeist is being left out. As if somehow our work is simply just a confluence of forces far beyond our control, framing college graduates as fragmented or marginalized which opens up a world of excuses. From Chaitin to Stallman, when hackers talk about the meaning of work, they're not talking about abstract decisions, they're talking about doing something that has concrete consequences. It may be true that there are seven billion people on the planet, never the less, your work matters in material terms. In short, I'd encourage any young person my age to not write themselves off as a victim of societal forces. It's always our decision who we are and what we do with our lives.
- guynamedloren 15y ago> As if somehow our work is simply just a confluence of forces far beyond our control... In short, I'd encourage any young person my age to not write themselves off as a victim of societal forces. It's always our decision who we are and what we do with our lives. You are wise. Please write a book for our generation.
- ronaldj 15y agoThe value of college when you enter the job market depends on what you make of it while you are there. Most people can probably finish one way or another, but that doesn't guarantee passion or valuable real world skills. I also believe that the 'name' of your school matters a lot too.
- pbreit 15y agoI don't like headlines like this that conflate two quite different situations (ie, "jobless" and "underemployed"). Ebay used to do the same thing when it would report that x00,000 people sold on Ebay "full time or part time". Kind of a big difference so not that meaningful a stat.
- rsanchez1 15y agoI wonder if this has anything to do with how it seems that every time someone talks about colleges better preparing young people for a career, there is always someone here that responds saying that college is not all about getting a job, but about a "cultural experience". I guess you need something to justify the expense now.
- invalidOrTaken 15y agoAbsolutely. This phrase is a distortion of the "liberal education" (that included calculus, biology, chemistry, and physics) provided by universities of the past. From what I can tell, universities used to have a much smaller student/professor ratio, and had a bit more "disciple" in the study of a particular discipline. Presumably that ended with the G.I. bill, but no one particularly minded because factory jobs were plentiful. So when baby boomers of yesteryear look back at their college experience, and try and figure out what they got out of it, can they point to stellar education that they use every day? If they majored in Communications, probably not. Do their jobs require collegiate-level knowledge or skills? If they're in marketing or sales, probably not. So they remember that they smoked their first joint there, and met that one foreign kid from Uzbekistan, and throw in the first awakenings of independent thought that come from living on one's lonesome for the first time, and call it a "cultural experience of self-discovery." I malign communications and the so-called liberal arts a bit, but that's not completely deserved. If done right, they actually seem about on par with mathematics in terms of usefulness---abstract and useless at first, but a fantastic base for further study, providing that that further study occurs.
- majelix 15y ago> If they majored in Communications, probably not. Do their jobs require collegiate-level knowledge or skills? How many dev jobs do you think require, say, integrals or compiler design?
- magicalist 15y agoThis seems like the most important line in the story: "About 1.5 million, or 53.6 percent, of bachelor's degree-holders under the age of 25 last year were jobless or underemployed, the highest share in at least 11 years. In 2000, the share was at a low of 41 percent, before the dot-com bust erased job gains for college graduates in the telecommunications and IT fields." Headline in 2000: "Even with incredible economic performance, nearly 1 in 2 new graduates are jobless or underemployed" Not to get in the way of the AP's narrative and everyone's self-congratulations for picking a profitable major.
- rgc4 15y ago1 in 2 new college graduates are idiots.
- moocow01 15y ago"Learn to program" is probably going to be a repeated answer here but I'm not so sure this attitude is going to be doing any good. Enticing people into technical professions that do not have the inclination is not going to make things much better - instead your going to end up with a significant band of people disinterested in their work. We all know how much "negative" work can be done by bad apples in software. The problem is that everyone has natural competencies, personalities and cognitive methods and only a relatively small sliver have the type that will fit software development. If you think I'm saying were special, I am not. Every discipline has a relatively small sliver of people who will be naturally inclined to do it and enjoy it. The real problem is us... meaning society. We currently aren't culturally organized in a manner to take advantage of everyone's abilities and part of the main reasoning I'd say is a lack of diversity in terms of what is appreciated and rewarded. From my limited perspective our culture seems to have a maniacal focus on money and a growing monoculture that is focused on how to become a millionaire at whatever cost. Right now software development seems to be a good way to get rich partly due to our monoculture's love of video games, apps, business processes etc. so our industry gets green lit for now so to say. The problem is that there is a lot of important stuff to us humans all living a better life that the majority falsely considers unimportant and lowly for the most part because of its current low correlation to the almighty profit ... things like culture, art, anthropology, farming, geology, architecture, care-taking, etc etc The sad thing is that we have swaths of people with great skills and inclinations that should be going into these different segments but essentially can't because we collectively don't appreciate people doing these things. In other words if you ask me our real jobs problem is that we don't have diverse enough "consumers" who appreciate the interesting niches different humans fill.
- RandallBrown 15y agoA bachelors degree is NOT (and should not be) a guarantee you will get a job. Yes, 30 years ago, a bachelors almost guaranteed you a job. That's because nobody else had one. That's not really the case any more. More and more people are going to college. Students know their psych degree is worthless when they graduate. They know it 2 years before they actually do graduate. They didn't go to college to become something, they went to college just because that's what people do now. The people I know from high school that are successful now went to school to become something (doctors, lawyers, software developers, photographers). The ones that are waiters and waitresses just went to college and took classes.
- gexla 15y agoI love this. The U.S. is a leader at everything. I live in the Philippines and everyone is crazy about getting cars. People in the U.S. now hate their cars. Countries such as China and India are churning out gobs of college graduates while people in the U.S. are beginning to question the value of a college education. Anyone who sends out 4 resumes a day is obviously doing something wrong. As a web developer, I probably couldn't expect to land anything if I were to apply for 4 gigs every day. The problem with learning marketable skills in college is that apparently college students aren't learning how to market. Get yourself out there, talk to people, network, make friends, build things! All these activities increase your surface luck area. Sending out resumes is doesn't really help with any of the above, though it probably doesn't hurt to send one out every once in a while if you are more targeted with it than sending out 4 a day.
- Quizzy 15y agoI'd like to throw in the practicalities of survival income that many college applicants fail to appreciate because they are so used to living off their parents' dole. The following are steps that young people ignore until it's too late: 1. Before living your dream or doing "something you love", you have to make your survival income: the first $1500 for food, shelter, transportation. So where does this steady $1500 come from, and is working the necessary hours to make $1500 going to leave you with enough time to invest in that "dream"? 2. So before graduation, have you established your fall back $1500 contingency plan? Do you have a skill (vocational or otherwise) that you KNOW will bring you that monthly $1500? Step TWO is where I believe high school counseling has failed America's youth. Everybody should leave high school with a $1500 skill, whether that be bookeeping, welding, sales, waiting tables, cashier, etc. It is imperative that upon graduating high school, you are able to count on having survival wage skills. 3. Does your college major allow you to skip step two because it is in such demand that the employment rate for your industry is healthy? Back in the early 90's, CS graduates were not having an easy time and were considered the bottom of the totem pole among engineering majors (in my school they weren't even considered engineers, but rather a soft science more akin to biology, insultingly enough). Again, this is the fault of high school counselors who fail to make foresight an essential part of the planning process - this whole "major in what you love" crap just leaves graduates with a sense of disappointment when they are unemployable. Always temper "major in what you love" with the caveat "as long as you already have a skill to pay for food/shelter/travel". 4. What's your exit strategy from your survival job? Plan this every day as you're waiting tables (bartending, welding, dancing,...). 4. Knowing that high schools (both public and private) are too highbrow to ever consider vocational training for their top students, it's up to parents to fully prepare their children. When my son is old enough, his summers will be spent honing a vocational skill so that he will have an employable skill that any society will find useful such that if he wishes to travel the world, he can always pick up a local job should the circumstances demand it. Two come to mind: welding (easier and ubiquitously needed) or electrician (harder, but more lucrative). This long rant is a part of my disatisfaction with the high school paradigm as currently constituted. The current paradigm is a crapshoot that ill prepares students for the rigors and realities of survival in a world that could care less if they were once a valedictorian or All-State track star. I have known many former high school heroes turned zeroes after college, and it's a fall from grace that their parents have never ever prepared them for because in their world, their kids will always be special.