3 ms·
Intelligence is expensive[1], and there may be some sort of threshold effect. Let's ignore the last few centuries of Revolutions, and look at the longer scale.
by gwern 15y ago
Intelligence is expensive[1], and there may be some sort of threshold effect. Let's ignore the last few centuries of Revolutions, and look at the longer scale. Humanity is recognizable back to 200k years or so; civilization in any sense goes back maybe 5k years. How successful was humanity's intelligence during those 195k years? Not very: humanity spread slowly, did not represent a huge population, and suffered many reverses. And that's not even getting into arguments about what the (extinct) Neanderthals mean with their larger brains.
[1] Metabolically and in other respects; if you doubt this, I've listed what I know about this in http://www.gwern.net/Drug%20heuristics http://www.gwern.net/Drug%20heuristics and especially the footnotes & hyperlinks.
- Cushman 15y ago> and suffered many reverses. I think this is a crucial point. If all of humanity had been wiped out in a famine in Africa fifty thousand years ago, there wouldn't be anyone sitting around today wondering, "Why is it there aren't any civilizations?" And there were probably millenia that went by when the odds of that happening dwarfed the possibility that we might survive long enough to develop a writing system.