4 ms·
>> Most people with kids and mortgages get by on less than 150k. > Not in sf or nyc. It's still trivially true that most people in SF and NYC, including marri
by _delirium 15y ago
>> Most people with kids and mortgages get by on less than 150k.
> Not in sf or nyc.
It's still trivially true that most people in SF and NYC, including married adults with families, get by on way less than $150k. Even Upper-East-Side Manhattan, one of the wealthiest zip codes in the U.S., has average incomes "only" in the high 5 figures. Maybe there is a small section of Nob Hill where $150k incomes are normal, but even in most nice parts of SF that's not a typical family's income.
Part of the reason is that in areas where housing is the major cost, the 40x-your-housing-cost rule of thumb is too conservative, and would lead to a conclusion that almost nobody can actually live in the city, whereas clearly many people do. And anyway I believe the usual mortgage-company rules of thumb are 30% of your gross income on the mortgage payment itself, but up to 40% on mortgage+insurance+etc. So that'd lead to $120k in your hypothetical.
- vaksel 15y agoNYC is a bad example, the real estate costs really sky rocketed over the past 25 years or so...so it's very possible that someone could have gotten one of those buildings on a $40K/yr teacher's salary. Good luck doing that in this day and age
- larrys 15y agoAs a matter of fact I dated such a person (UES of NYC). Her salary was, IIRC, actually about $80's. She was divorced with one child. They had a 1 bedroom and shared the same bed. And she wouldn't have been able to afford that without family help.
- larrys 15y ago"Even Upper-East-Side Manhattan, one of the wealthiest zip codes in the U.S., has average incomes "only" in the high 5 figures." I'm not sure that you can look at simply average income without knowing whether the people are single, cohabitating and if they have children and how many. Also average income I would imagine doesn't take into account healthcare costs which can run thousands. One person may be covered, another not covered, another on medicare etc. Some may have child support to pay. Saying that someone can get by on "less than 150k" is like saying that someone can build an ecommerce website for $X.
- michaelochurch 15y agoEven Upper-East-Side Manhattan, one of the wealthiest zip codes in the U.S., has average incomes "only" in the high 5 figures. East of Lexington, the UES is upper-middle-income yuppies. Apartments are affordable but very small: like 400 SF for $2,000 per month. Not an option if you have kids. Also, if UES is defined from 59th to 110th street, that includes areas in the north that are low-income and more like Harlem than UES. The change is quite stark.
- bearmf 15y agoIt is possible to live with a baby in 1br apartment, a lot of people do it in Manhattan. The real problems start later, with preschools, kindergartens etc.
- michaelochurch 15y agoThat preschool shit does sound terrifying. My question is: why? Are NYC public schools really that bad? (I have no idea, but I thought there were some good districts.) Or is the insanity just a product of it being hard to get them into top colleges coming from New York and not being prep? Because there's a solution, which is to have them move to Montana during their senior year.
- bearmf 15y agoThere are no public preschools in New York for middle class. The private ones are very expensive and competitive to get into. AFAIK, there are good public elementary schools. Middle and high schools are much worse if you don't get into a Gifted & Talented program.