8 ms·
Time for a return of the Cypherpunks, Crypto-Anarchists & Techno-Libertarians?
- m0nastic 15y agoBy contrast, I've noticed the exact opposite phenomenon that the OP describes (mainly, that over the past year or so, neo-cypherpunks have started coming out of the woodwork to prosthelitize things like bitcoin, and terrible in-browser Javascript crypto). I suppose we all see what we want to see. I do wish that there existed a forum for some of the discussions that used to actually happen on the cypherpunks list (even though it would frequently derail into arguments about assasination markets, and paranoid conspiracy theories).
- unimpressive 15y ago>terrible in-browser Javascript crypto I'm not a cryptographer by any means, but my first thought when reading that is can we make non-terrible in-browser javascript crypto?
- Aethaeryn 15y agoOne of the top Google results for "javascript cryptography" thoroughly attacks the concept, but I'm not an expert in the area so I can't refute or confirm its claims: http://www.matasano.com/articles/javascript-cryptography/ http://www.matasano.com/articles/javascript-cryptography/
- tkahn6 15y agoThis is tptacek's company.
- pgeorgi 15y agoThe main issue is the trust base. Allow the entire code base of a site to be pinned down to a cert (and that has to be done outside the website context, ie. in-browser), and you're halfway there. Say, a signed webapp manifest, listing all files that are supposed to be used in that context and their hashes. On first execution, the associated key is stored, maybe compared with third party knowledge about the site (not tampered with) and key (known not-trustworthy). After that, you know when someone else than the maintainer tampered with the code. With that you're down to trusting the maintainer. Which makes it as good as any other code distribution scheme.
- oconnore 15y agoIt's not a problem with javascript so much as a problem with the issue of knowing what code is actually running in your browser.
- m0nastic 15y agoThe short answer is "no, we can't" which every time someone proposes a new scheme seems to infuriate people (as though our inability to actually do it is a value judgement on whether or not it's a good idea).
- Estragon 15y agoActually, I think in some limited circumstances, JS crypto could be useful for a kind of "separation of trust." For instance, I am considering a service at the moment which would involve people uploading confidential information. The uploads will be fairly large, so a lot of bandwidth will be required (optimistically assuming it gets traction.) One architecture I am considering is a small dedicated HTTPS server which provides a self-contained webpage-plus-JS program to encrypt the upload and send it for storage on Amazon S3. Then I will pull the results off Amazon and decrypt them on a machine which is not even connected to the network. The advantage to this architecture is that it will scale arbitrarily but require me to secure only relatively modest dedicated resources, despite being used for transmission of confidential information. Because it uses a dedicated HTTPS server serving a self-contained page doing all the crypto, it avoids tptacek's objections to JS crypto in the browser (E.g., the server can provide the random seed in the JS itself, HTTPS prevents MITM attacks, etc.) (Copied from http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3872007 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3872007)
- m0nastic 15y agoSo, you're scheme would require the long answer... ;) Which is that it sounds rather complicated (which makes my security-sense go off, but certainly isn't a fatal indictment) and that I'd really need to either do an active evaluation of the system or get several reassurrances that someone else decent (ideally someone much smarter than me) did and it checked out before I'd be remotely comfortable using it or recommending it.
- Estragon 15y agoThat's fair enough. I was just pointing out that not every architecture involving in-browser JS crypto suffers from the problems tptacek detailed.
- mindcrime 15y agomainly, that over the past year or so, neo-cypherpunks have started coming out of the woodwork to prosthelitize things like bitcoin, OK, fair point about bitcoin. But other than that, I really feel like the cypherpunk types have been fairly invisible lately. Maybe it's just that there was a certain period of time, back in the /. heyday, when discussions of cryptography, surveillance, data-havens, etc. were at a peak, and now they've leveled off. But in any case, I would argue that we (still) need an active and efficient cypherpunk community to promote technological freedom.
- m0nastic 15y agoI think what's changed is that the discussions during the heyday were around the technology, which at the time was the limiting factor. The technology isn't really the issue anymore (with some specific exceptions). The problem with crypto-currency isn't the "crypto", it's the "currency". I think that same phenomena is the culprit for most "cyperpunk-related" discussions. 10 years ago I'd have said that I was really hoping for the "Star Trek" future, but that if I was forced to bet, I'd bet on a "BladeRunner" future being way more likely. Now I'm old, and I think if I was forced to bet, "Brazil" is a more likely model (the movie, not the country). But I don't want to sound like I'm dismissing the value of a healthy "cypherpunk" community. I think you can look at a lot of things that came out of the original community and see value there.
- mindcrime 15y agoNow I'm old, and I think if I was forced to bet, "Brazil" is a more likely model (the movie, not the country). I'm afraid you may be right. But I still hold out some hope that we can do better than that.
- personlurking 15y agoHere's a link to a list, by year, of how the future is portrayed in films. I'm not sure if it's listed in the infographic, but the film 'Code 46' (Tim Robbins) tells an intriguing story of where I see things heading. http://img197.imageshack.us/img197/3199/inforn.jpg http://img197.imageshack.us/img197/3199/inforn.jpg Another image I can't locate showed how we used to see the future, from a 1980's standpoint (think: Jetsons), and how we see it today (think: "The Road", "Book of Eli" or "I am Legend").
- ephermata 15y agoStart a mailing list, start recruiting people to post...who knows, maybe you'll set up the new place?
- mindcrime 15y agoCount me in. My initial focus is going to be on the RTP area, and trying to get a meatspace meetup going, that caters to folks of this mindset. But if a new hub for cypherpunk (and related) thought emerged online, I'd definitely join in.
- DanBC 15y ago> I do wish that there existed a forum for some of the discussions that used to actually happen on the cypherpunks list You may find some interested people in UK Crypto (but obviously I'm not suggestion you spam their list). (http://www.chiark.greenend.org.uk/mailman/listinfo/ukcrypto http://www.chiark.greenend.org.uk/mailman/listinfo/ukcrypto) > This group is comprised of people with a professional interest in the formulation and content of UK government policy on the provision, use and control of encryption products and services in the UK. It was formed in response to the 1996 announcement of UK policy on the provision of encryption services on telecommunications networks. > The mailing list is unmoderated, but only subscribed members can post. Please try and restrict postings to UK Encryption law and try not to stray onto general cryptology topics.
- apembroke 15y ago> I do wish that there existed a forum for some of the discussions that used to actually happen on the cypherpunks list check out the bitcoin forums. Honestly, I think the op has been hiding under a rock for the past couple years. Bitcoin and tor are great examples, but there are plenty of other disruptive projects out there, like loom, open-transactions, ripple. Crypto-anarchists didn't go away, they got to work creating practical applications that can change people's lives, and not just for the geeks.
- dredmorbius 15y agoWhat's your gripe on in-browser JS crypto? Is it worse than nothing, or just bad? What alternatives would you suggest?
- m0nastic 15y agoMy gripe is the same as the overwhelming majority of people in my industry: that given unlimited resources, in your wildest dreams you couldn't imagine a less hospitable place for cryptographic integrity than the DOM. Some people are of the opinion that the usefulness of being able to do crypto in people's browsers outweighs exactly how inhospitable it is. I don't share this opinion. In most circumstances, something bad might be preferable to nothing at all. I think crypto is one of the rare exceptions where "bad" is actually worse than none. My alternative suggestions are conservative: PGP and TLS These suggestions aren't particularly exciting, however, so people keep looking for other, newer, ones. I'm actually in the small minority of security people who don't think it's feasible to discourage people from trying to muck around with crypto. It's like sitting a kid in front of a television,handing them a video game controller, and then telling them not to play video games. Crypto is an attractive nuisance. It also seems like it answers a lot of our problems (it actually answers far less than we think, and just creates new ones in their place), so people naturally are inclined to experiment with it. So I hope someday to be wrong about crypto in the browser, because it'd be great. But right now, it's sort of like trying to fancy up a glory hole.
- dredmorbius 15y agoI'll admit that browser-based scripting isn't high on my list of secure environments either. It does, however, do a nice job of getting around the fundamental problem of finding some environment that's reliably and consistently available. It also nicely end-runs the problem of trusting a remote site to hold your data in confidence. There's the remaining problem of key management, though for many people, browser-based password managers are a reasonable mechanism. PGP/GPG and TLS still provide key management issues (with several notable registrar incidents in the past year). And even if you're, say, parking a public key on a site to autoencrypt material sent there (assuming it's not encrypted prior to upload), there's the question of how you're going to interact with encrypted data on that site. I see three basic options: server-side encrypt/decrypt, browser-based, or client-side non-browser utilities. In the latter case, you now have a wide range of environments (Windows variants, Mac, Linux, etc.) to support. Not saying it can't happen, but good crypto is hard. Even the pros (PGP) ended up using a server-based solution which had both public and private keys on it as their solution to the key-management problem.
- zdw 15y agoAs long as they stick to distribution and advocacy rather than creating new tech, I'm all for this. Crypto is very hard to do right - one example from last year: http://www.daemonology.net/blog/2011-01-18-tarsnap-critical-security-bug.html http://www.daemonology.net/blog/2011-01-18-tarsnap-critical-...
- mindcrime 15y agoCrypto is very hard to do right Very true. And simply raising awareness of that point itself, is a valuable thing. That said, there are (or were) actual skilled professionals, with the knowledge to create new crypto schemes, etc. in the cypherpunk community. But clearly not everyone falls into that bucket.
- noonespecial 15y agoNot only is it hard to do right, it seems like its often even hard to take crypto that's done right and use it right.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- thechut 15y agoMaybe these people feel it's no longer safe for them to be so vocal about it. Maybe even for the exact reasons you are mentioning they should be angered by.
- mindcrime 15y agoMaybe these people feel it's no longer safe for them to be so vocal about it. Could be. And that's a pretty sad thought, given that we (those of us in the USA anyway) live in a country where "free speech" has traditionally been one of the most fundamental and cherished principles.
- unimpressive 15y agoDing! Ding! Ding! I think we have a winner. It's a self reinforcing effect too. The less people that speak out the less people that speak out because nobody else is.
- mindcrime 15y agoYes, that's part of the reason for this blog post, and why I posted it here to HN. Sometimes you need somebody to stir the pot a little and try to stimulate the conversation.
- m0nastic 15y agoI don't think that fear is really the culprit here. People on the internet don't seem to have trouble speaking out about all sorts of other things. I think the issues which are fundamental to the cypherpunk ethos (if such a thing can be said to exist‡) just aren't things most people care about. And you can totally make a valid argument that this will pretty much ensure that the worst-case scenario is the one that will come to pass (if you are so inclined). But I don't get the impression that there's this large contingent of people who are actually interested in this who aren't participating because they're worried. I'd love to be wrong though, as that would mean that there could be a much more lively and productive community to swell up. ‡ although this is as good a stab at it as any: http://www.cypherpunks.to/faq/cyphernomicron/cyphernomicon.txt http://www.cypherpunks.to/faq/cyphernomicron/cyphernomicon.t...
- antihero 15y agoI see the issue as being that secure tools, such as GnuPGP, are still way too complicated and confusing for the average activist to use, thus people don't bother and use low-tech solutions to communicate for day-to-day protesting. If someone is organising something big and scary, they'd learn to use PGP and use it.
- mindcrime 15y agoI see the issue as being that secure tools, such as GnuPGP, are still way too complicated and confusing for the average activist to use Yes, I think that is very true. That's why I think two of the goals of a modern cypherpunk movement should be to: A. educate people on how to use encryption and related tools, and B. work on making tools that are simpler to use / easier to understand in the first place.
- ef4 15y agoThe advent of social networking can actually help make this stuff easier for normal people. The hardest part is managing a web of trust. If you can automate building your web of trust on top of existing social network connections, you can get strong crypto that's easy to use.
- javert 15y agoThere are just too many competing voices. For example, the "techno-libertarian" types have to "compete" with the voices of the net neutraily crowd, as well as the pro-piracy crowd. Unfortunately, all three camps use the same terminology to express totally different view and ideas. I don't care to spend time advocating techno-libertarian positions (that I agree with), just to see a larger mass of piracy people [mis] using the same words (e.g. freedom, rights, etc.) to try to justify a position that I personally find abhorrent.
- andrewcooke 15y agowhy compete? i saw the guy was a libertarian (and, perhaps worse, some kind of smelly metal head), which is not my scene at all, but i still emailed him to be added to any kind of list because i think privacy is important. if the list ends up being for "crypto to avoid paying taxes so the poor die as darwin wanted" then sure, i wouldn't join. but i think there's a clear need for a unified voice on crypto and online rights. worse, i think you are doing this a disservice, in that you're implying that these rights are only important for your group of people. these rights are important for all of us. even metal-head libertarians. incidentally, i would also encourage people to donate to eff - almost all the free gifts they give you for donating are horrible, but the hat pin is actually really nice. so go buy a $100 dollar hat pin and help spread some good.
- mindcrime 15y agoif the list ends up being for "crypto to avoid paying taxes so the poor die as darwin wanted" then sure, i wouldn't join. but i think there's a clear need for a unified voice on crypto and online rights. The thing about privacy is, you don't know what end it does serve. I personally am a Libertarian (and a metal-head, yes, although I'm getting too old for a lot of moshing and shit), but I certainly advocate for privacy rights independently of any other Libertarian position. If I'm using crypto to discuss my beliefs about ending tax-payer subsidized entitlement programs, others may simultaneously be using it to discuss their desire to raise taxes, end all private property and redistribute wealth "to each according to his need." but i think there's a clear need for a unified voice on crypto and online rights. Yes, this is one area where Libertarians and most left-leaning types can find some common ground.
- stretchwithme 15y agoMaybe they are all exposing their private data to Facebook. https://www.facebook.com/groups/technolibertarians/ https://www.facebook.com/groups/technolibertarians/
- overshard 15y agoIt's impossible to provide good tools for your average user without getting some government actively working to destroy it. There are already great tools for experienced users but I can't for the life of me figure out how to get my friends to send email using PGP even if I install it and set it up for them. They seem confused by the whole concept.
- _delirium 15y agoI think there's a bit more focus on networks than on cryptography lately among freelance activist type people. But if you include that, there is still substantial activity. Tor is going fairly strongly, Retroshare has recently gotten a big uptake in publicity, and some other darknet projects have been floated. The focus seems to be on hard-to-disrupt connectivity, with some indirect association with groups like Wikileaks who aim at using that connectivity to promote state/corporate transparency (which is actually pretty close to an old-school "information wants to be free!" agenda). In Europe, there's also been a rise in "Pirate Parties", which despite their name are more generally interested in techno-freedom issues, not purely copyright-infringement issues.
- nirvana 15y agoThis is the inevitable result of social news sites. Most people are not libertarian, and so they down vote comments that don't fit their ideology. On Reddit in many subreddits (including the politics one everyone is subscribed to by default) they practice outright censorship. Here on HN the down vote seems to be deployed for disagreement, even against well written comments that include substantiation. Fortunately, Libertarianism is far more mainstream now, even if the Ron Paul movement has managed to dilute it to some extent.
- gavanwoolery 15y agoGreat comment. Unfortunately, Libertarians get too closely associated with Republicans, because the sad truth is that many people do not even know what Libertarians stand for. I have always said that in the simplest terms, Libertarians are really just interested in freedom - social freedom (like Democrats) and financial freedom (like Republicans).
- mindcruzer 15y agoThis reminds me of a quote: "Democrats want the government to be their mother; republicans want the government to be their father. Libertarians just want to be treated like adults."
- EGreg 15y agofrom what I see, libertarians can be ones who blame their mother and father for their troubles :) but in all seriousness, I think out of the three, libertarianism is the only one that claims to be borne out of stable and unchanging "priciples" regarding individual freedom. By doing this, libertarians often invite criticism because of the bold claim that their position is based on principles, which implies it can withstand -- indeed would welcome -- being taken to its logical extreme. But the extreme is pretty much anarchy and is easy to criticize, considering that all developed countries HAVE governments -- typically in some form of republic. Collective action problems such as pollution of a commons or driving on a highway require some enforcement. And thus libertarians, by touting "principles", invite argument about extreme implementations of those principles. When in reality, many people who lean libertarian are probably looking at the other side of the bell curve where there are diminishing returns from regulation. That said, I want to emphasize that distributed systems on the internet do work better than centralized systems -- and I am passionate about that, so in some sense I am a libertarian myself! But internet servers typically coexist peacefully and thus do not require centralized enforcement of laws to protect them from each other.
- StephenFalken 15y agoFor those that haven't yet had the chance of reading a foundational text related to Cypherpunks and Crypto-Anarchy, there is "The Crypto Anarchist Manifesto" by Tim May (back then a Chief Scientist at Intel) -> http://www.activism.net/cypherpunk/crypto-anarchy.html http://www.activism.net/cypherpunk/crypto-anarchy.html
- pnathan 15y agoI see the core ideas being diluted into Wikileaks, Anonymous, etc. Those are bad representations of the core ideas. There are not many people who can lucidly translate the understanding of technology's issues into the language of non-techies. It's not sufficient to be technically correct: it's required that the presentation works as well. Techies seem to have allergies to other cultures that don't have similar value systems and have largely failed in translating our concerns to the broader world. The old word 'luser' adequately explains our shortcoming.
- sneak 15y agoDiluted? They're the same people.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- sneak 15y agoThe underground is still out there. It's just underground. Get in touch if you'd like to be invited.
- srconstantin 15y agoI'm skeptical. All of the articles cited are indeed about civil liberties, but I don't see them as being problems that can necessarily be improved by developing better cryptography. The social network propaganda isn't so much of a technological problem as a social one -- people assume that everyone's using social networks in a straightforward way, to express themselves and connect with friends, even though they have the capacity to be used in many other ways, including deceptively. The NSA email-hoarding thing is also a social problem -- encryption exists, it's just that nobody uses it. The "pre-crime screening" appears to be a statistical model. I don't yet know if there's a science of counter-machine-learning -- that is, creating examples that are hard for models to classify, analogously to making harder and harder CAPTCHAs. If government gets better at data science, what civil libertarians will need is not better encriptions, but different techniques designed to protect against statistical intrusions. Likewise, I don't think better crypto is in any straightforward way a protection against biometrics or government bills to take down certain websites. If he's saying "we need more libertarians and people concerned about civil liberties," then he's right. But I'm not even sure there are fewer than there used to be (look at the backlash to SOPA). I just suspect think there was a time when people had more hope in purely technological fixes to government abuses. I know some old-time crypto-anarchists, and they're largely disappointed with how things have turned out. In the end, preventing the abuse of government power is a hard problem, and it looks less likely that a small set of tech breakthroughs will suddenly make civil liberties violations obsolete.
- cabalamat 15y ago> all of the Cypherpunks, Crypto-Anarchists and techno-libertarians seem to have gone into hiding, or disappeared. Maybe they joined the Pirate Party?
- drstrangevibes 15y agomaybe they are just keeping their communication private by using encryption.
- rdl 15y agoTo be honest, more crypto got shipped outside the cypherpunks than within. PGP (of debatable utility now) and otr (the chat encryption) are the main useful systems produced by cypherpunkdom (mixmaster and tor (sort of) too); SSL, Start TLS, IPsec, ssh, ... came from outside. I'd rather see security and cryptography packaged so it can be widely used by normal app developers, vs. relying on privacy/security aficionados to do everything.
- JoachimSchipper 15y agoSSL, IPsec and the like are for banks, PGP / otr / mixmaster / tor are for dissidents and paranoids. I don't think these are equivalent. (Of course, SSL is very useful.)
- gbog 15y agoI don't read Slashdot or Reddit but on HN I have felt a slow drift from core technology topics towards design and UI. The Applemania is one of the culprit here, I believe.
- SoftwareMaven 15y agoI am lucky in that 1) my company is really trying to come up with a solution to allow individuals to easily keep their privacy and 2) our funders are strong libertarians who want to see this succeed more than they want an instant return. It's a difficult place to build a business, and impatient investors would make it impossible.
- EGreg 15y agoAny chance we can get in touch? My company's building something along similar lines, that will help improve privacy all over the web. And it has taken us two years to build the foundation, piece by piece. Contact me at http://qbix.com/about http://qbix.com/about
- noarchy 15y agoI hope you succeed in what you are setting out to do, if your goal is to truly protect privacy. I have to admit, though, that I am highly skeptical if the solution turns out to be closed, and proprietary. It is a huge risk to place one's security in the hands of something that is a black box.
- SoftwareMaven 15y agoThank you. I think about this a lot because I totally agree with you. I'm continually asking what it would take for me to trust me. One thing I know is we can't reach the end straight from the beginning, so we are going to move incrementally. Eventually, everything has to be open. I wouldn't trust a company with 100% of my data that wasn't. However, there is 10% I would trust with a company like mine today, assuming I got benefits in other areas, and that's where we are starting.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- chris123 15y agoOn the margin, there are some people (Brill) who are self-censoring to avoid/minimize the attention of the ever-growing police state. The hardest core "Welcome to the United States of Orwell, Part 3: We had to Destroy Democracy in Order to Save It": http://goo.gl/s7u6T http://goo.gl/s7u6T
- DrWhax 15y agoI think you are looking in the wrong direction, but things have changed over the years as well. This group of people might not be well organised anymore in terms of a mailinglist. But projects like the Torproject, EFF and pirate parties are doing better then ever. They got more organised and decentralised. A few good references: https://www.calyxinstitute.org/ https://www.calyxinstitute.org/ and https://crypto.is/ https://crypto.is/ | threatpost.com/en_us/blogs/behind-scenes-crypto-project-083011 We are rebuilding crypto.is and moving the site to other servers, we'll be back soon, you can find us at irc.oftc.net #cryptodotis