2 ms·
But the GPL isn't really that long; the 2.0 is only 340 lines of 80 characters. Is that all?! Out of curiosity, what proportion of people who choose to licenc
by Silhouette 15y ago
But the GPL isn't really that long; the 2.0 is only 340 lines of 80 characters.
Is that all?!
Out of curiosity, what proportion of people who choose to licence their own code under the GPL do you think have actually read all of that and consulted a lawyer to make sure they understood the terms they were themselves proposing? I'm not even considering the equivalent question for the wider population of users and downstream developers affected by the licence terms yet.
"Freeware" doesn't include the right to modify and re-distribute. Yes, we were certainly worse off for it.
In what way? We didn't worry about offering others formal rights in those days. People shared source code if they thought they had something worth sharing, without making a big deal about it. Such code frequenty came with comments to the effect that you could use it however you liked but please give credit, or words to that general effect, which would have just as much validity in court as a modern MIT or BSD licence for example.
The differences between the three versions [GPL, LGPL, AGPL] are minimal - a clause or two more, nothing else.
Wow. That's a mighty bold claim, and one I don't think a lot of software developers would agree with. The changes in wording may only be a small part of a vast document, but the implications are profound.
It seems irrelevant 'till you get hit by a patent troll, like startups are already getting hit.
The correct solution to patent trolls is not to allow things like software patents in the first place. It's a controversial subject and there is far from consensus internationally or even within some national governments on whether software should be patentable at all.
In any case, I think you are imagining a legal shield that is not there. Patent trolls typically don't contribute to a FOSS project and then go after other people who use it. In fact, patent trolls typically don't contribute much of anything to any project, which is one of the reasons they are... not well thought of. If you're using someone else's code and you don't have some solid legal agreement that they indemnify you fully against all the related IP threats, you're not safe, and no FOSS licence provides such indemnification; many explicitly state precisely the opposite.
For that matter, you don't have any real protection in a troll-friendly legal system even if you never use anyone else's code at all and you write every line yourself. I don't think there's much argument in favour of GPL-esque legalese to be found here. My personal view is that some of the GPLv3 stuff is basically the FSF trying to conflate two unrelated IP issues and leverage the viral nature of the GPL to advance other parts of their agenda. Which is a pretty scummy thing to do, actually.
- icebraining 15y agoOut of curiosity, what proportion of people who choose to licence their own code under the GPL do you think have actually read all of that and consulted a lawyer to make sure they understood the terms they were themselves proposing? Not many, but I'd guess they didn't read MIT nor BSD either. By the way, the original BSD licenses forced you to acknowledge the upstream project in any advertising materials for yours. How many people read that? Not many, I would guess. In what way? We didn't worry about offering others formal rights in those days. People shared source code if they thought they had something worth sharing, without making a big deal about it. As I said, that's fine in a community of hobbyists, not if we want businesses contributing. But that's a different issue. which would have just as much validity in court as a modern MIT or BSD licence for example. Do you have any example of a lawsuit where such freeform license was valid? Besides, even if it was, I doubt people had enough trust in that to release commercial stuff based on it. Wow. That's a mighty bold claim, and one I don't think a lot of software developers would agree with. The changes in wording may only be a small part of a vast document, but the implications are profound. I was talking about the license text, not the implications. The correct solution to patent trolls is not to allow things like software patents in the first place. It's a controversial subject and there is far from consensus internationally or even within some national governments on whether software should be patentable at all. I'm sure the FSF would've ended software patents if they could, but it's hardly fair to criticize them for not doing so. They did what they could: route around them. I would think the patent grant protects in the case the upstream developer sells those patents to a troll after you're already using the code, but I'm certainly not sure. My personal view is that some of the GPLv3 stuff is basically the FSF trying to conflate two unrelated IP issues and leverage the viral nature of the GPL to advance other parts of their agenda. Which is a pretty scummy thing to do, actually. This talk about the GPL being "viral" is just FUD. If the GPL "infected" your project if because you made the voluntary decision of including GPL-licensed code in it. And why is it scummy? They provide a tool (the GPL) to whoever wants to use it. Advancing the Free Software Movement is obviously one of the goals of the tool, like mostly anything the FSF does.